A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Marriage Series 32: If They Loved Me They Should Do Anything For Me!

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
August 28, 2025
Duration
10:40
Lecture code
sb-32

What People Try to Make a Spouse Change

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says people often ask how to get a spouse to change and give them what they need. He suggests that if someone has more than one or two complaints, they should take inventory of themselves; usually, the issue is no more than one or two things.
  • People may tell or ask their spouse—gently or otherwise—or try to get them to listen to a class or podcast, read a book, or speak with a friend, rabbi, or someone else. Rabbi Cohen says these approaches generally do not work.
  • When those efforts fail, some decide their spouse needs therapy and use “You need therapy” as a way to address the problem, whether they believe it involves trauma, drama, or something else.
  • Rabbi Cohen’s central point is that you cannot control another person or simply make them change. Waiting for something to click in their mind is not a solution.

First Understand Why They Are Not Meeting Your Need

  • Before looking for practical ways to get a spouse to meet a need, Rabbi Cohen says it is important to understand why they are not doing so. He encourages listeners to think it through, or discuss it with someone objective.
  • The question is: Why is the person who loves me most not giving me what I need or want? This is a genuine kasha (question), not merely a passing thought.
  • People may reason, “If you love me, wouldn’t you do it?” and conclude that a spouse who does not do it must not love them. Rabbi Cohen says that is the wrong conclusion: he says a spouse definitely loves you.
  • He also does not think the spouse is “crazy.” When he asks people why they think their spouse behaves a certain way, they are often stumped. In his view, finding the answer can provide a major clue and breakthrough in understanding the marriage.

Example: A Quiet or Reserved Spouse

  • Rabbi Cohen uses a spouse who is quiet and does not talk much as an example. That can make conversation and connection difficult, and people may say they have to make up the conversation themselves.
  • He describes two basic possibilities, while allowing that something out of the ordinary could also be going on.
  • The first possibility is that reserve is simply the spouse’s nature. If the person was like this when the couple married and has remained so for 5, 10, or 15 years, Rabbi Cohen says the other spouse needs to make a plan that takes this reality into account. The reserved spouse may be trying to be more outgoing, but it goes against their nature.
  • In that case, Rabbi Cohen says it is not even fair to ask the spouse to become outgoing. The first step is to accept that this is who they are, recognize the good in them, and not damage the marriage over a trait that is neither harmful nor dangerous. If you need to talk, talk with your spouse; if you need someone to respond, find a good friend. You may not be able to get that need met by your spouse.
  • The second possibility is that the spouse is usually talkative, or remains talkative with other people. That may indicate that the quietness is connected to the relationship rather than being their nature: they may feel threatened or defensive, be scared, or fear the repercussions of speaking.
  • Rabbi Cohen is not accusing either spouse or saying this is intentional. It could happen unintentionally—for example, one person may dominate the conversation or fail to leave room for the other to speak.
  • If this is what is happening, he says it would help to let the spouse speak without judgment. Make room for their views and respond positively—even when you disagree—while handling this carefully.

Avoid Forcing; Find a Different Approach

  • Rabbi Cohen says it is important to work out why a spouse is not meeting a need and then approach the situation accordingly, rather than continuing to force the issue.
  • He recalls someone saying they had no option but to force a situation. Rabbi Cohen replied that this was destructive, and challenged the idea that a destructive approach was justified by a lack of alternatives.
  • He says it is like hitting a brick wall. Once you understand why the spouse is not doing what you feel you need, preferably with the help of a third party, you may be able to approach them differently—for example, by speaking gently.
  • He also raises the possibility that the spouse is already meeting the need at a basic level, while the other person is unusually needy and wants more than the basics. He encourages listeners to examine that possibility as well.

Identify What the Spouse Actually Needs

  • Rabbi Cohen describes speaking with a couple in a very difficult situation in which one person was hurting the other on many levels. The person causing the harm defended themselves by listing what they had done for their spouse, including going out of their way to do various things.
  • Rabbi Cohen acknowledged those efforts but said they were not close to what the spouse needed: the spouse needed the hurting to stop.
  • He says people can get stuck on how much they are doing while missing the one thing the other person needs. He notes that popular books about love languages can be a useful read for understanding the different ways people feel loved.
  • Rabbi Cohen encourages listeners to think about the situation and pray to Hashem for clarity.