A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
. Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Torah Lecture

Funeral in Israel for ESTHER BAT CHANA, may she rest in peace.

Lectured by . Levaya Araya / Sheloshim

Published
January 25, 2018
Duration
51:32
Lecture code
LAS-94

Rabbi Abu D’Said’s Eulogy

  • Rabbi Abu D’Said described Esther as a woman of valor who stood closely with her husband, Avi, sharing their life and raising their children. He said she trusted and cared for him, and at one point managed the household finances with the checkbook.
  • Avi continued volunteering with Hatzalah after returning home, and Esther supported the work as its office: she answered calls around the clock, though she did not go out on calls in Brooklyn.
  • The Gemara in Kiddushin distinguishes a righteous person who is “good” from one who is not: beyond serving Hashem, a righteous person who is good bears another person’s burden and acts for another’s benefit. Rabbi Abu D’Said said Esther exemplified this through her warm greetings and willingness to participate and help at gatherings.
  • Rashi, at the beginning of Parashat Shemot, compares the Jewish people to the stars: each has a name and a number. A commentary explains that stars have tremendous light—greater than the sun’s, though we cannot see it because they are distant. Likewise, a Jewish soul has great light, but its light is hidden within the body.
  • Every soul has a unique mission that no one else can fulfill; each Jew must say, “The world was created for me.” Rabbi Abu D’Said said Esther fulfilled her mission, and that each mitzvah elevates the soul.
  • Esther endured difficulties from a young age, including not having a child of her own. With Avi, she built a life of companionship and happiness and raised wonderful children. She also suffered pain for more than ten years, sought many doctors and specialists, and endured an especially difficult final week and a half, when she could understand people but could not respond. Rabbi Abu D’Said said such suffering greatly purifies the soul.
  • He recalled Moshe Rabbeinu asking Hashem, “Why have You harmed this people?” Hashem promised that Moshe would see what He would do. Only after the Ten Plagues and the splitting of the Sea could Moshe see the redemption unfolding. Rabbi Abu D’Said emphasized that people cannot know Hashem’s ways or understand the purpose of suffering as events are happening.
  • Citing the Midrash Yalkut Shimoni on the redemption in the time of Achashverosh, he noted that “the city of Shushan was bewildered.” He suggested that alongside Haman’s decree, Hashem wanted the people to awaken, do teshuvah, and draw close to Him.
  • He connected this idea to illnesses and other hardships in the community, including children who were unwell and a fire. He mentioned more than three children being affected, and a father enduring hardship with his three children, and urged people to draw near to Hashem.
  • Rabbi Abu D’Said described the two-and-a-half months Avi and the family went through as very difficult. Hatzalah members supported them like family, doing what they could to help and carry the burden.
  • He recounted how, while traveling to the airport after tickets had been arranged in a rush for the burial, someone from Hatzalah in Queens called to ask what Avi needed. Within half an hour, two Hatzalah members arrived with a large meal; people from Flatbush and Queens were also there. Avi was known and involved in Hatzalah across Flatbush, Queens, Deal, and Lakewood, including in Queens management.
  • He thanked the people who worked with Avi, especially Uncle Charles, whom he called a pillar who had supported his home behind the scenes, and Harry Agami. He said acts of kindness include more than giving money: making someone feel cared for, happy, and supported is also kindness.
  • He spoke of Esther’s ancestors. Her grandfather Charlie Siroya served the community and its youth for forty years; David Ozery told him that he owed his own knowledge of songs and customs to Charlie Siroya’s influence. Rabbi Abu D’Said also mentioned Rabbi Nissim Tawil and the tradition that he helped support the Mir Yeshiva when it was in Japan, through Rabbi Yechezkel Levenstein and other great Torah leaders.
  • He said Esther’s two grandfathers and their group were great people who would come to greet her, and that the deceased would be accompanied by those who could testify to her accomplishments. He recalled a story of a person who had done kindness for someone in difficulty and said that person would come to greet him after his passing. He expressed hope that Esther would be received with great honor and brought to Gan Eden.

Rabbi Ayman’s Eulogy

  • Speaking as Esther’s first cousin, Rabbi Ayman recalled knowing her since childhood. He cited Chazal’s teaching that when someone dies, “the living should take it to heart.”
  • He said Esther made people feel valued. Even after many years without seeing him, she greeted him warmly and asked after him; she treated his wife the same way. He described making another person feel good as a great kindness that helps them persevere through hardship.
  • Esther had a difficult childhood after her parents divorced and, as the older sister, took responsibility for what was happening at home. Rabbi Ayman said she was not distracted by material things from the purpose and mission of life.
  • Reflecting on Avi, the children, Esther’s kindness, and her suffering, he cited Chazal, “According to the effort is the reward.” He explained that the effort is not only proportional to the reward but is itself part of the reward and shows how much kindness a person has done. He remarked that some people he knew had little pleasure in this world, mentioning the Rebbe, and described Esther as finishing her work and beginning again in a different way.
  • He recalled the Miller family’s loss of a grandson who had been involved with Hatzalah. He remembered Rabbi Miller asking how such a thing could happen and blaming himself despite not being at fault; Rabbi Miller then traveled less for his family. Rabbi Ayman connected that loss to Esther’s involvement in kindness and Hatzalah, and said that her death was a loss for his own family and for the community.
  • He referred to Chazal’s teaching that when the Temple was destroyed, the Divine Presence went into exile, and then spoke of the remarkable people in the community and Esther’s contributions as a mother and through her prayers for her husband, children, family, yeshiva, and learning.
  • He said the effects of a person’s good deeds continue to multiply through the people they affect and through generations. Hashem may reveal further consequences of those deeds over time. He emphasized that every life a person helps save, and every act of kindness, continues to have an expanding impact.

Eulogy by a Speaker in Hebrew

  • The eulogizer noted that the Hebrew word hesped (eulogy) contains hefsed (loss), and described Esther as a precious stone who brought healing to those who saw her.
  • He recalled being in New York two weeks earlier for Tehillim on Shabbat. Rabbi El Ben Chaim told him that he and his wife had awakened from the same dream, in which they were told to recite Tehillim for Esther’s recovery; he said Hashem prolonged her days.
  • He described Esther’s life as hidden and marked by suffering. Citing the teaching that someone negligent in eulogizing a righteous person deserves to be buried alive, he said that although he was not worthy to eulogize her, the community had suffered a great loss.
  • He urged people to learn from her suffering and remain close to Hashem even without suffering. He said that Hashem may bring suffering upon some people so that others, seeing what they endure, will draw closer to Him.
  • He cited the teaching that Hashem is glad when a pure and righteous soul comes before Him, alongside the statement that the death of the righteous is harder than the burning of the House of God. He explained that a righteous person’s death can stir people to grief and teshuvah, but they may later forget; the destruction of the Temple remains visible to those who see the Western Wall.
  • He called Esther a symbol of sanctifying Hashem’s name, love of Hashem, and love for people.
  • From that week’s Torah portion, he cited, “I have also seen the oppression with which the Egyptians oppress them, and I have remembered My covenant.” The Gemara in Berachot, page 5, teaches that suffering purifies a person of all sins.
  • The Gemara derives this through a kal vachomer: when a slave’s tooth or eye is knocked out, the slave goes free; therefore, suffering that purifies the whole person certainly frees them. The Gemara also teaches that suffering purifies through the “covenant of salt,” just as salt and a sacrifice sweeten meat.
  • He quoted an explanation from his father and teacher, Rabbi Yitzchak Abba Shaul: the covenant of salt is needed in addition to the kal vachomer because, as discussed in Kiddushin 24a, a slave is freed when the master personally knocks out the tooth or eye, but not when an agent does so. That qualification could challenge the kal vachomer, so the teaching of “I have remembered My covenant” provides an additional basis for the purifying effect of suffering.
  • He said Esther endured suffering from Hashem and accepted it with love and patience. Each person, he urged, should learn from her according to their circumstances and level.
  • He said she was now close beneath the Throne of Glory through the merit of her ancestors. He also knew Charles and Nissim and had seen their self-sacrifice in sanctifying Hashem’s name and bringing merit to the public.
  • He urged people to awaken and do teshuvah without waiting for suffering, since everyone has an evil inclination and personal stumbling blocks. He concluded that the words spoken and the lessons taken to heart should be for the elevation of Esther’s soul, and prayed for comfort and healing for her husband, Rabbi Avraham, and the family.