A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Parenting Series 8: Dealing With The Fragile Child

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
December 29, 2024
Duration
8:51
Lecture code
p-8

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Parenting Series with Rabbi Ali Cohen. You can reach me at 917-837-0102 or A-L-C-O-H-E-N@levtorah.org. What are you saying? You can call, or you can email if you're a little more comfortable with email. I coach people in their marriages. Call up; we can discuss your marriage or your parenting, whatever it is. With a lot of siyata dishmaya, a lot of help from Hashem, we're able to get people to a good place where they like to be.

Today's topic continues last week's topic, which was dealing with a fragile child. If you're listening to this and want to know about the fragile child, I advise you to listen to the other class, because that explains what a fragile child looks like and whether you're dealing with that type of child. Here, I'm going to give practical ideas on how to deal with a fragile child. But if you're going to identify another child as a fragile child and identify your own child in some other way, then you missed the point. So really go listen to that class if you want the full picture of a fragile child.

What do you do if you find that this is your child? Like I said last time, this is not simple at all. There's no quick fix. There's no quick fix or one-shot deal where you take one class and you're done, get a sticker chart, and it's all over, or just talk nicely and take them out. It doesn't work like that. All the ideas I'm going to mention today require a serious, serious commitment. It's serious work in progress. It could take months for things to fall into place, but the system works. The system I'm about to mention, which my rabbi, Rabbi Shimon Gruen, has put forth, along with a couple of my own ideas, works. I have tons of material on this, both my own and from my rabbi. He has helped out thousands of people with their parenting with a fragile child. But again, it's a work in progress. Let's get right into the ideas.

As you've seen, this child is different. They are hard to deal with. Their tantrums are out of control. You're at a loss. People have told me crazy things. I'm just bringing them up to make the point. People have told me, “We can't live with this person. I want to send them to somebody else's house—my sister's, my uncle's, my parents'. Just send them out. We can't have them. They're creating turmoil in our home like we've never seen.”

So, step number one: What do you do with a sensitive child, a fragile child? Understand that they are sensitive and cannot be forced. They cannot be forced into doing anything. Avoid forcing them at all costs. As you've seen, many people tell me, “So what? Now they're calling the shots?” They've been calling the shots. People call me when they're dealing with a four-year-old. People call me when they're dealing with an 18-year-old, as you've seen for 18 years. I mean, a few people come to mind now. They're dealing with an 18- or 20-year-old. And, you know, it's ridiculous. I'm sorry. I don't blame anyone. But they're telling me, “Oh, so I can't force them? I'm giving up control?” They've been ruling your life for 18 years. I'm telling you about a new program that you're actually going... You're in control of the program, and you control the system.

Not forcing them is going to be part of your system. Just getting that out there. People do get this notion when I tell them, “No force,” and they say things like, “Well, so I'm throwing in the towel of all of my whatever.” So don't force them. Figure it out. Be creative. Like I said, it's a work in progress, and it takes commitment, incentives, and speaking in a certain way: “It would mean so much if you took a bath. It would be so nice if you did your homework.” Every age is different, so I can't really give a full thing for this. But it's about being creative. Whoever is calmer, husband or wife, should deal with this child on a day-to-day basis. Don't force this child. They will rebel. It will backfire.

A lot of professionals say that when you have a child like this, you should exert more force. It doesn't work. I've seen this not work over and over. Don't do it. The next thing is: Don't challenge them. Don't challenge their feelings. Don't challenge them when they want to say something that doesn't need to be challenged. If they say something annoying, let it be annoying. If they say something out of character, again, we're going to get to the next point: What do you do about discipline when they do something wrong? But that's going to be last on the list. We've got to put discipline on the back burner right now. Don't challenge them. Validate their feelings. They need to be understood. They need to be heard.

Of course, people say, “Yeah, everyone does.” No. It's nice for everyone to be heard and understood. For them, it's crucial. For the fragile child, it's crucial, and it can make or break them if they feel like Mommy and Daddy get me or Mommy and Daddy don't get me. If they grow up feeling that Mommy and Daddy don't get them, it's not a great situation for the child growing up. Your goal is for them to feel understood. Now, it doesn't matter what you say: “I'm doing whatever. I'm doing whatever it is, and they should understand me.” They should feel understood. If they don't feel understood, that's the main thing. The main thing is how they feel. If they don't feel understood, figure out how to make them feel like you get them. Very, very important. This is not all-inclusive. There's so much more, but this is just a brief overview.

The last part is what to do when they do something that's completely wrong. Don't make them too many rules. Don't make too many. A lot of people—this is general for parenting—make ridiculous rules about punishing when there's no need to punish. “You made noise in the house, you're punished.” I mean, noise doesn't warrant punishment. It doesn't, unless something wrong was done: bad behavior, behavior that's clearly wrong. A kid that's, God forbid, cursing or telling his parents, “Shut up,” or hitting another sibling—these are things that are wrong. They're dangerous. They're behaviors that cannot be repeated as an adult. If these are things that, as an adult, you wouldn't want him doing, then yes, that's your point to discipline.

Now, how do you discipline this child? How do you discipline them? You don't yell and scream. You don't yell and scream at anyone. As a matter of fact, this applies to all children. Yelling and screaming is not even parenting mode. It's somebody who lost himself. I mentioned that in my first class of the series. You discipline them in a very, very gentle way and let them know: “Listen. I love you, and I know you do X, Y, and Z.” They need a warning: “I know you did X, Y, and Z. If it happens again, I'm sorry, we're going to have to have a consequence.” Whatever that is. Whatever. I'm sorry. Now, if it happens again, or when it happens again, you don't yell. You don't scream. You don't throw any—“That's it. I've had it!” None of that. Gently follow through with what you said. And that's it. If it's taking away a privilege, just take away the privilege and let them know how painful it is for you. “I love you. I understand. That is going to be hard. But, you know, we had something in place.” I'm sorry. That's it. Nothing more than that. There should never be fighting and arguing with them. There should never be debates. There's just so much to say, really.

I do have a lot to say about dealing with these children. I do recommend, now that I'm finishing the class and seeing how I ran through these points, that you give me a call or speak with a professional, and deal with this professionally, because it's not simple. Pray to Hashem. He's the one who gives you the ability, the answers. Hashem is the one who puts you in the situation. Hashem made this child for you, for you and your wife, for you and your husband, to deal with them. So Hashem knows you can do it. Pray to Him. Reach out. Be patient. Try these ideas. To finish off the class, again, I said this multiple times, but understand: I'm just showing where people do trip up. They try it once or twice and then they fall out. Don't do that. Tell yourself, “I know this is a work in progress. Let me try these ideas. Give it some time.” And with Hashem's help, you'll see a lot of siyata dishmaya.