A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Torah Lecture

Are You Allowed To Put Flowers Back in the Vase on Shabbat? What About NaNa Leaves?

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Published
October 29, 2024
Duration
4:36
Lecture code
RYR-180

Zore’a on Shabbat

  • Zore’a is one of the 39 melachot and means planting. It is forbidden min haTorah to put a seed or plant in the ground—or otherwise begin an act intended to make it grow—even if it will take days, weeks, or months to take root and grow.

Flowers in a Vase

  • The question addressed is whether one may move a vase of flowers on Shabbat, or take the flowers out and put them back in the water.
  • Maran Chacham Ovadia Yosef, based on the Shulchan Aruch, Siman Shin Lamed Vav (336), rules that flowers such as roses may be taken out of the water and returned to it. The vase may also be moved; it is not muktzeh.
  • Flowers are already fully grown, so returning them to water is not considered zore’a. Even if a rose is somewhat closed and its leaves or petals might open further, that is not considered growth or planting.
  • The Rema and Ashkenazim rule that flowers may not be taken out of the water and returned, because they might open further and this appears like zore’a. However, they permit moving the vase or cup of water; it is not muktzeh. Thus, returning flowers to water is asur according to Ashkenazim and mutar according to Sephardim.

Na’ana Leaves and Other Besamim

  • Chacham Ovadia cautions that na’ana leaves and other plants used as besamim are different from flowers. After several days in water, growth may appear at the bottoms of the branches or plants.
  • One may smell the na’ana, say Borei Isvei Besamim, and pick up or move its container. But on Shabbat one should not take the leaves out of the water container—whether it is a vase, cup, or bucket—because returning them may cause growth and may be asur min haTorah as zore’a.
  • Flowers do not grow at the bottom of their branches after being cut and placed in water; at most, their leaves or blossoms may open further, which is not considered zore’a.