Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Marriage Series with Rabbi Ali Cohen. You can reach me at 917-837-0102 or through the other contact information. I’ll give you a line to call to schedule a session or leave an email with a marriage-related question. There’s no reason to hold back. From my experience, most people are not reaching out about their marriage.
A lot of people have this attitude: “It is what it is. That’s life; that’s marriage.” It’s a horrible attitude, and it’s not true. If your marriage is not good, you know you’re struggling. It’s just not easy to move through life, not easy to navigate life by yourself when your marriage is not great. I don’t know why people hold back. Maybe it’s embarrassing; I don’t know. Read up a little bit and figure it out, but don’t neglect it.
Today’s topic comes up very often, and it’s very painful. Nobody talks about this. If it doesn’t apply to you, you might say, “Hey, what is that? I thought it was painful.” It’s something I see so often: people get married, and this starts right away. A husband or a wife boxes their spouse out from their family.
If this doesn’t apply to you, you’re going to think this is nuts, but I’ve seen it countless times. For example, a wife might tell her husband, “We can’t go visit your parents. I don’t want to visit your parents. I don’t want to go there for Shabbat. I don’t want them coming over. I don’t want to go to your sister’s.” Of course, she’ll have some type of reason: “I don’t like her attitude,” or “It’s so far,” or whatever it might be. “I don’t like the comments she made at the wedding,” whatever it might be—small stuff. It could even be valid, it could even be valid—something that actually happened. But no matter what happened, you cannot box your spouse out from their family.
When you get married, a person in life needs a husband and wife; they need family, they need many things. You need children, you have a family, you need a job—all these things have to exist. It’s the way Hashem made the world. Family isn’t just something that’s there. It’s part of the way Hashem made the world: people need family, support, closeness. There’s no comparing relationships with family to relationships with anyone else, with other people. There’s no comparison. A mother, a father, a brother, a sister, an uncle—it’s a beautiful thing. When people box family out and make it difficult to visit them or have them over for Shabbat, it’s nothing short of disgusting. Nothing short of disgusting.
If you have an issue and there’s a problem—when you go there, there’s a fight—then work that out. Shutting things down isn’t an option, unless a Rabbi has told you, “This is clearly dangerous or abusive.” I’m not even talking about that. I’m talking about little hits, little words here and there, little scuffles. So work it out. Boxing them out is a bad option. It’s childish. It’s immature. So many people I talk to suffer with this, and they don’t know what to do.
Then their spouse tells them, “Well, you’re choosing your family over me.” That's manipulating my opinion. That’s manipulating—not choosing their family over you. When you get married, if you want to have a successful marriage, you have to know that the person you’re marrying has family. They’re going to have time with you and your kids, and time with their family.
Of course, it can be excessive. There can be situations that are over the top. I’ve heard of such scenarios: someone will visit their mother—a man will visit his mother on the way home from work, before he gets to his wife or comes home—and he won’t even tell his wife. Then it becomes an unhealthy connection. Or somebody will ask their parents for marriage advice in an unhealthy way. Of course, there are situations that are unhealthy. They have to be dealt with and spoken about, and boundaries might be necessary.
But just because there’s something you don’t like about them or their family, you have to realize that this is something many people struggle with, and it’s not okay. It’s not okay to say, “Oh, no, we’re not going. We’re not going there anymore. We’re not visiting. They’re not coming over.” There are so many such examples. I’ve seen people not allow their spouse to talk to a sibling because they just don’t like them. I’ve seen this. They get upset with them: “Why did you talk to your brother today? Why did you talk to your sister?” What is that? What is that? You know what it is? It’s disgusting. That’s what it is.
Of course, I’m not talking about a not unhealthy situation where somebody is, let’s say, badmouthing their spouse. I’m not talking about over-the-top, wild situations. It’s just something that’s uncomfortable for you. So figure it out. Family should be—of course, it doesn’t have to be. Let’s say someone isn’t close to their family, which happens often. But family should be part of the life of a person who has a close connection with their family, whether they’re a wife or a husband. I mentioned men. I mentioned this in the context of women doing this because I talk mainly to men. But it happens both ways. Family should be—and I don’t say has to, but family should be—a part of everybody’s life. It’s not something that should be taken away from them.
It’s something that doesn’t get any attention. I don’t know what to say to anyone who’s listening, but if this is happening to you, take it seriously. Communicate with your spouse about what bothers you in a nice way. Not seeing their family and not letting them talk to their family is not an option. The option is to communicate properly. Let them know what bothers you. Let them know what works. If you have a hard time going there, tell them, “Please, you can go visit your family, and I’ll be here. Maybe one day, you know, maybe I can go for a little bit.” But boxing them out is just not an option.
Be patient. Be wise. Think about your relationship. Don’t be reckless. There are so many reckless people out there. Don’t be reckless. I know it’s not intentional. I know people mean well. I don’t think I’ve ever spoken to somebody who’s intentionally trying to hurt anyone. But you're unintentionally hurting people is also something. It’s also something. And it’s important to make sure: Am I unintentionally hurting my spouse? Am I unintentionally hurting them? I didn’t mean it. I know. We know you don’t mean it. We know nobody means it. But if it happens, it’s something to think about.