A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Arachin 5-6

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
January 30, 2026
Duration
3:47
Lecture code
RJD-MARACHIN-5-6

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

When a person owes something to the Beit HaMikdash, whether it is a donation he pledged or a korban (offering) he has to bring, he has to do his best to bring the korban immediately. He should really bring it before the next of the regalim (pilgrimage festivals), before Pesach, Shavuot, or Sukkot. If he waits until a full year has passed, with all three regalim having passed, and he doesn’t bring what he pledged, then he violates a law, Taaseh. But what do we do to motivate this person to pay his donation on time?

The Mishnah says, “We take security from those individuals who made an Erech vow (valuation vow) in order to make sure their obligation is paid on time.” The treasurer of the Beit HaMikdash takes possessions of the individual who made that vow and holds on to them until the person pays his pledge, then gives them back. We don’t take security from those people who are obligated to bring a korban chatat (sin offering) or a korban asham (guilt offering). These korbanot are brought by people who committed averot (transgressions). They know that in order to receive kapara, atonement, they have to bring the korban, so they’re not going to delay. They’ll bring them at the earliest opportunity they have. So there’s no need to take security from them.

Chayavei olot (burnt offerings) ushelamim (peace offerings) memashkenin otan. People who are obligated to bring a korban olah or korban shelamim, we do take security from them. These korbanot are brought as an optional korban. People donate them of their own free will. So, just like with an Erech vow, we want to make sure that they pay on time. The treasury takes a security deposit from them. Even though a korban is not fully accepted by Hashem unless the owner brings it willingly—as the Pasuk (verse) tells us, he has to bring it of his own free will—we could still take security to push him to bring the olah or the shelamim that he pledged. And we force him until he says, “I’m willing to do it.” Once he says it, it’s considered that he’s bringing the korban willingly, even though there’s a little bit of coercion, a little bit of force in there.

Likewise, the same rule applies to the get, the bill of divorce of a woman. A get is only valid if it’s given by the husband willingly. But there are some times when we use extra motivation to make the husband give the get, which is not a problem. Kofin oto ad sheyomar, rotzeh ani: we force him until he says, “I’m willing to give the get.” It’s considered as though he gave it willingly, and it’s still considered halachically valid.

But Rambam elaborates on this idea, and he says that every Jew wants to do the right thing. Every Jew who donates money wants to pay his bill. Every Jew who should give his wife a divorce—the right thing to do is to give her the divorce. But the Yetzer Hara (evil inclination) is holding him back from doing what’s right. So we push him a little to motivate him to do what he truly wants to do. And that’s what we do when it comes to the get of a woman. We pressure the man, of course, only with the authority of a beit din (religious court), which gives us the clearance to do it. And at that point in time, the giving of the get becomes a willing act, because that is the individual’s real internal will: to do the right thing.