We learned earlier that any earthenware utensil has to be broken in order to lose its status. You cannot simply immerse it in a mikveh (ritual bath). Here we’ll talk about how much an earthenware oven has to be broken in order to become tahor (pure) once again.
Mishnah says: An oven made of earthenware that became tameh (ritually impure). How do we make it tahor? How much do we have to break it in order to make it tahor? You have to divide the oven into three parts by cutting it in three places from top to bottom. Generally, we would think that two spots would be enough to divide it into two. Why do we have to divide it into three pieces? Three is important because if you cut it into two and the division is uneven, one part would be bigger than the other. We have a halakha (Jewish law) that if a majority of the utensil remains, it still holds the properties of the utensil, including its status as tameh. So, to make it pure, you have to have three pieces, which means that no piece is a majority of the utensil. You also have to scrape off the clay on the outside of the oven so that the sections are fully divided and not held together. Ad sheyehei ba'aretz, and these cuts in the walls have to reach the ground. If they do not, the uncut part of the wall holds the sections together, and they are not considered broken.
Rabbi Meir Omer: Eino tzarich ligror et ha-tefelah, says Rabbi Meir, you don’t have to scrape off the coating from behind the cuts. Ve-lo ad sheyehei ba'aretz, you don’t have to cut it all the way until the cut reaches the ground. Ela mema'ato mibifnim arba'ah tefachim (handbreadths): rather, if you cut the walls of the oven from the inside until less than four tefachim remain, you do not have to remove the coating of clay, according to the opinion of Rabbi Meir. As long as the oven itself is broken, cut to such an extent, it doesn’t make a difference if the broken parts are held together. It is still considered to be a broken oven.
Rabbi Shimon Omer: says Rabbi Shimon, he is strict and says even more than the first Tanna (Mishnaic sage): not only do you have to remove the coating and cut it all the way to the ground, but you need to move the sections away from each other in order for it to become tahor according to the first Tanna. As long as you cut it through, you did your job and you remove the clay; it’s now tahor. But according to Rabbi Shimon, you have to physically remove the sections from each other in order to make it tahor.
If you divided the oven into two sections, like we said earlier, one large and one small, the larger section is tameh and the small section is tahor. The larger section remains tameh because it is the majority of the original oven and therefore is not considered broken. It retains the original properties of the oven, which was already tameh. The smaller piece, on the other hand, loses its tum'ah (ritual impurity) status and becomes tahor.
If you divide the oven into three sections, one of them was as large as the other two combined. One section was more than half of the original oven, and each of the other ones was less than a quarter of the original oven. The larger section is tameh, and the two smaller ones are tahor. The large section, which is still the majority of the original oven, is tameh because it still retains the properties of the oven, because it is the majority. The two smaller ones, which are less than the majority of the oven, become tahor. They lose the properties of the oven. They are not called an oven anymore.

