In a previous
installment, we saw that just as Halacha requires reciting Birkot Ha'Torah in
the morning before verbally speaking words of Torah, one is similarly required
to recite Birkot Ha'Torah in the morning before listening to words of Torah. This is based on the Halachic principle of
"Shome'a Ke'oneh," which equates listening with speaking. One who listens to words of Torah is
considered to be speaking those words himself, and so he must recite Birkot
Ha'Torah.
This conclusion gives
rise to the question of whether it is permissible to teach Torah to Jews who can
be presumed not to have recited Birkot Ha'Torah. Many communities run Torah learning programs
for non-observant Jews, who certainly do not recite the morning blessings, such
as Birkot Ha'Torah. Seemingly, by
teaching them Torah, one causes them to violate the prohibition of learning
before reciting Birkot Ha'Torah. How,
then, is this allowed, given that one is not permitted to facilitate another
Jew's violation of Halacha?
The Poskim offer
different reasons why this should be allowed.
One theory is that the mechanism of "Shome'a Ke'oneh" works through
Kavana (intent) – meaning, the speaker has in mind that his words should be
considered as though they were spoken also by the listeners. When teaching Torah to a non-observant
audience, one does not have this intention, since the listeners have not
recited Birkot Ha'Torah, and so they are not considered as though they are
speaking the words.
However, as we saw in
a previous installment, it is uncertain whether the process of "Shome'a
Ke'oneh" indeed requires Kavana in the context of Torah study.
Another possibility is
that non-observant Jews have the same status as people who are incapable of
reciting Birkot Ha'Torah. If one is
practically unable to recite Birkot Ha'Torah – such as if he does not know
Hebrew, or if he does not have Siddur and does not know the text from memory –
then Halacha allows him to learn Torah without reciting the Berachot. Jews who are unfamiliar with Halacha
observance may likely fall under this category, and so they are allowed to
learn Torah without reciting Birkot Ha'Torah.
Others suggest that it
is preferable for non-observant Jews to learn Torah, despite not having recited
Birkot Ha'Torah, as the exposure to Torah learning could lead them to embrace
observance. It is better for them to
violate this transgression, of learning before Birkot Ha'Torah, than never to
be taught Torah, as they will hopefully be drawn to learn more and become
observant.
Rav Yitzchak
Zilberstein (contemporary) cites his father-in-law, Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv (Jerusalem,
1910-2012), as advancing a different rationale.
He noted that non-observant Jews who attend a Torah lecture have no
intention to fulfill the Misva of Torah learning, but come merely for the sake
of curiosity or intellectual engagement.
This kind of study, Rav Elyashiv asserted, does not qualify as a
fulfillment of the Misva of Torah learning, and thus does not require Birkot
Ha'Torah. Others dispute this line of
reasoning, claiming that this indeed fulfills the Misva despite the absence of
intent for the Misva.
Summary: Although one
is required to recite Birkot Ha'Torah each day before learning Torah, including
silently listening to a Torah class, the Poskim generally allow teaching Torah
to non-observant Jews who do not recite the required daily blessings.