A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Torah Lecture

Listening to Music While Driving? A Person That feels a little Down? Eating Meat at a Siyum?

Lectured by Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi

Published
August 8, 2024
Duration
6:09
Lecture code
RYR-151

Listening to Music During the Nine Days

  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi addresses two questions: whether an older woman who lives alone may listen to music at home, and whether a person may listen to music while driving if silence could make him fall asleep.
  • The general halacha is that music is forbidden during the nine days: this applies to both live and recorded music. The source for avoiding music during the three weeks is the Magen Avraham, who says not to listen to music that makes a person dance. Although this can lead to leniency for songs that do not make a person dance, Maran Hacham Ovadia Yosef writes that, in practical halacha, all music is forbidden.
  • A cappella music is also not allowed: even though it is made with voices rather than instruments, it can sound like regular music and make a person dance.
  • For an older woman who is home alone, the poskim allow listening to music in this specific situation to help her remain happy and calm. She should first try calm, classic music; if that is not enough, she may listen to her usual music.
  • Hacham Yitzchak Yosef brings a ruling from several rabbis that a person driving very late at night may turn on music if there is a real danger he will fall asleep and the music will keep him alert. The person must make sure this is genuinely necessary, and not merely the Yetzer Hara telling him he wants music. If it is needed for safety, he may even play it loudly, including during the nine days.

Meat at a Seudat Mitzvah During the Nine Days

  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi turns to whether meat may be eaten at a Seudat Mitzvah (commandment meal). Meat is permitted at a Brit Milah and a Pidyon HaBen; a Bar Mitzvah held Bizmano (at its proper time) is a matter of Machloket (dispute).
  • For a Brit Milah or Pidyon HaBen, a person may have meat only if he would have attended anyway and is part of the family.
  • A Siyum Masechet (completion of a tractate) is a Seudat Mitzvah, so meat may be served and eaten there. However, a person should not attend merely to eat meat. If he would normally have avoided a friend’s Siyum, he should not suddenly go because of the nine days; someone who is genuinely friendly with the person and somewhat involved may attend.
  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi says he has heard of restaurants hiring avreichim to finish Gemarot and hold a Siyum there every night, so that customers can eat meat in the restaurant during the day. He calls this wrong.
  • Maran HaShulchan Aruch says that someone who eats meat during the nine days is Poretz Geder (breaks a boundary), and adds that a snake can bite him. Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi explains the latter as an expression of how serious the halacha is, not something to violate without real need.
  • Exceptions for need include an older person, someone recovering from surgery, or a young child who needs meat or chicken; a pregnant woman may also have it if her doctor says she needs it. Attending a Siyum one otherwise would not attend, or going to a meat restaurant and using a Siyum as justification, is not halachically correct.
  • Sephardim hold a Zohar the night before a Brit Milah, with a meal that is somewhat a Seudat Mitzvah. Nevertheless, the Yalkut Yosef brings that Hacham Yitzchak Yosef rules that meat should not be served at the Seudat HaZohar.
  • Rabbi Yaakov Rahimi urges people not to evade the chumrot (stringencies) of the nine days, but to embrace them and mourn as much as possible for the Beit HaMikdash.
Words in this lecture1
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras