The Sefer Ha’hinuch lists as the 59th Biblical command the
obligation upon Bet Din to preside over cases involving a “Shomer Sachar”
(“paid watchman”) and a “Socher” (“renter”), and to rule according to the
Torah’s guidelines.
Both a person who is paid to watch something, and one who pays for the right
to use an item, receive benefit from the arrangement, and therefore bear a
higher level of liability than somebody who watches an object voluntarily,
without pay (a “Shomer Hinam”). As the
Torah establishes in Parashat Mishpatim (22:9), if the object is lost or
stolen, the Shomer Sachar or Socher must pay the owner the value of the
item. However, if the item was lost due
to an “Oness” – circumstances beyond the watchman or renter’s control, such as
in the case of armed robbery, or of an animal that died of natural causes, the
watchman or renter is absolved of liability.
He must, however, take an oath that he was not negligent in caring for
the item.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch mentions numerous different details that apply to
this law. We present here a small sampling
of these Halachot.
If a craftsman is given a utensil to repair, and will be receiving
payment for his work, then he is considered a “Shomer Sachar” who is paid for
watching the item. Therefore, if he
ruins the utensil, he is responsible to compensate the owner.
If a money changer receives payment for evaluating coins, and
mistakenly identifies a coin as legitimate currency, when in truth it was
counterfeit, causing a merchant to accept the coin as payment and thereby lose
money, the money changer must compensate the merchant.
If Reuben entrusted an object to Shimon, and Shimon then then gave it
Levi to watch, then if something happens to the item, Shimon – the first
guardian – bears responsibility and must compensate Reuben. Even if Levi watches on a higher standard
than Shimon, nevertheless, Reuben never authorized Levi to watch the item, and
placed his trust only in Shimon. Hence,
Shimon was not entitled to have Levi watch the item, and so he – Shimon – bears
responsibility. An exception to this
rule is that a watchman may have his family members guard the item. When somebody entrusts his object to a
watchman, he understands that the watchman will not home all the time, and so
he implicitly accepts the watchman’s family members as watchmen.
Likewise, a person who rents somebody’s object may not sublease it to
somebody else. However, the Rambam draws
a distinction in this regard between moveable property and homes. When it comes to moveable objects, the owner
can claim that he trusted only the first renter, whereas he was not prepared to
trust the third party, that he would not take the item for himself. A home, by contrast, cannot be “taken,” and
so there is no reason to trust one person any more or less than another person.
Thus, according to the Rambam, one who
rents a home may sublet it without the owner’s knowledge. However, the renter is allowed to sublet the
property only to the same amount of people.
He may not sublet the property to a larger family, because a larger
family causes more wear-and-tear on the home, and the owner can claim that he
was prepared to lease the home only to a certain number of residents, and not
to a higher number of people.