The
Torah in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 22:30) commands that we must not eat “Basar
Ba’sadeh Terefa” – “meat of a devoured animal in the field.” This command prohibits eating meat of a
kosher species of animal which was attacked by a beast and suffered a fatal
injury. However, the Sages understood
that this prohibition applies to an animal with any sort of fatal injury that
is not expected to live for another year.
The Torah gave the most common case of such an animal – where an animal
was attacked out in the field – but the prohibition applies even to animals
suffering from other fatal conditions, and they are all considered “Terefa” and
hence forbidden for consumption.
Additionally,
the Gemara inferred from this verse that any meat which was taken “Ba’sadeh” –
“into the field,” meaning, outside the boundaries of where it is supposed to
remain, becomes forbidden for consumption.
Namely, certain forms of sacrificial meat (“Kodasheh Kodashim”) are to
be eaten specifically in the courtyard of the Bet Ha’mikdash, and other forms
of sacrificial meat (“Kodasheh Kalim”) are to be eaten in the city of
Jerusalem. The Sages inferred from this
verse that sacrificial meat which was taken outside its boundaries – either
outside the Bet Ha’mikdash, or outside Jerusalem, depending on which type of
sacrifice it is – becomes forbidden for consumption. Another example is meat of the Korban Pesach,
which is not to be removed from the Habura – the group which offered the
sacrifice. Meat of the Korban Pesach
which left its designated area has the status of “Terefa” and becomes forbidden
for consumption.
Explaining
the reason behind the prohibition of “Terefa,” the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes that
the Torah forbade activities which are detrimental to our physical health, as
poor physical health adversely affects our minds. Therefore, the Torah forbade eating meat of a
“Terefa,” which is detrimental to the body.
The Sefer Ha’hinuch acknowledges that it is unknown why such meat has an
adverse effect on a person’s physical wellbeing, but he insists that we must
place our trust in G-d, the “dependable Healer,” who is infinitely wiser than
us and medical experts. He has
determined that meat of a “Terefa” is harmful, and for this reason He has
commanded us to refrain from such meat.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch then anticipates that some might wonder how an animal’s meat
could suddenly be considered detrimental to one’s health upon developing a
fatal condition. One moment, the meat is
presumed perfectly healthful, and then the next moment – when the animal
becomes a “Terefa” – it is deemed unhealthful, and some might question how this
could happen. The Sefer Ha’hinuch dismisses
this question, noting that “Le’chol Dabar Hat’hala” – every situation has a
beginning point. If we acknowledge that
food can be healthful at one time and be detrimental at a later time, then
necessarily, we acknowledge that at one point this change occurs. And thus the Torah has determined that when
an animal develops one of the conditions that render it a “Terefa,” from that
moment its meat is presumed detrimental to our wellbeing and thus becomes
forbidden.
The
Gemara in Masechet Hulin discusses the various kinds of physical conditions
which render an animal a “Terefa,” listing 72 different forms of
“Terefot.” There is also an additional
condition which occurs in birds, and thus renders a bird a “Terefa.” Not coincidentally, the prohibition of “Terefa”
is the 73rd Biblical command, alluding to the 73 types of “Terefot.”
This
prohibition is applicable in all times and places, and to both men and
women. Interestingly, the verse in the
Book of Yehezkel (44:31) states, “Kol Nebela U’trefa…Lo Yochelu Ha’kohanim” –
that Kohanim may not eat meat that is from a “Nebela” (carcass of an animal
that perished without proper slaughtering) or a “Terefa.” Of course, these prohibitions apply to all
Jews, and not only to Kohanim. The Sages
explained that Yehezkel clarified that this prohibition applies also to
Kohanim, because they would eat the meat of bird sacrifices in the Bet
Ha’mikdash which were sacrificed through “Melika” – puncturing the back of the
bird’s neck with one’s fingernail. Since
the Kohanim were allowed to eat bird sacrifices which were killed without
proper slaughtering, one might have assumed that they are excluded from the
standard restrictions that apply to the consumption of meat. Therefore, Yehezkel found it necessary to
clarify that even Kohanim, who are permitted to eat the bird sacrifices which
are killed through “Melika,” are forbidden from eating meat of a “Nebela” or
“Terefa.”
One
who eats a Ke’zayit of “Terefa” meat is liable to Malkut. Some Rabbis addressed the question of why
this prohibition does not fall under the category of “Lav She’bi’chlalot” –
Torah prohibitions which encompass more than one command. After all, as mentioned, the prohibition of
“Terefa” includes both meat from an animal with a fatal condition, and
sacrificial meat which was taken outside its designated area. A number of Rishonim, including the Rambam
and Ramban, discussed this question and distinguished between this command and
a “Lav She’bi’chlalot.”
Practically
speaking, an animal that is slaughtered can be presumed not to have any
conditions that would render it a “Terefa,” such that its meat may be eaten
without first inspecting the carcass.
Nevertheless, since lesions on the lungs are common, the lungs are
inspected after the animal is slaughtered to ensure that it did not suffer from
this condition. Inspections for the
other conditions, however, are not necessary.