A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Marriage Series 14: Don't Take Your Spouse Away From Their Family

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
December 15, 2024
Duration
6:56
Lecture code
sb-14

Take Marriage Difficulties Seriously

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says many people dismiss an unhappy marriage with “It is what it is,” but struggling in a marriage makes it difficult to navigate life. People may hold back from addressing the problem because they feel embarrassed, but they should not neglect it.

Don’t Cut a Spouse Off From Their Family

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says it is common and painful for one spouse to box the other out from their family, sometimes soon after the marriage begins.
  • Examples include refusing to visit the spouse’s parents or siblings, preventing family visits for Shabbat, not allowing relatives to come over, or objecting when the spouse speaks to a brother or sister.
  • A spouse may cite a relative’s attitude, distance, or comments made at the wedding. The complaint may even be valid, but Rabbi Ali Cohen says it does not justify cutting the spouse off from their family.
  • He describes making it difficult to see or host family, or getting upset that a spouse spoke to a sibling, as unacceptable, childish, and immature.
  • Saying, “You’re choosing your family over me,” is, in Rabbi Ali Cohen’s view, manipulative. A successful marriage makes room for the spouse’s family relationships alongside time with the spouse and children.

Family’s Place in a Person’s Life

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says people need family, support, and closeness, as part of the way Hashem made the world. Relationships with parents, siblings, and other relatives are different from relationships with other people.
  • Family should be part of the life of someone who has a close connection with their family, whether the spouse is a husband or a wife; it should not be taken away from them.
  • He notes that not everyone is close to their family, and that family does not necessarily have to be part of every person’s life in the same way. Although he discusses the issue mainly in the context of women restricting men, he says it happens in both directions.

Distinguish Ordinary Friction From Unhealthy Situations

  • If visits involve arguments or minor conflicts, Rabbi Ali Cohen says the couple should work through the problem rather than shut down family contact.
  • He is not referring to situations a Rabbi has identified as clearly dangerous or abusive, or to extreme cases; those are different.
  • He also acknowledges that family involvement can become excessive or unhealthy. For example, a man might visit his mother on the way home from work without telling his wife, or seek marriage advice from his parents in an unhealthy way. Such situations should be discussed and may require boundaries.
  • Ordinary discomfort or dislike of a relative is not, by itself, a reason to ban visits or contact.

Communicate Without Causing Unintended Harm

  • If this is happening, Rabbi Ali Cohen urges couples to take it seriously and communicate kindly about what is bothering them and what arrangements could work.
  • If one spouse finds visits difficult, they could tell the other to visit family while they stay home, and perhaps join for a shorter time another day. Cutting off contact is not the option.
  • He advises being patient, wise, and careful rather than reckless. People may not intend to hurt their spouse, but they can do so unintentionally; each person should consider whether their actions are causing that harm.