A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Parenting Series 8: Dealing With The Fragile Child

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
December 29, 2024
Duration
8:51
Lecture code
p-8

Understanding the Fragile Child and the Work Involved

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says this class gives practical ideas for dealing with a fragile child; listeners who have not heard the previous class should do so to understand what a fragile child is and whether that description fits their child.
  • He cautions against labeling a child as fragile without understanding the full picture presented in the earlier class.
  • There is no quick fix: one class, a sticker chart, or simply speaking nicely and taking the child out will not resolve the situation. The approach requires serious commitment and may take months to fall into place.
  • Rabbi Cohen says the system was put forth by his rabbi, Rabbi Shimon Gruen, together with some of Rabbi Cohen’s own ideas. Rabbi Gruen has helped thousands of parents dealing with a fragile child.
  • These children can be difficult to manage, with out-of-control tantrums that leave parents at a loss. Rabbi Cohen says some parents have told him they cannot live with the child and want to send them to a relative’s home because of the turmoil in the household.

Do Not Force the Child

  • Rabbi Cohen’s first practical step is to recognize that the child is sensitive and cannot be forced; parents should avoid forcing them at all costs.
  • He notes that parents may worry that not forcing the child means surrendering control. In his view, the child may already have been effectively calling the shots for years; the parent’s role is to take control of a new, structured program, of which not forcing the child is one part.
  • Parents should be creative, committed, and use incentives and gentle phrasing, such as, “It would mean so much if you took a bath” or “It would be so nice if you did your homework.” The right approach varies by age.
  • The calmer parent—whether the husband or wife—should handle the child day to day when possible.
  • Rabbi Cohen says forcing the child will lead to rebellion and backfire. Although many professionals advise exerting more force, he says he has repeatedly seen that approach fail.

Do Not Challenge Their Feelings

  • Parents should not challenge the child or their feelings, or challenge remarks that do not need to be challenged. If the child says something annoying, Rabbi Cohen advises letting it be annoying rather than responding to it.
  • He says discipline should be put on the back burner for now; he addresses it later in the lecture.
  • Fragile children need to feel heard and understood. While this matters for everyone, Rabbi Cohen says it is crucial for these children and can make or break their sense that “Mommy and Daddy get me.”
  • The goal is for the child to feel understood. If they do not feel understood, parents should work out how to help them feel that their parents understand them.
  • Rabbi Cohen emphasizes that this is only a brief overview and that there is much more to say.

When and How to Discipline

  • Parents should avoid making too many rules or imposing punishments where none are warranted. For example, making noise in the house does not by itself merit punishment.
  • Discipline is appropriate for clearly wrong behavior, such as cursing, telling a parent “Shut up,” or hitting a sibling. Rabbi Cohen describes these as wrong and dangerous behaviors that should not continue into adulthood.
  • Parents should not yell or scream. Rabbi Cohen says yelling is not parenting; it is losing control, and this applies to all children.
  • Discipline should be gentle. A parent can tell the child, “I love you,” acknowledge the child’s actions, and warn that if the behavior happens again there will be a consequence.
  • If the behavior happens again, the parent should calmly follow through on the stated consequence, such as taking away a privilege, without yelling, screaming, or reacting with “That’s it. I’ve had it!”
  • The parent can explain that the consequence is difficult and that they understand, while still following the plan they had set. Rabbi Cohen says there should be no fighting, arguing, or debating with the child.

Seek Help, Pray, and Give the Approach Time

  • Rabbi Cohen recommends contacting him or speaking with a professional to address the situation properly, because dealing with a fragile child is not simple.
  • He urges parents to pray to Hashem, who gives them the ability and answers, and who placed this child in their family. Rabbi Cohen says Hashem knows they can handle it.
  • Parents should reach out, be patient, and try the ideas consistently rather than giving up after one or two attempts.
  • Rabbi Cohen advises treating this as work in progress, giving the approach time, and trusting that, with Hashem’s help, they may see much siyata dishmaya.