Hard Trees, Soft Reeds, and Climbing
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud reads the passage at the bottom of the page: the rule under discussion applies to a hard tree; the text distinguishes soft reeds and says they may not be used.
- The discussion distinguishes climbing up from retrieving an object. If a person climbed up during the day, he may come down whether he climbed intentionally or inadvertently. The dispute is whether he may come down on Shabbat if he climbed up before Shabbat.
- Permission to come down applies to someone who climbed up himself. If he placed an object in the tree before Shabbat, he may not take it from the tree on Shabbat; the concern is that the object makes the tree easy to use.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud then discusses the view that reeds, as vegetation, may be used while attached to the ground. Grass is also included in the general permission, and the Sages did not issue a decree against using grass; this is discussed further in Seif 3.
- A question is raised about leaning on grass and causing it to bend: would that be an inevitable unintended consequence? Rabbi Shimon permits an unintended act when the consequence is not inevitable.
- The authorities nevertheless prohibit using cabbage stalks and pumpkins. These are hard, resemble trees, and eventually harden like wood.
Reeds and Vegetables: Differing Views
- The Shulchan Aruch permits wiping oneself on Shabbat with moist grass attached to the ground, because the prohibition on using attached objects applies to a tree, not to a vegetable.
- The Beit Yosef disagrees with the Rema’s view that reeds and vegetables are permitted, holding that there is no difference between a tree and reeds.
- The discussion clarifies that the question is about using reeds, not walking through a garden. Walking on grass is not treated as using it in this way; the later discussion also states that walking on grass is permitted.
- The Beit Yosef says this stricter view is suggested by the Rambam and Shulchan Aruch, whose wording prohibits using anything attached to the ground. The Bach is also stringent.
- The Eliyah Rabbah challenges that reading and cites several Rishonim who permit using reeds and vegetables. He argues that the Rambam’s wording is not conclusive: it refers to the tree mentioned earlier and does not establish that vegetables are included.
Dry Trees and the Three-Tefachim Measure
- A tree remains prohibited to use even if it is completely dry and has no leaves or branches. The prohibition is about using it, not plucking something from it; a dry tree is treated like a living tree.
- The discussion distinguishes the attached-tree prohibition from muktzeh. A question is raised about sitting on or moving a stump, and about whether one may use muktzeh without moving it; the exchange states that muktzeh may be used as long as it is not moved. A cut-down stump two feet high is mentioned as something one may not move or sit on.
- The discussion then returns to an attached stump: whether dead or alive, if it is three tefachim high, one may not sit on it. Below three tefachim, it is treated like the ground and may be used. The rule for a tree applies at three tefachim; a rock or detached log raises a different question.
- The same height distinction applies to branches: parts three tefachim above the ground are prohibited to use, while parts less than three tefachim high are permitted.
- If branches extend down toward the ground, the height of the part being used matters. A portion three tefachim high is prohibited; a portion below that height is permitted.
- If there is a space of three tefachim beneath the branches, they are prohibited even if another side is level with the ground. The level side is treated as subordinate to the side where the branches are three tefachim high.
Exposed Roots and Branches Near the Ground
- The text discusses visible roots emerging from the ground, such as those of old trees. Rabbi Rachamim Aboud mentions that roots can lift sidewalks, and gives the example of the large carob tree in Peki’in associated with Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai.
- The Gemara says that roots three tefachim high may not be used, even though detaching something is not a concern with roots; the Sages nevertheless issued a decree. Roots less than three tefachim high may be used, because they are treated like the ground. The same applies to branches less than three tefachim high, and, all the more so, to a vegetable below that height.
- A question is raised about a small fruit-bearing tree: perhaps using it below three tefachim should still be prohibited lest someone pluck its fruit. The discussion of roots concerns roots without fruit, and their prohibition is only the general rule about using a tree. The lecture then raises, without resolving, whether an edible vegetable might likewise be prohibited below three tefachim because it could be picked.
- If a root or branch grows from above and extends down, then bends back down after reaching the three-tefachim height, its lower portion may be used. Rabbi Rachamim Aboud clarifies that this lower portion is like the base of a tree below three tefachim; it was never prohibited, even though the upper portion is.
- Where branches extend sideways from a tree, their height is measured from the ground below them. If the ground is higher on one side, the rule is determined by the other sides: when only one side is level with the ground and the branches are three tefachim high on the other three sides, the level side is treated as subordinate to those sides. If two sides are level with the ground, those sides may be used.
Walking on Grass and Liquids in a Garden
- One may walk on grass, whether moist or dry, because one does not intend to pluck it.
- One may not wash hands over grass while eating in a garden. The water waters the grass, which is like planting, and softens the ground, which is like plowing. Although these effects are unintended, they are inevitable and therefore prohibited.
- Urinating on grass, or pouring other liquids that do not cause it to grow, is permitted. Spitting on grass is also discussed as something that does not cause growth.
- Rabbi Rachamim Aboud concludes that it is good to be stringent and avoid eating in gardens when water might be used there, and to take care not to spill water on the grass.

