A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Duvi BenSoussan

Torah Lecture

“The Bklyn College Chanukah Recap - It’s Chanukah Gmar Chatima Tova”

Lectured by Rabbi Duvi BenSoussan

Published
December 2, 2021
Duration
67:10
Lecture code
RDB-594

Chanukah and Jewish Identity

  • Rabbi Duvi BenSoussan says he hopes to offer chizuk (strengthening) that will help Jews continue to stand up for what they believe in. Chanukah reminds Klal Yisrael who they are: like oil, Jews do not mix into the societies around them but rise to the top and illuminate the world.
  • The Chanukah lights recall the Jewish mission to be a light unto the nations, especially in times of darkness. Looking at the menorah can also remind a person of the ambitions he had when young—to accomplish great things for Klal Yisrael and perhaps become a gadol—and that he may still become such a source of light.

The Bat Ayin and His Connection to Tzfat

  • Rabbi BenSoussan introduces the Bat Ayin, Avraham Dov ben Reb David me'Avritch, known as the Avricher. After coming from Europe to Eretz Yisrael and spending a short time in Yerushalayim, he visited Tzfat during Elul.
  • The Bat Ayin was so moved by Tzfat that he stayed for Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Yom HaDin, and Aseret Yemei Teshuvah. Though he planned to return to his family in Yerushalayim, he kept extending his stay until after Sukkot.
  • After Shemini Atzeret, he heard a Jewish woman urge her son to take belongings off the roof because Klal Yisrael had benched Geshem the day before and rain was coming. The Bat Ayin was struck by her temimut and emunah peshutah: she trusted the prayer so completely that she hurried to prepare for rain.
  • He decided to remain in Tzfat and sent word to his family that they would have to come there if they wanted to see him. He eventually became Rav of Tzfat.

The 1837 Earthquake in Tzfat

  • In the 1837 earthquake, many of Tzfat’s shuls were destroyed, and graves in the famous cemetery near the Arizal were lost beneath the rubble. Rabbi BenSoussan notes that some graves are now marked by blue boxes without names because it is unknown which tzaddikim were buried there.
  • The Bat Ayin was in his shul, standing before the Aron Kodesh, when the earthquake struck. He called for anyone who wanted to live to run to him, lay down by the Aron Kodesh, and cried out tefillot to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.
  • The shul collapsed up to the area where he lay, but that spot was untouched. A plaque in the shul identifies the place where the Bat Ayin lay and says that the miracle saved the congregation.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan says that a place where the Eibershter has brought miracles is a makom of et ratzon, and that visitors can daven there.

Yehuda and Tamar: The Peshat

  • Rabbi BenSoussan turns to the story in parashat Vayeshev, which he describes as difficult to teach to children and bachurim. He relates the peshat of the pesukim: Tamar married Yehuda’s son Er, who died, and then married Onan through yibum; Onan also died.
  • Yehuda had one son left, Shelah, and feared that he too would die if given to Tamar. Although Tamar was zakuk to Shelah for yibum, or to chalitza, Yehuda delayed and made excuses, saying Shelah was too young.
  • Tamar disguised herself, waited by the roadside, and was with Yehuda. When he later sent his friend, the Ish Adullami, with payment to retrieve the eravon he had given her—his signet, staff, and clothing—she was no longer there.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan cautions that the maaseh involving the shevatim cannot be understood by simply humanizing them or assuming that ordinary people can fathom them. Nevertheless, this is the peshat of the Torah and the account given by Chazal and the Midrash.
  • After about three months, Tamar began to show her pregnancy. People told Yehuda that she had been promiscuous and was expecting a child from zenut. Yehuda, who Chazal says was the av beit din, ordered: “Hotzi'uha v'tisaref.” Rabbi BenSoussan explains that the s'reifah meant burning her insides with a hot coal placed down her throat, not burning her in a fiery furnace.
  • As Tamar was being taken out, she sent Yehuda the items he had given her and said, “Haker-na, l'mi hachotemet v'hapetilim v'hamateh ha'eleh”—“Recognize, please, whose signet, cords, and staff these are.”
  • The words “Haker-na” recalled Yehuda’s earlier words to Yaakov Avinu when he presented the bloodied ketonet pasim and asked his father to recognize it. Rabbi BenSoussan emphasizes that the words Yehuda had used in the maaseh Yosef to hurt his father had now returned to him.
  • Yehuda recognized not only his belongings but the connection between the two events. He said, “Tzadkah mimeni”—she is right and he is wrong.
  • The Midrash says a Bat Kol came from Shamayim and promised Yehuda, “Chayecha v'chayei banecha … mimcha melachim yetze'u”: from him would come the kings of Klal Yisrael.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan presents Yehuda’s admission as an act of extraordinary gevurah. Yehuda could have denied responsibility, citing his position as av beit din, the risk of chillul Hashem, and the shame and harm to his family and kavod haTorah. Instead, he admitted the truth and recognized that Tamar had acted out of desperation because he had withheld Shelah from her.

The Bat Ayin’s Chanukah Teaching

  • Rabbi BenSoussan presents a teaching of the Bat Ayin in the name of the Arizal HaKadosh. The Bat Ayin reads “Vayehi k'mishlosh chadashim” as referring not only to the three months in the story of Tamar, but also to the final sealing of the gezerot for every Jew.
  • The Bat Ayin distinguishes among the stages of judgment: neilah on Yom Kippur was the chatimah, Hoshana Rabbah was the gemar chatimah, and Chanukah is the final, final chatimah, when the gezerot for the coming year are sent out for execution.
  • The first month is Tishrei, the second Cheshvan, and the third Kislev. Thus, the end of Kislev—Chanukah—is, in this teaching, the final gemar din and the last opportunity to change the judgment for Klal Yisrael.
  • At that final judgment, the prosecutor appears. The Bat Ayin identifies him as the Samech-Mem, the Malach HaMavet, the Sar shel Esav, and the yetzer hara.
  • The Bat Ayin reads “Vayugad liYehuda lemor” as the yetzer hara bringing an accusation before Hashem. In this interpretation, Yehuda represents the Ribbono Shel Olam, and Tamar represents Klal Yisrael, whom Shir HaShirim calls “damta le-tamar,” a verse recited by Sefardim every Friday night.
  • The prosecution is expressed through “Zantah Tamar kalatecha”: Klal Yisrael has fallen into averot and ta'avot. The further accusation, “hinei harah liznunim,” is that they are attached to their ta'avot and immersed in sin.
  • Hashem’s response, in the Bat Ayin’s reading, is that if the accusation is true, judgment should take its course. At this last stage of judgment, things appear bleak for Klal Yisrael.
  • Klal Yisrael’s answer is that they are not truly attached to their averot; they are attached to Hashem. They may fall because of the tirda ha-parnasah and the difficult nisyonot of galut, but sin is not their deepest attachment.
  • The Bat Ayin points to the Chanukah mitzvah as evidence: Klal Yisrael waited for pure oil rather than using tamei-dike oil, and performs the mitzvah mehadrin min hamehadrin. He also emphasizes the care and halachot connected with the menorah, including its wicks.
  • The Bat Ayin reads the items in Tamar’s message—the chotemet, ptilim, and mateh—as pointing toward the Chanukah mitzvah and its menorah. The menorah is the evidence Klal Yisrael presents in the heavenly courtroom that they are connected to Hashem and His mitzvot.
  • Hashem’s answer is again “Tzadkah mimeni”: Klal Yisrael is right. In this teaching, Hashem acknowledges that the people’s failings are connected to the long galut and the fact that Mashiach has not yet been brought, rather than to an essential attachment to sin.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan relates this to the pressures of the present day, including leftism, liberalism, social media, and billboards in New York City. He says that after enduring a long galut and the threats of nations that sought to wipe them out, Jews may fall, but they remain attached to Hashem.
  • The Chanukah menorah, in the Bat Ayin’s teaching, is the decisive testimony and the winning ta'anah in the final judgment. Rabbi BenSoussan says this should change how a person stands before the menorah: its light is an opportunity to daven and seek an et ratzon for the coming year.
  • He adds that his rabbi taught him that Chanukah ends without Havdalah, unlike Sukkot, Pesach, and Shabbat, because its light is meant to accompany and influence the entire year. He describes Chanukah as establishing the final neilah for the year.

Remaining Distinct in a World of Outside Influence

  • Rabbi BenSoussan says Chanukah also reminds Jews who they are, whether they are walking the streets of Brooklyn or returning to campus. Like oil, Klal Yisrael must not lose its distinctiveness; the holiday recalls the struggle to push away darkness and stand with a pure light.
  • He describes students who have called him about problems that began with something seemingly innocent, such as a smile or doing homework together. Some say they agreed because they did not want to seem abnormal or cause a chillul Hashem.
  • He invokes the Ben Ish Chai’s answer to the question of whether every generation is out to kill the Jews. The Ben Ish Chai says the question has it backwards: in some generations the threat comes by the sword, and in others it comes with a smile; the methods differ, but the result is the same.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan says Jews must be careful not to forget who they are when surrounded by people and influences outside the Jewish community. He compares a Jew to an eagle among chickens and urges Jews to carry themselves with that awareness.
  • He tells a parable about a farmer who finds a large egg and places it under a hen. An eaglet hatches alongside chicks, grows up following the hen and the chickens, and pecks at seeds in the mud because that is what everyone else does.
  • When the eaglet sees a magnificent eagle flying high, it wishes it could soar too. The hen tells it to put its head back in the mud and behave like the others. Rabbi BenSoussan says Chanukah tells Jews instead to lift their heads and remember that they are eagles, meant to soar.
  • He warns against wanting to imitate celebrities, their music, their fashions, and their idols. He mocks the desire to look, speak, and dress like celebrities whose lives are marked by repeated trips to rehab or brief marriages, and to buy watches bearing their names.
  • Chanukah, he says, pulls back the curtain on that imitation and reminds Jews who they are and what they are meant to be. He invokes the line, “Remember who you are,” and says that the long galut and its tests make this reminder necessary year after year.

The Target Parking Lot Story

  • Rabbi BenSoussan recalls that he commuted to Lakewood for 16 years while his children attended a good yeshiva there, spending every Shabbat at his in-laws. Years later, he moved back to Brooklyn for the shul.
  • One Wednesday, while driving on Route 9 past Target in Howell, he saw about 30 or 40 tents lined up in the parking lot in freezing weather, around 30 degrees. He took the jughandle and drove around to investigate.
  • A man explained that people were waiting for Black Friday. Target would give a free Wii to the first 50 people through the doors at 5 a.m. Friday. The Wii was back-ordered and could be resold online for north of $600 or $700.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan questioned whether two freezing days on concrete were worth the potential profit. The man repeated that he was there for the Wii. Rabbi BenSoussan noted the tent, kerosene lamp, kerosene warmer, and canned beans, and recognized one of the campers as a Jewish young man.
  • Feeling troubled as he returned to Lakewood and ate supper while the young man stayed in the cold with beans, Rabbi BenSoussan asked his wife to pack up the meal. He drove back to Howell at night and brought the food to tent number 27.
  • The young man welcomed him in, and they ate together by the kerosene lamp. Rabbi BenSoussan offered to learn with him from the Beis Halevi he had brought. The young man was enthusiastic about having night seder in the Target parking lot.
  • They learned for an hour to an hour and a half. Afterwards, the young man asked, “What in the world am I doing here?” Rabbi BenSoussan says the learning had brought light into his mind and neshamah and reminded him that he was an eagle, not a chicken waiting in the mud for a Wii.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan joked that the tent, lamp, and beans represented substantial costs, while the young man still faced a deficit of roughly $500–$600. He urged him to give up the plan and return to learning.
  • It took them 45 minutes to take down the tent. Rabbi BenSoussan intended to bring the young man home to Lakewood, provide him with a warm room and a shower, and return him to Brooklyn the next day, where he belonged in the “sky of Torah” rather than the “mud” of the parking lot.
  • As they left, other campers called out, “You’re leaving?” Rabbi BenSoussan told the young man to remember their words and the significance of leaving. He presents the experience as an example of how the light of Torah can wake someone up and help him return to who he is.
  • He describes the Or HaTorah as the light of Chanukah: it pushes away darkness, helps a person straighten out his thinking, and reminds him to clean the mud away and return to the sky where he belongs.

Fighting for Torah and the Final Chatimah

  • Rabbi BenSoussan praises the campus rabbi as a fighter for Torah, Yiddishkeit, and the students. He says the rabbi called him six times in six minutes to arrange the lecture, reflecting his determination not to give up on them.
  • Rabbi BenSoussan urges the audience to use the opportunity of Chanukah’s gemar chatimah and to remind one another who they are. He says the Arizal and the Bat Ayin would describe this moment as a final sealing, and emphasizes that the desired chatimah is a lichtige one: a chance to illuminate the world together while awaiting Mashiach.
Words in this lecture3
Hanukkahחנוכה
Terms Chanukah, the eight-day festival of lights celebrating the Maccabees' victory and the miracle of the oil. English: Festival of dedication
Also written: Chanukah, Hanukah
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem
Segulahסגולה
Terms Segulah, a practice believed to bring a blessing or protection.
Also written: Segula, Segulla, Sgula
Plural: Segulot, Segulos, Segullot, segulas, segulahs