A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Torah Lecture

You Are in the Middle of a Story- ‎למה רגשו גוים - למה ה' תעמוד ברחוק (תהלים ב, א - י,א)

Lectured by Rabbi Yossi Saadeh

Published
December 22, 2025
Duration
7:53
Lecture code
RYS-TEH13

Two Pesukim That Begin with “Why”

  • Rabbi Yossi Saadeh discusses two Pesukim in different chapters of Tehillim. In Perek Bet, Pasuk Aleph, David HaMelech says, “Lama ragshu goyim”—“Why do nations gather?”—and asks why regimes speak in vain.
  • In Perek Yod, Pasuk Aleph, David HaMelech says, “Lama Adonai ta'amod berachok, ta'alim le'itot batzarah”—“Why, Hashem, do you stand from a distance? Why do you seem far from me and conceal yourself in times of distress?”
  • Although these Pesukim come from separate chapters, both chapters begin with a question of “why.” Rabbi Yossi Saadeh notes that these are the only two chapters in Tehillim that begin this way.

The Questions Begin in the Middle of a Story

  • The rabbis teach that Perek Bet continues Perek Aleph, and Perek Yod continues Perek Tet. These Pesukim are therefore not the beginnings of new topics, but are in the middle of a chapter and a story.
  • Rabbi Yossi Saadeh explains that David HaMelech is teaching why people ask “Lama”—why they encounter things they cannot understand. It is like opening a 300-page story at page 132: without having read what came before, a reader may have many questions about who people are, why events are happening, and why someone is suffering.
  • In the same way, the questions “Why, Hashem, are You so far away?” arise because we are entering the story in the middle. David HaMelech alludes to this as the reason behind our questions.

Facing Difficulties and Tragedies

  • When people see difficult situations, tragedies, or events they cannot make sense of, Rabbi Yossi Saadeh says they must rely on the author—the Creator of the world.
  • The world is very ancient, and we are entering it in the middle of a story. Because we do not understand what happened in the past, we cannot fully understand what is taking place in the present.
  • When we next face something incomprehensible and ask “why,” David HaMelech’s lesson is to remember that we are in the middle of the story.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem