Today, the Talmud speaks to us about two very special rabbis who would specifically sit by the door of the women’s mikveh (ritual bath). Sounds odd? Well, the truth is, the Talmud also finds it odd. First, Rav Gidal would be sitting there, and the rabbis would come and ask him, “What are you doing over there? Why are you sitting at the doorway of the women’s mikveh? That’s not proper.” He answered, “Well, I’m there to answer their questions if they have any questions that come up with their dipping.” They said, “And what? Are you not worried that maybe your Yetzer Hara, your evil inclination, might grow on you and you might come to sin?” He said, “No. They all seem to me like white geese.” This alludes to the fact that he was on such a high level that he just did not give in to his Yetzer Hara. And again, don’t try this at home. He was at that very high level.
The next rabbi, Rabbi Yochanan, whom the Talmud elsewhere says was the most handsome man of his day, was even mistaken by a bandit, Reish Lakish, to be so beautiful that was a woman. Reish Lakish jumped tremendous bounds to try to jump him and be with him, until Rabbi Yochanan said, “No, I’m a man. But if you do teshuva, if you come back and you leave your horrible ways, and become a Talmid Chacham (Torah scholar), well, then I’ll give you my sister, who’s even more beautiful.” Regardless, Rabbi Yochanan was very beautiful. He also used to sit by the door of the women’s mikveh. He would do so so that when the women came out, they would see him and look at his beauty. Through that, they would also have beautiful children.
Again, the rabbis came to him and said, “Well, are you not worried about Ayin Hara, the wicked eye, the evil eye? Because the women are looking at you and how beautiful you are, don’t you think that it may bring upon you some bad omen, some bad energy?” His answer was as follows: “No, I am not worried about Ayin Hara, as the Talmud puts it, as Ayin Bisha, which is a translation for Ayin Hara, evil eye, because I am a descendant of Yosef HaTzadik, to whom the Ayin Hara has no strength and cannot cause any damage at all.”
So there are three different interpretations of why Yosef and the descendants of Yosef, and better yet, those who follow in the paths of Yosef HaTzadik, have no issue with Ayin Hara. This is how we can make it applicable to us. The Talmud gives these three different interpretations, and we’re going to apply them to us now.
The first is because the Pasuk (verse) says about Yosef that he was, as the interpretation of the Gemara says, above the eye. When he and his family, including his father Yaakov, came to meet Esav after many, many years of not seeing him—34 years, to be exact—Yosef HaTzadik stood in front of his mother, Rachel, and stood up nice and tall so that Esav could not look at her and maybe, Chas VeShalom (God forbid), hurt her or wish her any bad things. So Yosef was blessed by his father as someone who stood very strong in front of his mother. He was above the eye. Through the merit of standing in front and blocking his mother from Esav, he was blessed that he would always be above the eye.
As Rabbi Dessler explains, this means that he had Ayin Tov, he had a good eye. When one, like Yosef, has a good eye on others, looks at them, and is happy for them, he also has a good eye on others. And when one, like Yosef, has a good eye on other people, the Ayin Hara of others can have no effect on them. That’s the first interpretation.
The second interpretation that the Gemara uses is based on the blessing that Yaakov gives Yosef and his children, that they should be like fish. As the Talmud says, fish are samui min ha'ayin, fish are hidden from the eye, because they live and breed under sea level, meaning under ocean level, and are not able to be seen by others. Because they cannot be seen, the Ayin Hara of others is not seen by others. And because they cannot be seen, the Ayin Hara has no power over them. So a person who is tzanua, who is dignified and private in life, also has a tremendous amount of blessing. This teaches us that if we want no Ayin Hara in us, we should be as private and as dignified, and not loud and flamboyant, as possible. That would be the greatest thing for us.
The third interpretation is that, in the same way that Yosef did not allow himself or his eye to benefit and nourish itself from something that was prohibited to him, i.e., the wife of Potiphar, that’s how he was given the tremendous amount of power that the Ayin Hara cannot attack him. So too, if we guard our eyes and don’t look where we’re not supposed to, the Ayin Hara will have absolutely no power over us.
So let us take a lesson from this: Ayin Hara is a real thing. The power of the eye—the power of others, whether good or evil, wishing upon us—does have power. The way to overcome it is through these three ways, Rabbi Dessler says. Number one: a person should always be above the eye, meaning they should always give power only to the good eye. How do we do that? By looking at others and being happy for them with what they have. Second is being dignified and private as much as possible. And the third is to guard our eyes, to look at and benefit only from what is permitted to us.