A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot daf 35b #365 The protection Torah gives from the Din

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
September 26, 2023
Duration
46:30
Lecture code
RGK-992

Torah as Protection from the Sun and Divine Anger

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas opens by observing that many yeshiva students spend bein hazmanim (between the terms) tanning on the beach to get used to the heat.
  • He connects this to the word melahetet, “to burn them,” and to the Tehillim phrase ein nistar meichamato (“no one is hidden from his heat”). The sun’s heat cannot be escaped, he says, except through Torah, which protects the person who learns it.
  • The word chamah can refer both to the sun and to the *chemah*—the anger of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Torah blocks that exposure: as sunscreen may block the sun’s rays, Torah, and the Shema in particular, offers far greater protection.
  • He says that a person may have sinned yet be protected because he learned Torah, and invokes the image of Torah as the tik, the mantle or case of the Sefer Torah.

The Fire of Torah and the Yetzer

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas turns to the Zohar, which he says describes two qualities of the esh (fire) of Torah. He explains the first: Torah’s fire burns aveirot (sins), so a person need not be subjected to the fire of Gehinam for them.
  • He cites the image of the salamandra, which cannot be controlled by ordinary fire, as an analogy for protection from fire.
  • He shares a Chiddush of Rav Shlomo Amar, which Rav Shlomo Amar taught on Erev Yom Kippurim, the Sunday morning before Yom Kippur: “Kol asher yavo ba’esh, ba’esh ya’avor” (“Whatever comes into fire shall pass through fire”).
  • To explain the principle, he reviews the halachic distinction between hag’alah for something that absorbed through cooking and libun for something that absorbed through fire. He also discusses a kli cheres, which normally must be broken rather than returned to the oven, joking that people might have Rachmanut on their plates and avoid heating them to the point that they could break.
  • He relates this to the Gemara’s teaching that Torah is the way to overcome the Yetzirah. In the Yom Kippur prayers, people are described as facing fire while being basar vadam (flesh and blood): a person cannot overcome the Yetzer by human strength alone. Fire must be met with fire, whether one is trying to prevent an aveirah or repair one afterward.
  • Torah is called “Ke Esh Ni’um Hashem”; since Hashem gave Torah through fire, Torah’s fire is the means to combat the fire of sin. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas also invokes the salamander image as a way of describing Torah’s protection.
  • He refers as well to Elisha, the Maharsha, and a passage in Rosh Hashanah in connection with divine punishment by fire and the protection Torah provides.

Torah, Life, and the Promise of Long Days

  • In Nefesh HaChayim, Sha’ar Dalet, Perek Yud-Zayin, he cites the teaching that Torah was given in fire and darkness, and that one who engages in Torah is saved from the consuming fire of Gehinam and from the darkness associated with the other nations.
  • He cites Ra’aya Mehemna, Terumah, kuf lamed dalet, on the mitzvah of learning Torah every day. Torah is the secret of supernal faith and knowledge of Hashem’s ways; those who engage in it are rewarded in this world and the next and are saved from evil and accusation.
  • He discusses orech yamim (length of days), drawing on teachings associated with the Zohar, including Vayeshev and Chayei Sarah, where Rabbi Eliezer begins a discussion of the phrase. He notes that orech yamim can refer to the enduring life of the world to come, not simply a long lifespan in this world.
  • The lecture also refers to a recently studied passage in the Gemara in Kiddushin and to the Rishonim. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas emphasizes the distinction between *yamim shleimim*—full or fulfilled days in this world—and *yamim arukim*—long days in the world to come.
  • He describes Torah as bringing life, freedom, goodness, and honor in both worlds. He says that Torah protects its students from judgment in this world and the next, and raises the idea that those who engage in Torah will not be required to answer for a law in the next world.
  • He mentions the questions asked at judgment: “Asaqta baTorah?” (“Did you engage in Torah study?”) and “Kavata itim?” (“Did you set fixed times?”). He jokes that a person should answer yes to the first question, and says that answering yes to the Torah question would mean not needing to answer the others.

Questions About Reward, Suffering, and Lifespan

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions how broadly to understand promises of protection and reward, since many chachamim were murdered and many Torah scholars did not live long lives. He says the teaching needs clarification rather than being applied simplistically.
  • He cautions against basing conclusions only on visible examples of reward: descendants of a Holocaust victim may flourish, or a couple may have children after 18 years, but such stories do not answer the situation of other victims or couples who continue to suffer. These are limited perspectives on matters people do not fully understand.
  • He says that people who are not osek baTorah may not see the beauty and inner life of the Torah world. At the same time, he asks what it means to say that Torah brings tov in this world when many Torah students do not experience material good.
  • He returns to orech yamim: the wording may mean full, meaningful days in this world and long days in the world to come, rather than a guarantee of an unusually long earthly life. He says that a person’s days have to be filled, and that the question of why people’s lives unfold as they do is one Moshe Rabbeinu asked Hashem; some matters remain beyond human understanding.
  • He mentions “Im bechukotai telechu” (“If you follow My statutes”) while acknowledging that not everyone appears to experience the stated outcomes. He suggests there is a regular case, but says people will understand more when they reach that point.
  • He notes that some rabbanim live to 100, 102, 103, or 105, while many others suffer or die young. He does not claim to know what explains the difference.
  • He also raises the financial difficulty faced by people who learn Torah: basic necessities are not luxuries, and some Torah learners need to raise funds. He has no answer to why Torah study does not always remove that need.
  • He discusses people who try to follow Rashbi’s way but do not succeed materially. He distinguishes the ideal of Torah dedication from a requirement to live in luxury, while acknowledging that even necessities can be lacking.
  • Not everyone can devote the entire day to Torah like Moshe Rabbeinu. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas describes the resulting difficulty: a person must work, yet without full-time dedication may not reach that level. He says he does not know why this does not work out in every case.

Protection in the Grave and the World to Come

  • He clarifies that the protection under discussion concerns three stages: ba’olam hazeh (in this world), ba’kever (in the grave), and ba’olam haba (in the world to come).
  • He cites a teaching that one who strives in Torah merits life in both worlds, even if the Torah study is not lishma (for its own sake); the teaching also promises reward in this world and says the person is not judged in the world of truth.
  • He describes the Torah as going before a person when he leaves this world, protecting him from judgment, guarding him while his body lies in the grave, and accompanying his soul until the resurrection and the recognition of his merit. He asks whether this relates to the 12 months, and calls the process severe.
  • He cites “Nefesh amel, amlah lo”: a soul that toils works for itself. If someone toils in Torah in this place, the Torah will toil for him in another place.
  • He adds that someone who earns money and supports places of Torah has a share in that Torah.

Supporting Torah and the Stories of Donors

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recounts a story about Reikman and Rav Shach. In the 1980s, after making a billion-dollar deal, Reikman gave 100 million dollars as ma’aser and asked Rav Shach to clear the yeshivot’s debts. Rav Shach paid them off.
  • Reikman also made loans to yeshivot without collecting them. When he later went bankrupt in England, a trustee proposed collecting the loans. Reikman paid them off himself so the yeshivot would not be pursued. He tried to clear their debts again near the end of his life but could not do so.
  • He then tells a story about Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz and Mir Yeshiva. During an earlier visit to Israel, Schultz heard a rabbi speak to a group of wealthy businessmen about the Holocaust: when each person pulls a blanket toward himself, there is not enough room or covering, but when people try to give the blanket to one another, there is enough. The rabbi urged them to return to America and share their “blanket.”
  • Schultz said that the message had moved him. Years later, he returned to meet the rabbi and offered a blank check for the yeshiva. When the rabbi wrote $1,000, Schultz urged him to add zeros, since the yeshiva owed millions. The rabbi declined and told him to keep the check as something for the two of them; he also told Schultz to buy tefillin. The account says Schultz did buy a pair, and that the yeshiva’s debts were around nine or ten million dollars.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks whether a large donation can be treated as purchasing merit, but says he does not know how divine reward is measured; perhaps it is according to each person’s means. He recalls another donor who gave ma’aser and later went bankrupt. When asked why, the donor said, “I think I didn’t give enough,” despite being described as the greatest donor. The lecture leaves the question of how such events are judged unresolved.

Torah and the Fire of Gehinam

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas returns to the teaching of Chazal that the fire of Gehinam does not rule over Torah scholars. He says the discussion also considers a scholar who has fallen or erred, while stressing that the Torah itself remains protective.
  • He connects this to Mishlei and the word melitza, which he explains as a parable associated with protection from Gehinam.
  • He examines “Mitzvotai tizpon itach” (“Treasure my commandments with you”) in Mishlei, Alef. He explores the connection between tzafun and “treasured” or “hidden,” and mentions modern Hebrew matzpun (“compass”) and tzafon (“north”), while treating the word connection as uncertain.
  • He concludes by asking whether Torah can save a person on the Day of Judgment even if that person dies violently. He raises a question about a victim and whether regret for past actions matters, but says he does not know. He cites the report that Rabbi Meir restored someone to Gan Eden, and closes with Midrash Tehillim, Mizmor Yud-Tet: Rabbi Yochanan and Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish say together that there will be no Gehinam in the future.
Words in this lecture2
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem