Yesterday, the Talmud mentioned the dispute among the Talmudic sages over whether there are three sections of the evening, each consisting of four hours, or four sections of the evening, each consisting of three hours. In that discussion, King David is brought up, and we hear how he knew exactly when midnight was. He would doze from the beginning of the night until then, and at that point he would get up like a lion and continue to study Torah, praise God, sing to God, and prepare for his day.
Yesterday, the Talmud asked: How is it possible that David knew exactly when midnight was if Moses himself, Moshe Rabbeinu (Moses our teacher), did not know? How did Moshe not know? When Moses comes to Paro and tells him, “Tomorrow, your firstborn is going to pass,” he says, “Around the time of midnight, tomorrow is going to be the time when God himself is going to come and slay all the firstborns.” So how could Moses say “around the time of midnight”?
The Talmud answers that King David had a special commodity that Moses did not have. According to this answer, Moses was somewhat doubtful. He didn’t know exactly when it was. However, King David knew precisely when it was going to be because he had a very special harp, which hung over his desk—or bed, however you want to learn it.
Today, on page four, we bring up this discussion again: How did David know, and Moses not know? Really, according to Rebbe Zeira on today’s page, both David and Moses knew exactly when midnight was. The reason David needed this harp was that it would wake him up as an alarm clock. He was dozing off and needed to know when to stop dozing off and take the rest of the evening.
More seriously, Moses also knew exactly when midnight was. He had no doubt, again, because God had no doubt about when it would be. Rather, the only reason he told Pharaoh “around the time of midnight” was in order that Pharaoh’s stargazers would not make any mistake in their miscalculation. They shouldn’t make a mistake and then come back and say, “You know what? The firstborns died, like you said. But it wasn’t exactly to the minute or to the moment of midnight. So therefore, we’re not believing in you, and everything is false.”
The Talmud quotes a very, very special line from Masechet Derech Eretz Zuta, from the third chapter: “A person should teach themselves to say, ‘I do not know.’” Again, a person should always teach themselves to be comfortable saying, “I do not know.” The reason for this is that a person saves themselves from trapping themselves in deceit, from entangling themselves in a web of deceit. This is what the Talmud tells us today.
It’s a very mature thing for a person to admit and say they do not know. It’s something smart. Saying that you aren’t confident about something is much better than saying something that will come back to haunt you. Anything you say, in essence, you will always have to provide an answer for. But anything you have not said, you own.
In the world that we live in, although it might seem embarrassing not to know something—you might look uneducated—the Torah’s view is completely opposite. There’s actually a tremendous amount of respect for one who says, “I don’t know.” There’s nothing wrong with saying, “I don’t know,” or, even better, telling someone, “Let me get back to you on that.” Then, when you do follow up with an educated answer, with a strong, solid answer, that makes you look much greater and strengthens other people’s confidence in you.
The Talmud later, here on page 4, discusses King David’s merit: He was a very pious and altruistic individual, to the point that he never gave a definitive answer or decree until he consulted with his very own rabbi, forgoing his royal dignity. His rabbi’s name was Ish-Boshet, and David referred to him as Mefiboshet. This means that David would be embarrassed in matters of Jewish law by being corrected by his own rabbi in public. Meaning, David was admitting—King David himself was admitting—to his own errors. David was rewarded with a genius of a descendant who was even wiser than Mefiboshet himself.
So again, today’s lesson is: Do not be scared of saying, “I don’t know.” It actually makes us greater and wiser, much better than giving an invalid or mistaken answer.
