Good morning. This morning, we will discuss the Beracha (blessing) on hearts of palm. This item comes from a palm tree. It actually grows out from the center of the bark. While they’re soft, farmers cut them off, and that’s what we eat. If they left this soft growth—the soft hearts of palm—on the tree, after some time they would become hard and would actually become part of the tree. But, like I said, when they cut them off earlier, they’re soft and edible, and that’s what we eat: hearts of palm.
What is the Beracha on such an item? This item is discussed in Masechet Berachot, and the Gemara says that the halacha (Jewish law) is that we make a Shehakol (everything exists through His word) on it. The reason for that is that even though it grows on a tree, the person who planted it planted it for the fruit, like dates. When one cuts the hearts of palm while they’re soft, it’s actually destroying the tree, because now it won’t be able to grow perot (fruit). Therefore, you make a Shehakol on it.
So it seems like an open-and-shut case: you should make a Shehakol on them. However, contemporary producers of hearts of palm actually plant the trees not for the perot, not for the fruit. They have farms just for these hearts of palm, so they grow them for this item that we’re eating. It’s not that they went to a regular palm tree that was grown for dates or some other fruit and took off the hearts of palm, destroying the tree. They actually planted it for that reason. So, according to that, it’s logical that one should say, since it was planted for that intended purpose.
Now, there are those who want to say that maybe we should make a Beracha on it, since it is a tree that grows it from year to year. However, the logic of those who argue is that since you’re not eating actual fruit, you’re actually eating part of the tree, so for that reason, among other reasons, one should make a Beracha on it. So again, even though the Shulchan Aruch in Siman Resh Dalet says that for hearts of palm we should make a Shehakol, today’s hearts of palm in the market are grown specifically for that reason, and therefore it would be proper to say the Beracha of Borei Peri Ha'adamah (Who creates earth’s produce) over them.