A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Marriage Series 5: Roles In Marriage

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
October 12, 2024
Duration
7:31
Lecture code
sb-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome everyone back to the iTorah Marriage Series with Rabbi Ali Cohen, class number 5: the roles of men and women. I see a lot of people getting mixed up about these ideas, so I’m going to lay out the basics as clearly as possible. I do marriage counseling if you’d like to speak with me: 917-837-0102. Or you have a question on this class or any marriage-related topic, as they are sensitive topics. A class is really just a side point for hearing something and implementing it. I hear so many people hearing ideas and implementing them wrong; it’s just not good. You have to talk to a third party, reach out, and clarify something before you implement anything in your marriage.

There are two points today about the roles of men and women. The first point is the basics of what it says in the Torah. The rabbis say that the woman is the Akeret; her function is to give stability to the home in its physical sense: the house, making sure it’s running properly, the kids. Anything pertaining to the house is the woman’s function. Nowadays, it has become, like, “It’s annoying and it’s overwhelming.” The right perspective on Hashkafah (Torah outlook) is that, as Rabbi Avigdor Miller zatzal (of blessed memory) says, a woman should feel like she is the Kohen Gadol (High Priest) doing Avodah (service) in the Beit HaMikdash (Holy Temple). The house is a mini Beit HaMikdash. It’s a Mishkan (Tabernacle), a Mishkan Me’at (miniature sanctuary), as they call it. She is doing the work of the house. It’s not just, “Clean it and then mop it.” It’s to make sure the kids are healthy and functioning so they can grow up happy, healthy Torah people, people of the Torah. It’s not just about having it clean so it smells nice. It’s to make sure everyone is growing properly in Torah and Yirat Shamayim (fear of Heaven). It’s a holy job. Don’t belittle it. Don’t let the world mess you up. It’s a very holy job. The more you feel a responsibility toward the house, the better you’ll feel.

Now, does this mean women don’t work? No. Does it mean men don’t help out? No. Women can work, and men should help out. That’s not what it means. It means your main function. The woman’s main function is the home. If you’re going out to work, you should make sure the house is taken care of. It comes naturally to women. That’s why Hashem gave wives—women—these abilities. Utilizing your capabilities is something that should be done.

Now, the man’s responsibility is as it says in the Ketubah (marriage contract). Everybody listening, I’m saying basic stuff. I’m not saying anything of my own right now. This is like the ABCs. The man’s responsibility is to support his wife. It says, “I will work and support.” He should support you emotionally, support you physically, and give you whatever you need. Now, what about different scenarios? What if he’s not bringing in enough money? What if he’s working hard and the money isn’t coming in? It’s not his responsibility to rob a bank. He has to go out to work. He doesn’t say, “I will guarantee money.” Hashem guarantees the money. There are no guarantees. Hashem is the one who decides. We just had Rosh Hashanah (Jewish New Year), and Hashem decided.

Ladies, you’re listening. Hashem decides how much money your husband makes. He’s not in charge of that. Don’t beat him up. Go to Hashem and say, “Hashem, what’s going on here?” Daven to him. Pray to him. Don’t beat your husband up. He has a responsibility to go out and work, to try his best to bring in the money. That is his function. This is step number one. Again, does it mean women don’t work? No. Does it mean men have to make more money? I mean, if there’s a man who isn’t making enough money, is he not fulfilling his function? No.

Point number two: people get confused about who’s the boss of the house. That’s nonsense. That’s garbage. It’s poison. It’s going to mess you up. There’s no ruler. There’s no dictator in a Torah home. Nobody controls anybody in a Torah home. Even when it comes to kids, it’s very sensitive. But with a husband and wife, nobody controls anyone. The man has a responsibility. He’s responsible for the spiritual growth of the home and for setting the tone. He has to set the tone and show everyone the right way. He’s responsible. It’s his responsibility to make sure everybody is fed, has food, is clothed, and is happy. And if his wife needs his help, emotional support, he’s responsible for that. Is he controlling? No. If he says something, it must be done, and that’s it? Nobody has a say? No. That’s not a Torah concept.

Respect is brought down by the Rambam, quoted from a Gemara. Respect. The man and the wife have to respect each other tremendously, more than they respect themselves. Do you control someone you respect? Would you control somebody you respect? No. Rabbi Miller uses a phrase, and a lot of Gedolim (great rabbis) use these words: the man is the captain and the wife is the co-captain. That means they’re both running the ship. There are situations where there’s going to be a discrepancy. Of course, everything is done with a rabbi. The man has, let’s call it, the upper hand—which I’m saying very, very delicately—but the man will have, let’s say, the upper hand. That has to be taken with extreme caution. Everybody’s word is important. Communicate what you want, without forcing anyone or being very repetitive, because there is no control in a marriage. There’s no relationship with control. It’s very, very important to understand these two points. There’s a lot to talk about, and everyone’s dynamics are different. There are women who are more dominant and stronger, and men who are much more passive. There are so many different variables and variations in marriages and dynamics. You need to reach out to someone if you have a problem and get stuck.

The two points are that the woman is called the Akeret HaBayit, and her function is to take care of the home. The man’s function is to go out and work. Of course, there’s kollel (Torah study program) and yeshiva. That also needs to be dealt with separately. Then there is the man’s responsibility to make sure there’s stability in the home. Nobody is controlling anyone in the home. Everybody’s opinion is important, discussed, and taken into account.

I know I’ve said this, and I’ve probably said it a lot of times, but this gets so mixed up. Men, if you’re listening, you should not be telling your wives, “You have to listen to me because I’m the man. Go get me something from the kitchen. Go get me this.” Rabbi Miller makes fun of that in his 10 commandments of marriage: “You have two feet; get up and get your thing yourself.” If she wants to be an Eshet Chayil (woman of valor) and you ask her nicely, “Could you please get it for me?” that’s great.

So just the real, real, real touching the surface and the basics, the question of who’s the boss is just a mistake. It’s just confusion. It just gets people messed up. Understand that everybody has to respect each other. Forget about discussing who’s the boss, and discuss respect. Everyone has an obligation. This is a chiyuv, obligation, to respect each other. Think about this. Be wise, be patient, and make sure to have a wonderful relationship.