A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kinnim 3-3

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
May 6, 2026
Duration
2:03
Lecture code
RJD-MKINNIM-3-3

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We'll continue to talk about a Kohen (priest) who didn't ask a Hacham what to do. Earlier in the Masechet (tractate), we said that if a chatat (sin offering) bird gets mixed with an olah (burnt offering) bird and we don't know which is which, they're both left to die because we don't know where to offer them on the Mizbeach (altar). But that's only if the Kohen asked what to do. If the Kohen didn't ask and offered them both, what happens in that scenario? He offered the chatat and the olah as he wanted to. He didn't ask for anyone's opinion.

The Mishnah says there was a mixture: one woman had a bird chatat, and one woman had a bird olah. We don't know which bird is which. They had already offered the other birds they needed to offer. Now one woman has a chatat, and one has an olah. The Kohen didn't ask, but he offered them above the red line, like an olah. Then half of them are valid and half are invalid. Whichever bird was an olah is valid, and whichever one was a chatat is invalid.

If he offered them both below the red line, which is for the chatat, then half are valid—the one that was a chatat—and half are invalid—the one that was an olah. If he offered half of them above the red line, then half are valid, and half of them below the red line. The one above the red line should be an olah, and the one below the red line should be a chatat; they're both invalid. Because you may say, ah, the chatat was the one that was put above the red line, and the olah was the one offered below the red line, and a bird chatat offered above, and a bird olah offered below are invalid. So, in other words, we have to imagine the worst-case scenario. The scenario is that maybe the chatat was offered wrongly, and the olah was offered wrongly, and therefore they're both invalid.