A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Torah Lecture

Understanding Tefillah #16 - Hashem pays us to make our lives better

Lectured by Rabbi Alex Mizrahi

Published
December 30, 2025
Duration
3:57
Lecture code
RAM-TEF16

The apparent contradiction in gomel chasadim tovim

  • In the first Beracha of the Amidah, we describe Hashem’s greatness through His traits and actions, including that He is gomel chasadim tovim: gomel means “repays,” while chasadim tovim means acts of great kindness.
  • The rabbis say the phrase seems grammatically contradictory: repayment is something owed, whereas kindness is given voluntarily, as with tzedakah, donating one’s time, or doing a chesed for someone without being obligated.
  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi asks how Hashem can be described as repaying us with kindness.

Why reward for mitzvot is itself a kindness

  • We are commanded to perform mitzvot, and Hashem rewards us for them. Yet, since Hashem created us, gave us our Beracha, and provides everything we have, it seems we should not expect payment for carrying out His commands.
  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi illustrates this with a parent asking a child to take out the garbage. If the child then asks for 20 dollars, the parent could point out all the care, food, cleaning, clothing, and late nights already provided, and question why one request should require payment.
  • In the same way, Hashem gives us everything; asking for reward for mitzvot would seem improper. Nevertheless, Hashem gives a reward, making it a great chesed.
  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi compares this to Hashem saying, in effect, “Take out the garbage—and I’ll give you 20 dollars for doing it”: the reward is included alongside the command.

Reward as an incentive for our benefit

  • Rabbi Alex Mizrahi asks why Hashem wants to reward us for performing mitzvot.
  • His answer is that mitzvot perfect us and make us holier. Hashem does not need our mitzvot; they are for our benefit, and reward encourages us to do what is right.
  • He recalls a summer job when his father offered to match any money he put in the bank. He could spend what he wanted, but his father would match what he chose to save. The father did not have to offer this; he wanted to encourage saving because it was beneficial.
  • He also gives the example of a child who comes home with a report card of A’s. Even though the parents pay tuition and might be very upset about F’s, a good parent may give the child a gift for doing well in order to encourage success.
  • This is the meaning of Hashem being gomel chasadim tovim: Hashem wants us to perform mitzvot for our own good and rewards us as an act of chesed, encouraging us to become great.