The
Torah in Parashat Re’eh (Debarim 14:11) commands, “Kol Sipor Tehora Tochelu” –
“You shall eat every pure species of bird.”
The Sefer Ha’hinuch, following the Rambam, understands this verse as
introducing the command to determine the kosher status of birds. As discussed in the context of an earlier
Misva (153), the Torah lists twenty-four species of birds which are forbidden
for consumption, and all other birds in the world may be eaten. In theory, then, one who knows the identity
of these twenty-four species can eat any species of bird which he has
determined to not belong to any of these species. The Sages taught that a bird can be confirmed
kosher it has all of the following four properties: it does not attack other
creatures with its claws; it has an extra toe; it features a crop; and it has a
gizzard that can be peeled.
The
Ramban disagrees with the Rambam, and does not consider it a Misva to inspect
birds to determine their kosher status.
In his view, this verse adds a Misvat Aseh (affirmative command) to the
Misvat Lo Ta’aseh (prohibition) against eating non-kosher species of birds,
such that one who partakes of a such a bird transgresses both a Misvat Lo
Ta’aseh and a Misvat Aseh.
After
listing the twenty-four non-kosher species of birds, the Torah commands that one
may not eat “Sheretz Ha’of” (14:19), referring to small flying insects, such as
bees and hornets.
The
reason behind these commands is the same as the reason underlying the restrictions
on the consumption of other creatures, which the Sefer Ha’hinuch explained in a
separate context, namely, that the species which the Torah designated as
forbidden damage the body. The body
serves the vital function of containing the soul, and thus if we compromise the
body’s wellbeing, this adversely affects the soul. Partaking of non-kosher species impairs the
body, and thus, by extension, it impairs the soul.
This
idea is expressed in a letter which the Rambam had his student, Ibn Tibbon,
write to a certain community that had contacted him asking for guidance. The people in this town were struggling with
certain matters involving Jewish faith, as the people were finding it difficult
to accept and embrace certain principles of Emuna (such as the belief in the
future resurrection). The Rambam told
his student to respond, and the student wrote a letter advising the people to
check to ensure that the food they were eating was permissible. He explained that when a person eats, the
digestive system processes the food, expelling the waste and distilling what it
is kept in the body. The finest
components of the food are sent to the brain, so it can function at optimum
level. Therefore, if one consumes
non-kosher food, the brain receives low-quality nourishment, and this
compromises its functionality, impeding its ability to properly perceive and
understand. Therefore, Ibn Tibbon urged
the townspeople to determine whether perhaps they were eating non-kosher food,
and this was hampering their ability to accept the core principles of Jewish
faith.
For
this same reason, when Abraham Abinu set out to teach and guide people toward
monotheism, he offered hospitality, inviting guests and giving them food. At first glance, we might think that this was
simply a tactic, a way to bring people under his influence. But it has been explained that Abraham wanted
them to ingest kosher food in order that their minds would then be receptive to
the concepts of Emuna which he sought to teach them. Likewise, the Zohar comments that Beneh
Yisrael needed to eat Masa at the time of Yesiat Misrayim in order for them to
be able to achieve Emuna. The Zohar
draws an analogy to a doctor who instructs a parent not to give the ill child
normal food until he finishes the prescribed medication, because only once the
malady is cured will the child’s body have the ability to properly process
food. By the same token, Beneh Yisrael
were spiritually ill, deficient in Emuna, and they required “medication” to
cure them of this malady. Masa, the
Zohar teaches, is “the food of faith,” with the power to bring spiritual
healing, and Beneh Yisrael could not eat Hametz until they first ate Masa for
seven days to cure themselves of their spiritual illness and achieve firm
belief in Hashem.
The
Rama (Rav Moshe Isserles, Cracow, 1530-1572), in Yoreh De’a, writes that a
woman who eats non-kosher food should not nurse an infant, because the child
would then ingest milk produced from non-kosher food, which would have a
deleterious spiritual effect. The
commentaries (Shach and Taz) explain that the Rama refers to a case where a
woman needs to eat certain non-kosher food for medical reasons due to a
life-threatening condition. This is a
situation where the mother is allowed – and even required – to eat non-kosher
food, and nevertheless, the milk she produces could contaminate the child
because of the non-kosher food she ingests.
If this is the effect of non-kosher food consumed permissibly, then
certainly, non-kosher which one eats in violation of the Torah causes severe
spiritual harm.
These
commands, of course, apply in all times and places, and are binding upon both
men and women. If a person eats a
Ke’zayit from a forbidden species, or an entire forbidden creature (“Birya”) regardless
of its size, is liable to Malkut.