A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Torah Lecture

Mishna Berura Siman 183 Seif 8 + Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 45

Lectured by Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Published
December 17, 2023
Duration
65:42
Lecture code
RSC-978

Mishna Berura, Siman 183: Interruptions and Posture During Birkat Hamazon

Seif 8: Asking and answering

  • Maran cites the Orchot Chayim, which says that asking or answering during birkat hamazon is like doing so during Keri'at Shema: one may respond to someone out of respect, as in the rule of sho'alin mipnei hakavod.
  • Although this practice of greeting someone during birkat hamazon is not generally relevant today, Rabbi Shmuel Choueka says the underlying question applies to answering yehei shemeh rabba mevarach, amen, or Barechu.
  • The Mishnah Berurah rules that birkat hamazon is like the Amidah: one should neither ask nor answer at all. Its explanation is that the Sages required birkat hamazon to be recited in one place, unlike Keri'at Shema, which may be recited while walking after its opening verse. Rabbi Shmuel Choueka says he is unsure whether the reason is that birkat hamazon is de'oraita, and notes that this is not the Mishnah Berurah’s explanation.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka says that his community does not answer amen during birkat hamazon, because it is treated entirely like the Amidah. Ashkenazim do answer amen after “Baruch Attah Hashem hazan et hakol”: they regard that amen as belonging to the blessing being recited, rather than as an interruption to answer something else.
  • The Ben Ish Chai says that one should put the feet together during birkat hamazon, as during the Amidah, to show its importance. Rabbi Shmuel Choueka also says one should wear a hat and jacket, as for the Amidah.

Seif 9: Sitting and conducting oneself with awe

  • Birkat hamazon should be recited sitting, even if the person ate while walking, standing, or reclining in the house. Sitting allows greater concentration.
  • One should not recline during birkat hamazon, because reclining is a manner of ga'avah; one should sit be'eimah, with awe.
  • The gloss says that this applies not only to the person reciting the blessing: all the people who are listening and fulfilling their obligation through him should sit with awe, as though they were reciting it themselves.
  • If someone recited birkat hamazon while walking in the house where he ate, he fulfilled his obligation bedi'avad, though he should not do so lechatchilah.
  • The Mishnah Berurah says that one must sit even for the fourth berachah, although it is miderabanan, so as not to treat it disrespectfully.
  • This discussion concerns someone walking in his house. If he leaves the place where he ate and blesses elsewhere, there are differing opinions, discussed in the next siman.

Seif 10: Birkat me'ein shalosh

  • Some say birkat me'ein shalosh, including al hamichyah after eating cake or cookies, must also be recited while sitting.
  • The Bi'ur HaGra connects this ruling to the discussion in siman kuf-peh-dalet, and the Rambam follows his approach there.
  • For the five kinds of grain, the lecture says that everyone agrees the after-blessing must be recited while seated. Whether the same rule applies to the other after-blessings, such as ha'etz, al peirot, and al hagefen, is disputed.

Seif 11: Eating while traveling

  • Someone who was walking on the road and eating may recite birkat hamazon while walking. Sitting would make him anxious about delaying his journey and would interfere with his concentration.
  • This differs from someone who ate in the house: there, he can sit when it is time to bless. A traveler who ate while walking has a reason not to stop.
  • The Chayei Adam limits this leniency to someone who ate while traveling. Someone who stopped and ate sitting down, such as at a rest stop, should recite birkat hamazon sitting where he ate, rather than resume walking to bless.

Seif 12: Not blessing while occupied with work

  • It is forbidden to bless while occupied with one’s work; the Mishnah Berurah says this applies to all berachot, not only birkat hamazon.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka gives the example of someone clearing the table or putting things away while reciting birkat hamazon, and says one should put the work aside and concentrate.

Siman 184: Reciting Birkat Hamazon in the Place of the Meal

Leaving before blessing

  • One who ate in one place should recite birkat hamazon before leaving.
  • According to the Rambam, if someone left intentionally without blessing, he must return to his place. If he blessed where he remembered, he fulfilled his obligation bedi'avad.
  • The Rema cites the Rosh, who holds that even someone who left unintentionally should ideally return to his place; if he left intentionally, blessing elsewhere does not fulfill his obligation even bedi'avad. Rabenu Yonah agrees with the Rosh that one who left unintentionally must return.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka illustrates the unintentional case with someone who ate at a barbecue, then went to shul for Minchah and realized there that he had washed and needed to say birkat hamazon. According to the Rambam, he can bless where he is; according to Rabenu Yonah and the Rosh, he must return to where he ate.

What counts as the same place

  • Moving from one corner of a room or house to another is permitted, even in a large house and even if the person can no longer see his original place. A partition blocking the view does not change this.
  • If something prevents him from blessing in the room where he ate, he may bless in an adjacent room if he can see the place where he ate.
  • The Mishnah Berurah suggests that, under pressing circumstances, one may be lenient if, when saying hamotzi, he intended to bless in another room in the same house—even if he cannot see the original place.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka recounts a case on Erev Pesach that fell on Shabbat: a woman said hamotzi over pita in a room attached to the house, to keep chametz out of the main dining room, then moved there for food that was kasher lePesach. He advised that, under the sha'at ha-dechak, she could rely on the ruling for someone who intended at hamotzi to bless in the other room. He says no new berachah was required.
  • All four amot from the place where one ate count as the same place. A minor impediment—such as someone occupying one’s seat or the spot being dirty—can justify moving within that area to bless.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka clarifies that the case he discussed involved an attached room; he does not extend the ruling to a detached house.
  • He raises, but leaves unresolved, the case of someone who began eating bread in a sukkah and then has to move indoors because it starts raining.

Bava Kama, Daf 45

An ox sentenced to be stoned

  • The Mishnah discusses an ox that gored someone to death and was on its way to be stoned. The owner cannot avoid the sentence by consecrating it after the judgment: the consecration does not take effect, and if it is slaughtered, its meat is asur behana'ah.
  • If the owner consecrated or slaughtered it before its judgment was concluded, the consecration takes effect and its meat is permitted.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka responds to the apparent cruelty of stoning the ox by comparing it to a surgeon amputating a leg or a mohel performing a berit milah. An observer may not understand the act, but it can be required; likewise, people do not understand everything Hashem commands.

Custodians and return of an ox

  • The Mishnah lists four shomrim: shomer chinam, who receives no payment and is liable only for peshi'ah; shomer sachar, who is liable for theft or loss; socher, whose status is disputed; and sho'el, who has the greatest responsibility because he uses the borrowed item and is liable even if it dies on its own.
  • When an ox is entrusted to a shomer, the shomer enters in place of the owner for relevant liabilities: a mu'ad pays nezek shalem and a tam pays chatzi nezek. If the ox is sentenced to death, a shomer may also have to pay the owner for the loss of the ox, in addition to other liability.
  • A baraita says that before judgment is concluded, the ox can be sold, consecrated, slaughtered, or returned to its owner. After judgment, the Sages say it cannot be sold or consecrated, its slaughtered meat is forbidden, and its return is invalid. Rabbi Ya'akov says that returning it is valid even after judgment.
  • The Gemara considers whether their dispute is about returning something asur behana'ah with the claim harei shelcha lefanecha. Rabbah rejects that explanation: everyone accepts that such a return can be valid, as shown by a thief who stole chametz before Pesach and returned it after Pesach, when it was already asur behana'ah.
  • The Gemara instead says the dispute concerns whether the ox must be present when its judgment is concluded. The Sages require it to be present, comparing the ox’s sentence to the owner’s sentence: just as the owner is judged in his presence, so must the ox be. They say that returning it after judgment is not a valid return because the owner lost the opportunity to hide it before the court ruled.
  • Rabbi Ya'akov holds that the ox need not be present: the court would reach its judgment anyway, and an ox cannot make a claim or defend itself.

The shomrim’s liability and levels of guarding

  • A further baraita says that when a shomer’s ox kills someone, a tam is stoned and the shomrim are exempt from kofer; a mu'ad is stoned and the responsible shomer pays kofer and must also reimburse the owner for the ox, except for a shomer chinam.
  • The Gemara asks how the baraita can exempt the shomer chinam alone. If the ox was guarded adequately, all the shomrim should be exempt; if it was not guarded, even the shomer chinam should be liable.
  • The answer invokes two levels of guarding: shemirah pechutah, ordinary guarding such as locking an ox in a barn in the usual way, and shemirah me'ulah, extra-strong guarding. Rabbi Shmuel Choueka emphasizes that shemirah pechutah does not mean negligent or unacceptable care; it means ordinary care. He compares the stronger level to protection designed to withstand an extreme event such as a hurricane, rather than normal wind.
  • The Gemara examines which authority could explain the baraita. Rabbi Meir holds that a mu'ad needs shemirah me'ulah, but if so, the status of a socher matters because Rabbi Meir’s view of a socher could require exempting it along with the shomer chinam. Rabbi Yehudah holds that a mu'ad needs only shemirah pechutah, which would create a different problem with the baraita’s distinction.
  • Rav Huna bar Chinena says the baraita follows Rabbi Eliezer, who holds ein lo shemirah ela sakin: the only adequate protection for a mu'ad is to slaughter it. The socher follows Rabbi Yehudah’s view that a socher is like a shomer sachar, leaving only the shomer chinam exempt.
  • Abaye says the baraita can follow Rabbi Meir: the shomrim are liable because ordinary guarding is insufficient for a mu'ad, while the shomer chinam is exempt.
  • The Gemara resolves the issue of the socher by citing a version of a baraita transmitted by Rabbah bar Avuha: Rabbi Meir considers a socher like a shomer sachar, while Rabbi Yehudah considers it like a shomer chinam. On that version, the baraita’s distinction is consistent with Rabbi Meir.

A shomer chinam who accepts responsibility for a goring ox

  • Rabbi Elazar says that if an ox was given to a shomer chinam, “hizik chayav, huzak patur”: if it caused damage, the shomer is liable; if the ox itself was damaged, the shomer is exempt from reimbursing its owner.
  • The Gemara asks how this distinction works. If the shomer accepted responsibility for the ox’s damaging others, why did he not also accept responsibility for damage to the ox? If he accepted neither responsibility, why is he liable when it causes harm?
  • Rava answers that the shomer accepted responsibility for the ox’s damages and knew it was a gorer. He accepted that it should not go and harm others, but did not accept responsibility for someone else coming and damaging the ox.

How much guarding a tam and a mu'ad require

  • The Mishnah says that an owner who tied an ox with a rein or locked it properly in the ordinary way is liable if it escapes and causes damage. Rabbi Meir says this applies to both a tam and a mu'ad; Rabbi Yehudah says a tam is liable but a mu'ad is exempt.
  • Rabbi Meir holds that both require shemirah me'ulah. The Gemara explains that ordinary oxen are not presumed to be guarded. A tam’s liability teaches that at least shemirah pechutah is required; the verse about a mu'ad, “velo yishmerennu,” requires stronger guarding. A gezerah shavah from negichah then applies the mu'ad’s higher level to a tam as well.
  • Rabbi Yehudah holds that ordinary oxen are presumed to have ordinary guarding. Since a tam still incurs liability, it must require shemirah me'ulah. The repeated language concerning the mu'ad is treated as ribui achar ribui, which reduces the requirement: a mu'ad needs only shemirah pechutah. The discussion then applies the relevant level between tam and mu'ad through negichah.
  • Rabbi Elazar ben Yaakov says that both a tam and a mu'ad are exempt if guarded with shemirah pechutah. He follows the view that the mu'ad’s lesser guarding requirement is applied to the tam through negichah.
  • Rav Ada bar Ahavah explains Rabbi Yehudah’s position by saying that the tzad tamut remains in place when an ox becomes a mu'ad. The mu'ad’s additional aspect may need only shemirah pechutah, but its tam aspect still requires shemirah me'ulah. Thus the owner is not better off when the ox becomes a mu'ad: the tam portion remains liable for the half-damages it would have incurred as a tam.
  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka also explains that once an ox is publicly known to be a mu'ad, people can keep their distance; nevertheless, an ox may still be needed for work. On this account, Rabbi Yehudah’s lesser guarding applies to the mu'ad portion, while the tam portion retains its stricter requirement.

A mu'ad for one horn

  • Rav says that an ox that is mu'ad for its right horn is not thereby mu'ad for its left horn. If it gored three times with the right horn and then gored with the left, the left-horn goring is still treated as tam. Rabbi Shmuel Choueka illustrates this with an ox that sees and gores on one side.
  • The Gemara asks how this fits Rabbi Meir or Rabbi Yehudah. Under Rabbi Meir, either horn requires shemirah me'ulah. Under Rabbi Yehudah, if the right horn already contains a tam and a mu'ad aspect, the same tam portion seems to remain relevant, raising the question of what Rav’s ruling adds.
  • The Gemara answers that Rav follows Rabbi Yehudah but does not accept Rav Ada bar Ahavah’s explanation. In this case, the right horn has a tam aspect alongside its mu'ad status, while the left horn remains tam. This is the case in which tam and mu'ad aspects coexist within one ox.
  • The Gemara distinguishes this from an ox that is fully mu'ad for both horns. In that case, it treats the mu'ad as a new entity without a remaining tam portion; there is no half-damages liability for a tam aspect. Proper guarding as a mu'ad can therefore exempt the owner.
Words in this lecture4
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras
Kosherכשרות
Terms Kosher, fit to eat or use according to halacha.
Also written: k'sherah
Plural: kesherot, K'sherot, kesherim, ksherim, kesheirim, kasherim, b'kesherim, haksherim
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem
Shasהש"ס
Terms The whole Talmud (from the initials of the six orders).
Also written: HaShas, Ha-Shas