Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Marriage Series with Rav Ali Cohen. I'm Rav Ali Cohen, a marriage counselor. 917-837-0102 is the number to call if you want to make a session or discuss any marriage-related questions or issues or whatever it is. There's no reason to hold back. I know many people have been calling, which is great, and they're finally getting help. It's nice, but in a sense, it hurts me when people call and say, “I've been dealing with this for 15 years,” and I'm like, “Well, why did you wait so long?” They say, “I don't know. We thought of speaking to someone, then we did, and it didn't work out, and I don't know.” Why would you do that? I don't. Most of the time, it's simple stuff. Most of the time, people have basic questions. There are complicated questions, but you get the point.
So today, I want to talk about a concept that is very, very important. It's called the Mine, Yours, and Ours concept. Rabbi Shimon Gruen shlita (may he live long), the greatest marriage counselor on the planet. That's my opinion. You can take it or leave it. If you feel like John Gottman is great, then that's your opinion. I don't. If you don't know who he is, then good, because I don't. Whatever.
Mine, Yours, and Ours. Who decides what in every relationship? That's the question. Who decides what? Whose decision is it? Do I decide what my spouse wears, or do they decide? Do I decide whether I can tell them not to work in a certain area, or can I not? Do I decide how to raise the children, or do they decide? All these things—all these things—whose decision is it?
Hopefully, with Hashem's help, there's a lot to talk about, but I want to put down the basics. For you, the listener, there are three areas in the relationship where decisions have to be made, and each one has a different decision-maker. It's complex, but I feel like this is the foundation of a healthy marriage. This is, like, number one.
There's mine. My decisions are things that pertain directly to me, which means the clothes that I wear, the job that I choose, the way that I eat, the foods that I eat, and the people that I talk to. Those directly affect me. That is my decision. Nobody could tell me how to be. Nobody else can tell me how to be. Of course, I'm not talking about extreme and wild situations where I want to be an alcoholic and I want to talk to dangerous people. I'm not talking about that. I'm talking about regular stuff that falls in the category of normalcy, acceptable in the world. That's my decision.
Even though it indirectly affects my spouse, because they have to look at the clothes that I'm wearing, that's my decision. It's not for you to decide what I eat or consume because you don't like that food, or because what I eat bothers you. But at the end of the day, I'm the one eating it. So why are you?
“You're the one who's deciding because you're my spouse, and you have to witness it.” I hear that. But again, why am I losing my decision to eat something that I'm the one consuming? I'm the one putting the clothes on, and I lost my ability to decide because you don't like how it looks? I hear that, but why am I not deciding? It's so illogical to me to think otherwise. My classes became shorter because a lot of these things are such no-brainers.
The second area is yours. Even though I'm affected by you, it's the same thing in reverse, but indirectly. I don't have a right to tell you how to operate in anything that involves yourself.
And then there's the ours. This is where it's at, where the relationship is at. We both share decisions: how to raise the children, where to live, where to send the kids to school, which doctor to use for the... If we're going to get one car, that's a shared thing. Anything that applies directly to both of us. Let's say it applies to both of us, whether it matters physically or not. Both parties have a right and a say in how things go down. And that's where the relationship is made and created and built: we come together.
“I feel like we should be tough with the kids.” “I feel like we should be soft.” Okay, they're my kids—and your kids; they're our kids. And now we have to come up with something: a compromise. Work it out together. Figure it out. Talk to a third party.
But I'm not going to go and say, “Yeah, okay, let's do it your way because you're stronger than me and scarier.” No, I'm not going to cower down because you're stronger. And saying, “We have to be tough in this house. This is my house. That's the way that I saw it as a kid. And that's the way...” Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. One second. I don't care about your upbringing, and I don't care about your ideas. I care about... I have my... Also, my way... My way of doing things. And you're just louder. So you have an opinion, I have an opinion, and let's calm down, think about this, and discuss it in a mature manner like adults.
The definition of maturity is being able to hear somebody else and not sit in your think box the rest of your life. That's... by definition, go Google that. Maturity.
The idea of decision-making in a relationship is complex in the Hashkafa (philosophy), but once you get it down, it becomes very, very simple. It's not a matter of taking a tag and putting it on each thing. Is that my lamp? Is that your lamp? Is that my...? No, no, no. Decision-making. I often mention cell phones, too. Each one has their own cell phone. You have no right to tell me that you want to look through my cell phone. This is my thing. I have a right to my privacy. I have a right to my decision. What applies to me.
Of course, like I said, everything has to be done the right way: without going against the Torah, without going against the Hashkafa, and without going outside normalcy. To wear a clown suit and say, “That's me”—that's insane. To wear a pink shirt when many people are wearing pink shirts for a man. Again, I'm not going into Hashkafa and halacha (Jewish law). A checkered shirt that the wife doesn't like. “I mean, but people wear checkered shirts.” “Yeah, but it's ugly.” You think it's ugly. So why are you getting...?
Again, like I said in the beginning, Mine, Yours, and Ours should be clearly understood. It is complicated, and people do feel like, “Ah, what is this? What kind of relationship is this now? We have to split things.” It's not about splitting things up. It's healthy that each person is an individual. When they get married, you remain an individual. That didn't change. But now, what changed is the shared area. The shared area is what changed. I remain myself, and you remain yourself. But now we come together with shared things, trying to work it out, compromising, talking to a rabbi, and working things out in the shared area.
But when people cross the line into mine and yours, that's where marital strife kicks in and gets heavy. “I told you not to wear that. I told you not to talk to him. I told you to go over there. I told you not to go there.” Why are we demanding things of people that apply to themselves? “You're going to wear those shoes? You're actually going to wear those?” That's where the fights really begin. And the shared area doesn't really become, for the most part, a fight, because it's pretty clear that it applies to both.
So be wise. Be patient. Think about these concepts. This is advanced stuff, but it's important that everyone should know it. Have a wonderful relationship.

