Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Marriage Series and the Sailing Relationships Podcast, as I’m going to post this on both. Today’s topic is getting your spouse to change. My number is 917-837-0102 if you’d like to ask me a marriage-related question or set up a session so we can get your marriage to where it would like to be, with Hashem’s help.
Many people want to know what to do. What’s the secret? What can I do to get my spouse to change and finally give me what I need? And just that one or two things, like I talk about all the time—it’s a one-two. If you have more than that, more complaints than that, then it’s time to take inventory of yourself. Most likely, it’s not more than one or two things.
In any event, people want to know what to do. I’ve seen what people do. First, they try to tell their spouse. They’ll tell them; they’ll ask them, maybe nicely, maybe not. Then it doesn’t work, so they’ll try to get them to listen to a class or a podcast, get them a book, or get a friend, a rabbi, or someone to talk to them. Those are all different ideas people have. I’m not going to say they don’t, but for the most part, they don’t work.
When you get stuck and feel that there are things you genuinely need in your relationship, and it’s not working, there’s another route people take: they come to the conclusion that their spouse needs therapy. Then they pull the therapy card: “You need therapy,” whether it’s trauma, drama, or whatever it is that your spouse needs.
People want to know what to do. If you’ve been listening to my classes long enough, you know I’m not going to say anything conventional here. You can’t control your spouse. You can’t control anyone. You can’t just get them to change. It doesn’t work, obviously, and waiting around for something to click in their minds isn’t going to happen.
Before I give some practical ideas on how to get your spouse to give you what you feel you need, it’s important to understand a few concepts. It would be really helpful to understand why they’re not giving you what you need. Think about it. Really think about it after this podcast, or pause it now—whatever it is. Really think about it, or talk it over with someone who can give you an objective opinion. Really understand why, because that’s at the core of it. Why is the person who loves me the most not giving me what I need or want? Why?
It’s a question, not just a thought. This is a real question. As we would say, it’s a kasha (question). They love me so much. People say all the time, “If you love me, wouldn’t you do it?” And then they can’t do it, or they don’t do it. “Well, I guess they don’t love me.” That’s the wrong conclusion. I say this all the time: your spouse definitely loves you. That’s a fact, so that’s ruled out.
Are they crazy? I don’t think so. I don’t think they’re crazy. People have rachmanut (pity) on people who are crazy and have lost their minds. They try to get them help—I mean, real help. So what is happening? Many times, when I ask people, “Why do you think they do this?” they’re stumped. “I really don’t know.” The answer to that question would be a very, very big clue as to what’s happening, and a major, major breakthrough in your marriage and in understanding what is going on.
There are so many examples, so it’s hard to say. But let’s give one simple example that you could build off of. Many people will say, “My spouse is so quiet. They’re so reserved. They don’t”—whether it’s a man or a woman—“talk a lot. I try to have a conversation, and I have to make up conversation. I don’t know what’s happening here.” That’s a valid point. It’s hard to connect or communicate with someone who doesn’t really talk much. People say, “My husband’s not a man of many words,” or, “My wife is just very quiet.”
It’s important to understand that, in my opinion, there are two basic possibilities, although there’s also the possibility of something out of the ordinary. Let’s take the simpler idea: that’s them; that’s their nature. They’re not talkative people. They’re reserved people, and that’s not going to change, especially if you saw that when you first got married. I’ve had people tell me, “Yes, I noticed my spouse was like this when we got married.” I said, “Okay, so what are you trying to do?” “Well, I need more.”
It’s really on you to figure out a plan for the person you’ve been married to for 5, 10, or 15 years, who was always reserved and is still reserved. Nothing changed. Most likely, they’re trying to be more outgoing for you, but it’s against their nature. That’s not something that doesn’t have a solution. But if it’s their nature and that’s who they are, I don’t even want to say it’s going to be hard for them to change. I don’t think it’s even fair to ask them to change. Forget about not even getting them to change. It’s not even fair to ask someone who’s reserved by nature to start being outgoing. It’s not fair.
There are tips and tools to use, but the first thing to do is accept that that’s them and you’re not going to change them. There’s a lot to talk about on that point. If that’s what’s happening, you need to come to terms with it and enjoy the good that you have in them. If you’re a talker and need to talk, talk to them. If you need someone to respond, find a good friend. Don’t hurt yourself and your marriage because of something that’s a fact. They’re not hurting you; they’re not damaging; they’re not dangerous. They’re most likely very good-hearted people, either supporting or taking care of the kids. It’s just something that would be nice. If you’re a good-hearted person, people say, “I need, I need to talk.” Okay, you need to talk, so find someone to talk to.
“Now, I need my spouse to talk.” Oh, well, you can’t have that. I’m just saying, maybe you can’t have that. That’s just one idea.
The more complex idea would be if they were usually outgoing and talkative, or if they still are with other people. That might be a clue or a hint that there’s a reason it’s happening, and that it’s not by nature. It might be the relationship. They might feel threatened or defensive, or they might get scared, or whatever it might be. Over the years, they just don’t—they’re scared to open their mouth or say something because of the repercussions.
Now, I’m not saying that’s your fault, whether you’re a man or a woman. I’m not saying it’s your fault or that you intentionally did that. It could be unintentional. Maybe you’re dominating the conversation. Maybe, if they say something, you don’t give them the space to speak up. Whatever it might be, I know it sounds accusatory. I’m not. I’m not accusing anyone of anything. I’m just trying to put the ideas out there so you can have food for thought. Think about it, work it over, and try to come to some type of conclusion and closure on this point.
If that’s what’s happening, what would be productive is to let them talk in a nonjudgmental way. Don’t put them on the fence; let them speak. Say, “Wow, that’s great. That’s a great opinion,” even if you don’t agree. Of course, that has to be done with care. Be careful; there are so many points on each thing.
I want to put out two points. I went a little bit off on the reserved spouse, but it would be appropriate and helpful for yourself to figure out why in the world they’re not giving you what you need and why they’re behaving in a certain way. Then you can approach the situation properly instead of forcing and forcing and forcing.
Someone told me a few months ago, “I have no other option but to force a certain situation.” I told them, “But you know that’s destructive.” “Yeah, but I don’t have any other options.” So we do something destructive for lack of better options? Come on. That doesn’t work. You’re hitting a brick wall. They’re not giving you what you feel you need, and it’s important to think about why they’re not doing it. Once you figure that out—better with a third party, of course—you can figure out why and approach it differently. Maybe they need to be spoken to in a gentle way. Whatever it is, there are so many examples.
Maybe they are giving you what you need, and maybe you’re extra needy and need more than the basics. It’s really important to think about this. I could talk about this literally for hours. If you want to get your marriage in order and there are things that are bothering you, it’s so easy once you figure out what you need. It’s so easy once you figure out why they’re not giving it to you. They want to give you whatever you want.
I’ll leave off with one example. I spoke a while ago to a couple. It was a very hard situation. The person was really hurting their spouse. I spoke to both of them. Someone was really getting hurt on many levels. There was an unclear phrase. This person, who was, let’s say, the perpetrator, was defending themselves and telling me, “Look at all that I do for this person. Look what I did here. I went out of my way and did X, Y, and Z.”
I looked at them and said, “I know you did. That’s not even close to what they need. They need you to stop hurting them. That’s not what they need.” That’s another point people get stuck on: “I’m doing so much. I’m doing all this.” But you’re missing the one thing. The popular love languages are a nice read, just to get an idea of how people feel loved in certain ways.
Think about this, and pray to Hashem for clarity. You should have a wonderful relationship.