One of the followers sent in an email with a question about his mother. She is older, the father has passed away, and she lives alone. She likes to listen to music while she’s cooking and while she’s at home. Is she allowed to listen to music during the nine days? Someone else asked about traveling a long distance: if he doesn’t put on music in the car on the way back from work, or while traveling a long distance at night, he can fall asleep, and the music keeps him up. Can he turn on music in the car?
The answer is this: We know music is not allowed during the nine days. Absolutely not. Halachically, a person is not allowed to listen to music. We don’t listen to any music, not live music and not recorded music, as we said in the audio in the past. However, for an older lady in such a situation, our poskim (halachic authorities), our hachamim (sages), bring down that she’s allowed to listen to music. Try to tell her to listen to more classic music, not music that’s going to get a person to dance.
The source of the issur (prohibition) against listening to music, the source of the practice of not listening to music during the three weeks, is the Magen Avraham. The Magen Avraham says that a person should not listen to music that’s going to make them dance. Therefore, sometimes we are lenient with a song that doesn’t make them dance. Still, Halacha lema’aseh (practical halacha): any music is asur (forbidden), as Maran (our master) Hacham Ovadia Yosef writes. Any music is not allowed. In fact, even a cappella music—our rabbis are very against a cappella, a cappella, whatever you call it, music—because it makes you dance. So what difference does it make if it’s electronic noises that make you dance? That’s what a cappella music is: it’s backed by people’s voices. But at this time, it’s music that makes you dance. They’re so professional at it that they make it sound like real music, and it gets a person to dance. Therefore, a cappella music is also not allowed, and regular music is not allowed.
However, in the case of an older woman, she should try to listen to calm, classic music, like the kind they have in shoe stores, as I remember. If that’s not enough for her, she’s allowed to listen to her regular music if it’s going to put her in a good mood. A lady of that age who’s home alone, in a specific situation like that, is allowed to listen to music to make sure she’s happy and calm.
Similarly, for a guy driving back, there’s a psak (halachic ruling) from a few rabbis, brought down by Hacham Yitzchak Yosef: if a person is driving back home very late at night, and it’s dangerous for him to drive because he might fall asleep, and the music is going to keep him up, halachically he’s allowed to turn on the music. But you have to make sure that’s true. Sometimes it’s the Yetzer Hara (evil inclination) talking to you, telling you that you need music. If it’s really true, then yes, you can turn on music to keep yourself alert and not fall asleep while you drive. Chas veshalom (God forbid). Keep yourself safe. You’re allowed to blast music in the car, even during the nine days, to make sure you’re safe.
Someone else asked, and I’d like to raise a little awareness about it: Is one allowed to eat meat at a Seudat Mitzvah (commandment)? We discussed this. Yes, if there’s a Brit Milah (covenant of circumcision), a Pidyon HaBen (redemption of the son), or, let’s say, a Bar Mitzvah (coming-of-age celebration) Bizmano (at its proper time), that’s already a Machloket (dispute). But definitely for a Brit Milah, and definitely for a Pidyon HaBen, a person can have meat.
However, a person has to be careful. For a Brit Milah and a Pidyon HaBen, a person is allowed to have meat only if he would have joined anyway and is part of the family. But let’s say there’s a Siyum Masechet (tractate) (a party). A person finishes a Masechet, finishes a Gemara, and is making a Siyum. Is one allowed to eat meat in such a situation? The answer is yes. A Siyum Masechet becomes a Seudat Mitzvah, a meal of a Mitzvah. Therefore, you’re allowed to eat meat at that Siyum Masechet, a party.
However, at the same time, we can’t fool the system. If a person would have been invited throughout the year to come to his friend’s Siyum, he would have run away from it, and now suddenly he’s running to it. If he’s really friendly with the person and was a little bit involved and all that, then yes, he should go. But if you go to a Siyum Masechet for a person you don’t know, and you’re only going to eat meat, that’s not allowed.
In fact, I’ve already heard of one or two restaurants that are doing the wrong thing. Hashem should give them only Beracha (blessing). What’s the wrong thing? They hire avreichim, they hire people, they pay them to finish Gemarot and come to their restaurants to make a Siyum once a night, every single day in the restaurant. So now that they’ve made a Siyum, it means that everybody else can have meat in the restaurant throughout the day. That’s a horrible thing to do. Remember what Maran HaShulchan Aruch says: a person who has meat during the nine days is Poretz Geder: they broke a barrier, they broke a wall that should not be breaking, according to the tradition of the Jewish people. Then Maran goes on and says that a snake can bite them. It’s a saying, which means this is a very serious, severe halacha that should not be broken unless a person really needs to. An older person who needs meat or chicken is allowed to have it. A person after surgery who needs meat or chicken is allowed to have it. Little children can have meat or chicken if they need it. Somebody who’s pregnant and whose doctor tells them they need meat or chicken is allowed to have it. But playing this game—going to a Siyum party that she never would have gone to if it weren’t for the nine days, or, Chas veshalom, going to a meat restaurant—Chas veshalom, God forbid—to go to a meat restaurant during the nine days and really lie to yourself and fool yourself that because somebody made a Siyum, it’s good enough, is halachically not correct.
Even a Zohar: Sephardim (Sephardic Jews) make a Zohar the night before the Brit Milah. They sit together and read the Zohar, and they have like a meal; it’s a little bit of a Seudat Mitzvah. Even then, the Yalkut Yosef brings down that Hacham Yitzchak Yosef says you’re not allowed to serve meat at the Seudat HaZohar (Zohar meal) the night before a Brit Milah. One has to be very careful. As we discussed, don’t run away from the chumrot, the stringencies of the nine days; rather, run to the chumrot, the stringencies of the nine days, and try to mourn as much as possible for the Beit HaMikdash (Temple). Everybody should have only Beracha.