I can reveal a flaw. Good morning again. Yes, it is Tuesday. It is Torah Tuesday. It’s 1145. We’re at the point where we discuss for just a few minutes the important halachot (Jewish laws) and the behavior patterns having to do with proper speech.
If you would go to Klal Bet (the second chapter), you'll find a very interesting, quite interesting subject that happens all the time. If you heard a speech, went to a class or a lecture, and did an exit poll, how was the class? How was the speech? Or if you missed something, there’s a special speaker invited to your particular place of learning or synagogue, and you didn’t go. And so you asked, “So how was he? How was he? How was the talk?” Maybe he’s famous. We know he’s good. But how was he? There’s a likely chance that if a famous person was invited to come speak, or if somebody on the circuit, as they say, came to speak, there would likely be many, many positive comments. “Wow, it was awesome. Wow, it was great. I like his style. His delivery is unbelievable.” But like in any crowd, there’s a likely chance of some negativity. And the criticism may range from, “Well, you know, he thinks he’s funny, but I don’t go for his jokes,” to “Or he tries to, to everybody who says and take a stand on anything.” Or maybe it was boring.
Chafetz Chaim says that when leaving a lecture, especially a Torah lecture, we have to realize a very important principle. Each person in an audience, each recipient of the delivery of the speaker, hears it from their own vantage point. There may be people who are very knowledgeable, and they may say the lecture wasn’t deep enough. While there are those who may not have much background and, on the same speech, on the same night, to the same crowd, say, “It’s too complicated, too deep. I didn’t understand.” Basically, what I’m telling you is, the opinions are subjective, not objective. Every complaint a person might have may be something somebody else came specifically to hear. The fact that a member of the audience did not enjoy it, was not inspired by it, or did not understand it does not in any way, shape, manner, or form mean it wasn’t good. It just means it didn’t suit that person’s taste or level.
The Chafetz Chaim goes to great lengths because he’s aware of the fact—and he says it—that people criticize lectures. People give their opinions and evaluations of a speaker’s style, knowledge, delivery, and many things that are said may, in some way, shape or form, affect his reputation or his future ability to be hired somewhere else. That’s damaging speech. That’s Lashon Hara (damaging speech). The Halacha (Jewish law) identifies a particular nature that comes along with being human. It’s the human psyche, we call it. If I listen to a lecture and my friend belittles it, denigrates it, criticizes it, then even if I enjoyed it, my respect for the speaker or my enjoyment during the lecture, in the long run, will be reduced and denigrated. I’ll think less of what I heard and less of the person who delivered it. You might say, “That’s how he felt.” You might say initially, “He’s just telling you what he thought.” But if it influences somebody else’s opinion, or damages the future reputation or finances of that speaker, that’s Lashon Hara.
Now, by the way, don’t get me wrong: everyone’s entitled to their opinion. It’s democratic. Not lately in our country. And the Chafetz Chaim is not saying you’re forbidden to have an opinion, or that you have to enjoy every speaker’s Dvar Torah (Torah teaching). He’s not looking for robots. He’s not looking for imbeciles. What he is saying is, we’re not allowed to verbalize negative opinions. The only time you can, as we’ve learned in this class of the many years we’ve been having it, is l'to'elet: to protect the person listening, to warn my companion, to help somebody else out. Then I can speak negatively. But again, the laws of to'elet, of constructive—and it is, but it’s constructive—it has seven prerequisites, which are pretty hard to fulfill. It’s very common with speakers, shiduchim (matchmaking), jobs, classes, shuls (synagogues), everyday stuff. We have to be careful not to violate the laws of proper speech.

