The
Torah in Parashat Vayikra (4:13) speaks of a case where “the entire nation
mistakenly sins” because “a matter was concealed from the ‘eyes’ [leaders] of
the congregation.” This refers to a
situation where the Sanhedrin – the highest Rabbinical court, consisting of
seventy-one leading scholars – issued a mistaken ruling, permitting something
which is forbidden and punishable by Karet (eternal excision from the Jewish
Nation). If the majority of the nation
accepts their ruling and violates the prohibition in question on the basis of
this mistaken ruling, then a special atonement sacrifice must be offered, consisting
of a bull, called the “Par He’alem Dabar Shel Sibur.”
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that if the great Rabbis of the Sanhedrin issued a
mistaken ruling, this reflects a deficiency in their intellect, which in turn
indicates that their physical beings overpowered, if only somewhat, their
intellectual faculties. An intellectual
error testifies to the intellect’s having been subdued by one’s physical
essence. The offering of a sacrifice
symbolizes the need to subdue our animalistic, physical qualities, and to
instead elevate and enhance our spiritual beings. Therefore, when the Sanhedrin errs, a special
sacrifice is brought to remind them of the primacy of the Sechel (intellect)
and that it must never yield to our base, physical inclinations.
This
obligation applies only if all seventy-one members of the Sanhedrin issued the
mistaken ruling, together with the Ab Bet Din (head of the court). All seventy-one members had to have been
eligible to sit on the Sanhedrin, to the exclusion of Gerim (converts), those
of advanced age, and others who are disqualified from serving on the Sanhedrin. Moreover, this sacrifice is required only if
the majority of the nation accepted the ruling, trusting and relying on the
Sanhedrin’s wisdom and scholarship. If
the people figured that the Sanhedrin issued an erroneous ruling, but they
decided to nevertheless act upon the mistaken leniency, then this Misva does not
apply.
Furthermore,
this obligation applies only if the Sanhedrin mistakenly concluded that
something was permissible, but not if they denied the prohibition in
question. For example, if the Sanhedrin
determined that Heleb – animal fat which the Torah strictly forbids – is
actually permissible for consumption, then the sacrifice is not offered. The sacrifice is required only if the
Sanhedrin wrongly determined that a certain part of the animal is not included
in the Heleb prohibition, when it in fact is considered Heleb and forbidden.
This
command applies only if Bet Din is aware of the precise ruling which they
issued and which turned out to be mistaken.
If they acknowledge in a general sense that they had made a mistake,
this sacrifice is not offered; they must be able to specify to the particular
error that was made.
In
a case requiring a “Par He’alem Dabar Shel Sibur,” each of the twelve tribes
must offer this sacrifice. If the
mistaken ruling permitted a certain action which in fact constitutes forbidden
idol worship, then in addition to this sacrifice, each tribe must also offer a
goat to atone for mistakenly violating the prohibition against foreign worship.
This
Misva applied only when the Sanhedrin convened in its office in the Lishkat
Ha’gazit – the special chamber in the courtyard of the Bet Ha’mikdash
designated for the Sanhedrin. Forty
years before the destruction of the second Bet Ha’mikdash, the Sanhedrin was
exiled from the Lishkat Ha’gazit, and ever since that time, this Misva has not
applied.