A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

To put the dishes in the dishwasher on shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
March 28, 2025
Duration
3:21
Lecture code
RGK-1532

Storing Dishes in the Dishwasher on Shabbat

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas shifts from the topic of Amirah le'akum to a different question: may someone who has no help put dirty dishes into the dishwasher on Shabbat, intending to turn it on after Shabbat?
  • Although no melacha is being done, arranging the dishes could be preparing from Shabbat for chol, which is not allowed.
  • Rabbi Koskas recalls that his rabbi in France permitted putting the dishes in the dishwasher because the person wanted to avoid leaving them piled in the sink and was using the dishwasher to store them.
  • At age 15, Rabbi Koskas challenged this ruling: if the purpose is only storage, the dishes should be placed there haphazardly, not arranged in the racks as they are meant to go. Putting plates with plates and cups with cups makes clear that one is preparing them for use after Shabbat.
  • He also questioned rinsing the dishes, since they are rinsed before using the dishwasher. One could argue that rinsing is to prevent them from smelling, but that would not explain why they should be loaded in their proper order.
  • His rabbi maintained that placing them in that order was permitted. Rabbi Koskas later found a teshuva from Chacham Ovadia supporting his objection: arranging the dishes in the racks is clearly preparation for chol and is assur.
  • According to that conclusion, the dishes may be stored in the dishwasher, but not arranged in the racks as they are meant to be placed for washing.