A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Torah Lecture

Mishna Berura Siman 216 Seif 10+ Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 46

Lectured by Rabbi Shmuel Choueka

Published
April 14, 2024
Duration
51:57
Lecture code
RSC-2569

Berachot on Besamim

Separate blessings and intent

  • Rabbi Shmuel Choueka begins with the case in Siman Reish Zayin, se'if yud: someone has atzei besamim, asvei besamim, and minei besamim before him and wants to smell all of them. He makes a separate Beracha for each; one Beracha does not exempt the others.
  • If he wants to smell only one kind, he smells and blesses only that one. If the fragrances are mixed together and cannot be separated, he should separate a sample and identify it for an individual Beracha if possible; if he cannot, he can say borei minei besamim for the mixture.
  • The Mishnah Berura explains that the case is one in which he intends to smell all the fragrances. The discussion also distinguishes whether he intended a Beracha to cover the other kinds: some say that a Beracha covers them only if he had them in mind. The lecture compares this to the question of whether shehakol covers other foods when they were not intended.
  • The lecture recalls se'if bet, which discusses someone who mistakenly said borei minei besamim over something whose Beracha is borei atzei besamim. It also notes the principle that a specific Beracha does not exempt the general category.

Which fragrance to bless first

  • As with ha'adamah and ha'etz, the preferred item is given precedence. If neither is preferred, the lecture says to try to bless ha'etz first, since it is considered somewhat more special than ha'adamah.
  • In the case of hadass, which is atzei besamim, and fragrant shemen, the order depends on what gives the oil its smell. If the oil is being used only to clean the hands, no Beracha is made, because smelling it is not its purpose; here, the oil is brought to be smelled.
  • Maran’s preference for hadass first is explained by its intrinsic fragrance: hadass itself smells good, while the shemen may be scentless on its own and derive its fragrance from ingredients added to it.
  • The lecture raises the case of peppermint added to oil: its Beracha might be borei asvei or a distinct Beracha for shemen ha-parsimon. One cannot say the Beracha for hadass and thereby cover a different kind of fragrance. The item receiving the Beracha should be held in the right hand.
  • A question is raised about whether shemen ha-parsimon should precede hadass because it has its own fragrance and Beracha. The answer given in the lecture is that hadass is itself a fragrant plant, whereas the oil’s fragrance may depend on what has been added to it.

Mugmar and other pleasant smells

  • A Beracha is made over mugmar (incense) when its smoke rises and reaches the air. One should say the Beracha before smelling it, but not before the smoke has begun to rise.
  • If the mugmar is burned only to remove a bad smell, no Beracha is made; the Beracha applies when it is intended for enjoyment. A person close enough for the fragrance to be reaching him may still make the Beracha, but not while the incense is still unlit or too far away. The lecture compares this to not making a Beracha on tefillin while they are still in their bag.
  • The lecture discusses things that may smell pleasant but are not ordinarily besamim, such as shalak and cigars, and says that a Beracha is not made on them. Fresh bread is also given as an example: smelling it while passing a bakery does not call for a Beracha.
  • A question is raised about whether burning mugmar changes its identity as besamim. The answer is that the burning releases the fragrance already inherent in it; it does not lose its identity.
  • The practical advice given is to avoid deliberately smelling hot bread or other pleasant food aromas when no Beracha is made. Someone passing a bakery should try to ignore the smell and not intend to smell it. When food is cooking on Friday and its aroma is noticed, one can thank Hashem without making a deliberate episode of smelling it.

Bava Metzia 46: Coins, chalipin, and redemption of maaser

Whether coins can be used for chalipin

  • The lecture turns to the last two lines of the previous page and reviews the question of whether a coin can be used for chalipin. Chalipin is an exchange of items, not simply a trade based on the coin’s monetary value.
  • One view says a coin cannot be used to effect chalipin because the transaction concerns the coin as currency, not its silver content. If the face on the coin is removed or becomes unacceptable, it may cease to function as currency.
  • The lecture distinguishes using a coin to acquire something through chalipin from acquiring a coin through chalipin. It compares the latter to fruit: fruit cannot be used to acquire an item in chalipin, but fruit itself can be acquired by giving a handkerchief.
  • The discussion of redeeming fruits at the threshing floor concerns the additional fifth required when someone redeems his own produce with his own money. If another person redeems it, the extra fifth is not required, so people sought to have someone else redeem their produce.
  • If the owner has money with him, he can give it to another person to acquire and use for the redemption. If he has no money there, he may give the fruits to that person as a gift so that the other person redeems them as his own; the fruits can then be returned.
  • The lecture describes giving the other person a handkerchief to acquire money that is elsewhere, or using agav by transferring a small amount of land and thereby acquiring the money. The case is one in which the person has no handkerchief or land available, and the threshing floor belongs to someone else.
  • The Mishnah’s unusually difficult case—described as a person with nothing—teaches that coins cannot be acquired through chalipin either. The lecture says this is evidence for both sides of the coin question: a coin cannot effect chalipin, and cannot itself be acquired through it.
  • Rav Papa had previously said that a coin could be acquired through chalipin, but later changed his mind. He had 12,000 dinars deposited in Bei Hozai and arranged for Shmuel bar Acha to acquire them through the threshold of his house, using a kinyan on the land rather than transferring the coins directly through chalipin.
  • The person sent to retrieve the money could then collect it as his own. Rav Papa later went as far as Tabakh to meet him and show his appreciation. The lecture recalls that Rav Papa had once been very poor and later became wealthy as a beer merchant.
  • Ulla’s position is that a coin cannot effect chalipin. The lecture then considers whether another case involving copper coins contradicts that position.

Copper coins, workers’ wages, and interest

  • In the case discussed, workers are owed wages and meals, but their employer does not have money with him. He asks a money changer to give him copper coins to pay them, promising to repay with a dinar and a smaller coin from money he has at home.
  • The question is whether the extra amount is interest. The lecture distinguishes money that the employer has but cannot presently access—for example, money locked away or at a distant location—from money he does not have. If he has the money at home but cannot get to it, the lecture treats it as available; if he does not have the money, the arrangement is a loan with an extra payment and is forbidden.
  • A challenge is raised: if a coin cannot be used for chalipin, perhaps taking the copper coins does not transfer ownership of the money at home, and the employer is simply borrowing at a premium.
  • One answer considered is that the copper pieces may be unminted slugs, valued for their metal rather than functioning as coins. Such items could be treated like other movable goods for chalipin. Ulla is initially silent; Rabbi Abba suggests this explanation, and the wording of the baraita is discussed in support of it.
  • The lecture distinguishes “yafe dinar,” meaning something worth a dinar, from “dinar yafe,” meaning a good coin. It says the wording may indicate a different denomination or unminted copper pieces rather than ordinary currency.
  • Rav Ashi’s answer, as presented in the lecture, is that there is no chalipin in the case: the money changer is lending the coins, while the employer already has the funds at home. Since the extra payment is not for waiting for money the employer lacks, it is not agra natar (payment for waiting). The extra can be for the service; if the employer has no money at home, the arrangement is forbidden.
  • The lecture cautions against judging such a transaction from appearances alone. Someone unfamiliar with the halacha should ask a Rabbi rather than assume that a payment is interest.

Movable goods, debt cancellation, and meshicha

  • The lecture next examines the statement that an item used as payment can make a transaction take effect once the other party takes possession. It asks whether this proves that coins can serve as chalipin.
  • It discusses the wording in the Mishnah in Kiddushin, including “na'aseh damim ba'acher,” and the examples of chalipin: shor b'parah and chamor b'shor. These examples involve exchanging one animal for another, not simply money.
  • A case is described in which a buyer has already taken an ox through meshicha and owes 100 dinar. He offers a cow worth 100 instead, and the seller agrees to waive the debt. The waiver finalizes the exchange even though the cow has not yet been taken into the seller’s possession; if something then happens to the cow, the loss is the seller’s.
  • The lecture explains the case as an unusual arrangement: an item has been sold and taken, a debt is owed, and the parties settle that debt by exchanging another item. It contrasts this with the usual sale of a movable item, where the Rabbis required meshicha.
  • Rabbi Yochanan’s view is presented as: ma'ot konot—the Torah recognizes money as acquiring. The Rabbis nevertheless required meshicha in ordinary cases, lest a seller who has already received payment fail to protect the goods, as in the example of wheat that burns in the seller’s attic.
  • The lecture says the Rabbis made this decree for a common situation. The unusual case of waiving a debt for another item is distinguished from an ordinary money payment.
  • The opposing approach holds that meshicha is required by Torah law, not merely by rabbinic enactment. Under that view, the debt-waiver case must be explained through chalipin; the lecture connects this possibility to the view that movable goods or perot can serve as chalipin.
  • This discussion is set against Rav Nachman’s position that chalipin requires a keli, while the alternative associated with Reish Lakish allows other movable goods, including perot, to be used.

The Mishnah’s purse of coins

  • The lecture brings a Mishnah stating that movable property can be acquired one from another, even a purse full of coins exchanged for another purse full of coins. Reish Lakish says the rule applies even to kis malei, a full purse.
  • The Gemara’s explanation, as presented in the lecture, is that the coins in question are not functioning as ordinary currency: one kind has been withdrawn by the government, while another is rejected locally though accepted in other regions. The lecture also refers to coins that are unusable locally during the period of the 15th of the year.
  • Since these coins are treated as disqualified or used in an unusual way, they are treated as perot rather than ordinary currency; that is why one purse can acquire the other.
  • The lecture notes the difficulty in the distinction: if the government has disqualified a coin, one might expect it not to circulate at all; if only one region rejects it, it remains usable elsewhere. The discussion ends with the conclusion that these are not ordinary coins functioning as currency, and the sugya on the page concludes.