A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H

Torah Lecture

Berachot 19; Daily Lesson From The Daf - The Nature Of A Torah Scholar

Lectured by Rabbi Yaacov Laredo

Published
January 27, 2020
Duration
5:31
Lecture code
RYL-DAF18

The Gemara on a Torah Scholar Who Sinned

  • The Gemara teaches that if someone sees a Talmid Chacham (Torah scholar) sin at night, they should not think ill of him the next morning: perhaps he has already repented; indeed, the Gemara says one can be sure he has repented.
  • This certainty applies to sins between a person and Hashem. For a transgression against another person—such as damaging or taking something—one can be sure the matter has been addressed only once the person has made amends, repaired the damage, or returned what was taken.

Why a Torah Scholar Is Called a Talmid Chacham

  • Talmid means “student,” and Chacham means “wise.” Rabbi Yaacov Laredo asks why Torah scholars are called “wise students” rather than wise teachers or professors.
  • A Torah scholar recognizes that there is always more to learn and remains a student throughout life. Because the Torah is endless, a Talmid Chacham spends a lifetime learning Torah.
  • Rabbi Yaacov Laredo explains that such a person looks for opportunities to learn, including learning from a mistake and repenting at the earliest opportunity. We should likewise seek opportunities to learn, grow, and repent from our shortcomings.

Repentance Between a Person and Hashem, and Between People

  • The Gemara’s assurance of repentance applies to sins between a person and Hashem, such as speaking Lashon Hara (evil speech), being insufficiently diligent in prayer or other obligations, lacking concentration in prayer, or failing in kashrut (kosher dietary laws).
  • For an obligation or transgression between a person and their fellow, we should not assume the matter has been repaired; we need to know that it has.
  • Rabbi Yaacov Laredo connects this distinction to the period before Rosh Hashanah (Jewish New Year) and Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement): repentance between a person and Hashem is between them and Hashem, but when another person is involved, we must also make things right with that person.
  • If we took or damaged someone’s property, or hurt someone’s feelings, we must repent to Hashem and also make things right with the person affected.
  • As people striving to learn, become great, and do what is right, we should do as much as we can not to hurt others; if we do, we should return to them, apologize, and make things right.
Words in this lecture1
Kosherכשרות
Terms Kosher, fit to eat or use according to halacha.
Also written: k'sherah
Plural: kesherot, K'sherot, kesherim, ksherim, kesheirim, kasherim, b'kesherim, haksherim