Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Parenting Series with Rabbi Ali Cohen.
This is the third class, and I will mention this in all the classes: this is a build-up. This is a build-up. It’s not, “I like that topic,” or, “Oh, respecting parents. That’s the one. That’s what I’m missing.” Even if you feel like that’s one thing you’re missing, everything I mentioned is in order. So it would be ideal if you listen to one, two, and three in order to get the basics and build it up.
Today we’re talking about respect. How do I get my children to respect me? Now, before I get into it, there are a lot of popular secular books that talk about how to get children to listen, different techniques, and all different things. We have to understand that I do believe a lot of these secular books are missing the mark. I read multiple, multiple books, and they’re missing the mark. It’s not about getting your children to listen and do what you’d like them to do. If they respect you, they’re going to do what you’d like them to do. This is a basic concept. In the secular books, they don’t have a concept of Kibbud Av Va'em (respecting parents), so they’re not going to really talk about this. It’s just so important. We have an entirely different system. I don’t want to go off on a tangent.
Once you respect somebody—and I mean healthy respect, not fear, where you’re scared of someone; we can mention that later—when you have real, true respect, you think, “Wow, I really respect that person. They’re so good and such a good-hearted person. They treat me right. I respect them.” When you respect somebody, you want to do what they say. You want to listen to them. Some of the Mefarshim (commentators) say that this is actually the reason why respecting parents is so important: if they respect you, they’ll receive from you, and they can continue the Mesorah (tradition), or whatever it is you’re trying to give over. So respect is very crucial.
It’s contrary to the way we’re supposed to be. It’s the way we feel, or maybe even believe, these days. That was me: “Who am I? They sit in my seat. It’s okay. I don’t mind.” That’s not good. You should mind. You should mind. If you don’t mind, don’t let them sit in your seat. We can talk about the Halacha (Jewish law) aspect another time. I’m not going into that; I’m just drilling home the concept that respect is important. And how do we earn that?
Now, respect doesn’t mean that they’re scared of you and are going to do everything you say, and that they’re just going to run around fearful of you. So it’s important to understand what respect looks like. They talk to you in a nice way. There are many, many points of respect. I have a certain amount of love. They treat you with dignity. This is a Torah concept, and we want them to respect us.
So, number one: what is going wrong in society? What is happening that children do not naturally respect adults? It’s not a child problem. It’s an authority problem with all of us. What happens when a cop pulls you over? “Look at this guy. What do you think? Has nothing better to do? Go to Dunkin’ Donuts. Go away. Give me a ticket. Go deal with the crime.” When I do that, you’re saying that I can’t stand authority, and you want children to humble themselves to authority. So this is not a child problem, just putting everything into perspective. It’s an authority problem with our society. We’re not going to fix that, per se. That’s how it is; it came from somewhere. Who cares? It came from the entertainment business; it doesn’t matter. The vibe in the air everywhere is that authority is no good. That’s just how it is. It’s very rare, but maybe it happens: someone gets pulled over by a cop, and a cell phone is involved. They say, “I deserve that. Thank you, officer. Thank you, and keep up your duty and your hard work.” Maybe it happens.
So naturally, children will not be respecting adults. That’s how it is—not all, but many. If you’re listening to this, it means you want them to respect you; it means they’re not respecting you. That’s what’s happening: the concept of authority has, for the most part, gone out the window. So what do we do if the concept of authority is gone out the window? Do we say, “Kids these days,” look at them, and say, “They don’t listen. What’s the matter with them?” No, we understand that that’s what’s happening, and we teach them authority. We teach them what it is. Teaching doesn’t mean just invoking my father and expecting respect. That’s not teaching authority. Teaching means explaining it to them.
So the first step is to acknowledge that authority is gone and needs to be taught. It needs to be explained to children, however you do that, in a nice and gentle way. Of course, teach your children in a pleasant way that there are certain things you demand of them and expect of them. “No, you cannot sit in Daddy’s seat. No, I’m sorry; that’s the rule. You cannot talk to me like that. I’m just letting you know: yesterday you said something like this. We don’t tolerate that in this house. It’s just something we’re not going to tolerate.” You don’t have to come with a consequence and a punishment. Everyone’s very quick on the draw these days. Let them know; explain it to them in a nice way. Then, if you need a consequence, you do that. There’s a lot to talk about, but let’s keep it moving.
The second point is—and this is also a hard pill to swallow—you have to be worthy of respect. If we know that respect is naturally not there, for the most part we have to teach it to them. Yes, we all also have to be somebody who is worthy of respect. That means you shouldn’t walk around talking badly about yourself, just lazing around, wearing clothes that make you look like a schmata (rag), and telling your kids or your spouse, “I’m nothing. I’m a loser.” Or knocking other people, talking in a non-dignified way, or using, God forbid, foul language. Of course they’re not going to respect you. Why should they respect somebody like that?
And, like I mentioned in class number two, especially if you don’t respect your spouse, this is where they’re learning from you. You want to have the best of both worlds: they learn everything from you, but not the bad ones. It doesn’t work like that. They learn everything from you. So if you talk nasty to your spouse, there you go. They learn, “Disrespect is great. That’s the way we do it. You said Mommy is whatever, so I say you’re whatever.” That’s just how it is. A little harsh, but, you know, it’s important.
The last point is that the way you relate to your children is very important. This whole buddy-buddy thing is no good. I hear people talking, whether it’s in our circles or on the net. I hear how people talk: “Hey, pal, can I talk to you? Hey, pal, pal. Could you want to come here for a minute? We’ll talk. Hey, pal. Hey, pal. Hey, buddy.” When your child is your pal and your buddy, and that’s what you want—and I’m not saying what’s wrong and right right now, even though there is a wrong and right; I’m not saying that—but if you want them to be your buddy and your pal or best friends, and you’ll go to the game together and you’re buddies, then they’ll treat you like a buddy. Sometimes they’re upset at their buddy and they’ll yell at them. Sometimes, if you hit your buddy, they’re going to hit you back or they’re going to be upset. “What kind of friendship is this? I don’t want this friendship. I’m done with this.”
So you have to understand: if you want that buddy-buddy relationship, which the goyim (non-Jews) have introduced to us, unfortunately, it comes with a price. And Rabbi Dessler says that’s the reason why hitting has gone out the window: if you hit your buddy, he hits you back. But the Torah perspective is that your child is not your buddy. You know what your child is? Your child, and you’re the authority. You’re the father or mother. That means it’s a whole different relationship. You have a father-mother relationship, a father-child relationship, not buddy-buddy. So of course you have to be warm—we can talk about that another time—and be loving and caring. It’s not a contradiction. “Let’s go hang out. Let’s go talk. Let’s go schmooze (chat). Let’s go to a game.” Whatever it is that we do, I’m the boss and I call the shots. If you want something, I’ll think about it, whatever that might be. I’m in charge here. I’m in charge, but there has to be a balance. Everything has to be balanced, and we’ll talk about that another time. I just want to get the points across.
So, number one, authority has to be taught. Number two, you have to be someone who is worthy of respect. And number three, if you want them to respect you as a father or mother, then you have to relate to them as a father or mother, which is, “I am the boss now.” Don’t say those words, “I’m the boss, and listen to me.” I don’t take anything out of context here. We’ll talk about the balance of discipline and love another time. Be wise, be patient, pray to Hashem, and you should have wonderful, wonderful children.