The
Torah commands in Parashat Vayikra (2:11), “Kol Se’or Ve’chol Debash Lo Taktiru
Mimenu Isheh l’Hashem” – “you shall not offer as a fire-offering to G-d any
leaven or honey.” This verse establishes
a prohibition against offering on the altar any leavened product, or any sweet
product. “Debash” (“honey”) in the Torah
normally refers specifically to the juice extracted from dates, but in this
context, it includes any sweet food item.
All sweet products may not be offered on the altar.
This
prohibition forbids not only directly placing sweet products on the altar, but
also including sweeteners among the ingredients of the Ketoret (incense).
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch offers several different approaches to explain the reasoning
behind this command.
First,
he suggests that Hametz symbolizes laziness.
Dough rises and ferments when it sits for a period of time without being
handled, and thus Hametz is the result of inactivity. By banning Hametz from the altar, the Torah
expresses to us the importance of zeal, energy and alacrity in the service of
G-d. For this reason, the Sefer
Ha’hinuch explains, the Torah allows Hametz to be brought as a public offering:
on Shabuot, a special sacrifice called the “Korban Sheteh Ha’lehem” was
offered, which consisted of two loaves of leavened bread. When it comes to a communal project, people
feed off each other’s energy, and so there is no need to warn about the dangers
of laziness. This warning is needed only
in the private, personal realm, and so leaven is not allowed in the framework
of individual sacrifices. The Sefer
Ha’hinuch notes that the Lehem Ha’panim – the showbread which was placed on the
Shulhan (table) in the Bet Ha’mikdash – was a public offering which was
nevertheless baked unleavened. He
explains that since the Lehem Ha’panim was constantly on the Shulhan, it was
made unleavened in order to reinforce the lesson of the dangers of laziness.
As
for the prohibition against offering sweet products, the Sefer Ha’hinuch
explains that this conveys the message that we should strive to limit our
consumption of sweet food products. Of
course, we need to eat in order to survive, but we must do just that – eat so
we can live, as opposed to living so we can eat. We are to avoid gluttony and overindulgence,
and exercise moderation in our enjoyment of food, and so the Torah forbade
offering sweet food products on the altar, as a symbol of the need to curb our
lust for tasty food.
Secondly,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, leavened and sweet products both represent
arrogance. Dough rises when it ferments,
and honey naturally forms bubbles that rise above the surface. The Torah therefore forbade offering these
products on the altar to express the need to eliminate arrogance, as the verse
states, “To’abat Hashem Kol Gebah Leb” – “Everyone haughty of heart is
abominable to G-d” (Mishleh 16:5).
Thirdly,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch cites the Ramban as commenting that G-d wants only that
which is in its natural, organic form to be placed on the altar. Leavened bread is the product of flour which
has been altered and engineered by yeast, and so it forbids bringing leavened products
on the altar. As for sweet products, the
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that sweetness represents extremes, which we must
avoid. G-d created the world in such a
way that it requires a delicate balance between different extremes, such as
between Din (strict justice) and Rahamim (mercy). We are therefore commanded not to offer sweet
products on the altar, representing the need to avoid extreme behavior.
The
Torah forbids offering “Mimenu” (literally, “of it”), which the Sages
understood to mean that even the smallest amount of Hametz or sweet products
may not be placed on the altar. Even if
a small amount is mixed with other food, the mixture may not be offered.
The
prohibition forbids only offering leaven or sweet products as part of a
sacrifice; such products may be placed on the altar as fuel, to sustain the
fire.
In
listing this command, the Sefer Ha’hinuch follows the view of the Rambam, that
these two prohibitions – offering Hametz and offering sweet products –
constitute a single Biblical command. In
his view, one who at once places both leaven and a sweet product on the altar
is liable to only a single set of Malkut.
The Ramban, however, disagrees, and maintains that these should be
counted as two separate Biblical commands.
In his opinion, one who places Hametz and a sweet product on the altar
at the same time receives two sets of Malkut.
Needless
to say, this prohibition applies only in the times of the Bet Ha’mikdash, and
applies only to the Kohanim.