The
Torah commands in the Book of Shemot (12:15), “Ach Ba’yom Ha’rishon Tashbitu
Se’or Mi’batechem” – that we must eliminate Hametz from our homes “on the first
day” of the festival of Pesach. While
this command at first seems to require eliminating Hametz from our homes only
on the first day of Pesach, the 15th of Nissan, the Gemara (Pesahim
5) explains that in truth, it means that the Hametz must be eliminated by the
onset of the first day of Pesach, and thus this is required already on the 14th
of Nissan, Ereb Pesach.
This
Misva, of course, like the other commands relevant to Pesach, are observed for
the purpose of commemorating the great miracles that G-d performed for our
ancestors at the time of the Exodus from Egypt.
This command applies in all places, and even after the destruction of
the Bet Ha’mikdash. It is binding upon
both men and women.
One
who does not eliminate Hametz from his home on the 14th of Nissan is
in violation of a Misvat Aseh (affirmative command). If he leaves the Hametz in his home during
Pesach, he violates as well the Misvat Lo Ta’aseh (Torah prohibition) of “Se’or
Lo Yimaseh Be’batechem” – that Hametz may not be present in one’s home during
Pesach. Although Misvot Lo Ta’aseh
(Torah prohibitions) are generally punishable with Malkut (lashes), one is not
liable to Malkut for violating this prohibition, because it entails no action,
and one is liable to Malkut only for violating a Misvat Lo Ta’aseh that is
transgressed by committing an action.
The
Minhat Hinuch, in discussing the command of “Tashbitu,” notes that this Misva
might perhaps be treated differently than other Misvot Aseh. He cites the discussion of the Ran (Rabbenu
Nissim of Gerona, Spain, 1320-1380) in Masechet Yoma (4 in the Rif) regarding
the case of an ill patient who is in life-threatening condition on Shabbat and
urgently requires food. Needless to say,
Pikuah Nefesh (saving a human life) overrides Torah law, and it would thus be
permissible to cook food for this patient, despite the prohibition against
cooking on Shabbat. The Ran writes that
even if readymade non-kosher food is available, it is preferable to cook kosher
food for this patient. He explains that
the transgression of cooking on Shabbat is violated through just one action,
whereas the prohibition against eating non-kosher food is violated through each
and every act of eating. Therefore, it
is preferable to violate once the severe transgression of Shabbat desecration,
even though it is punishable by death, rather than have the patient repeatedly
violate the less severe prohibition of eating non-kosher food. According to the Ran, repeatedly violating a
lower-level prohibition is treated by Halacha with greater severity than a
one-time violation of a higher-level prohibition. By the same token, the Minhat
Hinuch posits, one might argue that the Misvat Aseh of eliminating Hametz,
which one violates at every moment he allows the Hametz to remain in his home,
should be considered a stricter command than other Misvot Aseh, which one
violates only at one moment. For
example, the moment Rosh Hashanah ends, one who did not hear the Shofar blowing
has transgressed the Misva at that moment.
In the case of “Tashbitu,” however, one transgresses the Misva
repeatedly, every moment the Hametz is present in the home.
The
Minhat Hinuch proposes two practical applications of this theory. First, it will affect the question of how
much an expense one must incur in order to fulfill this Misva. Generally, Halacha requires one to spend even
all his money if necessary to avoid violating a Misvat Lo Ta’aseh, but requires
spending only up to one-fifth of one’s assets for the sake of fulfilling a
Misvat Aseh (Shulhan Aruch, Orah Haim 656).
When it comes to the Misvat Aseh of “Tashbitu,” however, one might argue
that since this Misva is violated every moment it is not performed, its status
is that of a Misvat Lo Ta’aseh, and thus one would be required to spend any
amount of money necessary for the sake of eliminating the Hametz from his home.
Secondly,
as the Rambam famously discusses in Hilchot Teshuba, one atones for neglecting
a Misvat Aseh simply by performing Teshuba (repentance), whereas atoning for
violating a Misvat Lo Ta’aseh requires both repentance and the experience of
Yom Kippur. In this respect, too, we
might assume that the Misva of “Tashbitu” is treated like a Misvat Lo Ta’aseh,
and is thus not atoned through repentance alone.
The
Minhat Hinuch writes that this theory is a “He’ara Nechona” (“correct
observation”), though he remains inconclusive, stating that this point requires
further study and analysis.