The
Torah commands in Parashat Vayakhel (Shemot 35:3), “Lo Teba’aru Esh Be’chol
Moshebotechem Be’yom Ha’Shabbat” – “Do not burn fire in any of your residences
on the day of Shabbat.”
At
first glance, it appears that the Torah here introduces the prohibition against
kindling a fire on Shabbat. However, the
Gemara notes that this cannot be the meaning of the verse, because kindling
fire on Shabbat is already included under the general prohibition forbidding
Melacha (work) on Shabbat, as kindling is among the thirty-nine forms of
Melacha. Moreover, the Torah here
specifies “Moshebotechem” – “your residences,” and kindling fire is, of course,
forbidden on Shabbat everywhere. The
Gemara therefore explains that the Torah here addresses Bet Din, and forbids
the court from executing an offender who deserves the punishment of Serefa
(execution through fire). The word
“Moshabot” is used as a reference to Bet Din, and thus the Torah here commands
that Bet Din may not execute offenders through Serefa on Shabbat, and that they
should instead delay the execution until after Shabbat. The Sages established that this command is
not limited only to Serefa, but rather applies to all punishments administered
by Bet Din, forbidding Bet Din from punishing any offenders on Shabbat.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that this is forbidden because G-d wants us to respect
Shabbat by having all people – even the sinners – enjoy rest on this day. Indeed, the Rabbis tell us that even the
sinners in Gehinam are granted a respite from their punishment each week on
Shabbat. One of the expressions of the
special status and sanctity of Shabbat is that everybody is given the
opportunity to rest on this day, even the sinners who deserve to be punished.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that if Bet Din executes an offender on Shabbat, then
since this was not allowed on Shabbat, the executioner is guilty of desecrating
Shabbat. Like all Shabbat violators, he
is liable to Sekila (death by stoning) if he transgressed intentionally, and
must bring a sin-offering if he committed this violation mistakenly.
The
Rambam, in Hilchot Shabbat (24:7), clarifies that this prohibition applies not
only to capital punishment, but also to Malkut (lashes). Even though whipping somebody does not entail
any Melacha, this punishment may not be administered on Shabbat. This explains why the prohibition against
punishing offenders is counted as a separate Biblical command. At first glance, one might have assumed that
once the Torah forbids administering punishment on Shabbat, a court that does
administer punishment has violated the prohibition against violating
Shabbat. As such, there is no reason to
list a separate prohibition against punishing offenders. But once the Rambam clarifies that this
prohibition includes administering Malkut, we understand why this is considered
a separate prohibition. If Bet Din
administers Malkut on Shabbat, they are not guilty of Shabbat desecration, but
they have transgressed the separate prohibition against punishing offenders on
Shabbat.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that even the judges who instructed the court official
to administer punishment on Shabbat are in violation of this command, simply by
giving the instruction. However, they do
not receive punishment, because they transgressed the command without
committing an action.