In the first two perakim (chapters), we spoke about what a Kohen (priest) should do ideally in that situation to mitigate risk if he has this mixture of pairs of birds. What does he offer? How should he offer them? Now we'll talk about those cases. What happens if the Kohen didn't discuss the case with anybody, but he just offered the birds?
Mishnah says: What are we talking about in these last two perakim? A case where a Kohen asked the chachamim (rabbis) what he should do with this mixture of birds. But if a Kohen did not ask the rabbis what he should do, but offered the mixtures of birds on his own, this applies in a case where he had one pair that was separated for this woman and one pair that was separated for this woman, or two pairs that were separated for one woman and two pairs that were separated for another woman, or three pairs.
If you offered all of them above the red line on the Mizbe'ach (altar), which indicates that they're olot (burnt offerings), then half of them are valid and half of them are not valid. Half the birds in all the pairs were supposed to be olot. So those olot pairs were offered properly and are valid. But whatever was supposed to be chatat (sin offering) was now offered improperly, and those are not valid.
If you offered all of them below the red line on the Mizbe'ach, which indicates that they're for a chatat, then half of them are valid and half of them are invalid. Half of them that were supposed to be for a chatat are valid, and therefore they were offered properly. But those that were supposed to be olot were offered improperly and are therefore invalid.
If you offered half of them above the red line and half of them below the red line, then above the red line would be for olot, and below the red line would be for chatat. Et shelema'alah mechatzah kasher u-mechatzah pasul. The law is—those that were offered above, half of them are valid and half of them are invalid. Ve'et shelematah mechatzah kasher u-mechatzah pasul. All those that were offered below the red line, half of them are valid; those that were supposed to be for chatat are valid, of them are invalid.
What he did in this last case is that he's offering up the pairs together. Half of the pairs were above, and half of the pairs were below. So whatever pairs he offered above, half of them were supposed to be for an olah, and therefore they were offered properly. The half of that pair—so, one of the birds and one of the birds—is really supposed to be below, so we basically say we split the difference, and half of them are offered correctly and half of them are offered incorrectly. We're not talking about a case where half of the birds that were mixed were put above and below. He didn't know what was supposed to be an olah and what was supposed to be a chatat for those individual pairs. So now he's offering up the pairs: half the pairs are above, half the pairs below. He just messed up on—he's supposed to split the pairs, but here he just took two pairs. One pair is going all above, one pair is going all below, so half of it was offered correctly, and half of it wasn't offered correctly.

