A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kinnim 2-5

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
May 4, 2026
Duration
6:24
Lecture code
RJD-MKINNIM-2-5

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

A person had a chatat bird on his right side and an olah bird on his left side. They had already been designated. In between them, he had an undesignated pair, between the chatat and the olah. If the two birds from the middle, this undesignated pair, flew out to the sides, with one flying to the right of the chatat and one to the left of the olah, we don't know which birds on the right side are which, or which birds on the left side are which. But we definitely know that one of them is a chatat and one of them is an olah, and next to them are two undesignated birds. We say he didn't lose anything; all the birds could still be offered. He simply has to say, “The undesignated bird that went to the chatat is being offered as a chatat, and the undesignated bird that went to the olah is being offered as an olah.”

But if a bird from each side now came back to the middle, the birds in the middle might include a designated chatat or olah, or perhaps one of the undesignated birds. The ones in the middle have to be left to die, as in any case where a chatat or olah gets mixed up. The ones on the right side should be left as a chatat, and the ones on the left side should be left as an olah, since we definitely know which is the chatat and which is the olah. The birds on the left and right could still be offered, but the ones in the middle are mixed up with each other. One came from the right, and one came from the left, and they landed in the middle. We don't know what's what, but there's a possibility that they're an olah or a chatat, and therefore, as in any other case, we wouldn't offer them.

If a bird then flew from the middle, whose identity we don't know, and it went to the sides, the sides may now contain a mixture of a chatat or an olah; we don't know. All of them have to be left to die, like any other possible mixture of a chatat or an olah.

Now we'll go to a new topic. We've been talking about a mix of a chatat and an olah of undesignated birds. Now we'll talk about different species of birds being paired together. We could only bring a tor or b'nei yonah, a dove or a pigeon, as a bird offering. The Mishnah says, “You're not allowed to bring doves to be paired with pigeons, or pigeons to be paired with doves.” Even though both are fit to be offered, they can only be offered separately as pairs. They can't be combined into one. A person who's obligated to bring birds has to bring a chatat and an olah from either a dove or a pigeon, but you can't combine the two.

What's the application of this rule? If a woman brought a dove as a chatat and a pigeon as an olah, she didn't fulfill her obligation because they're not from the same species. So what should she do? Does she now bring a second dove as an olah, or does she bring a second pigeon as a chatat? The Mishnah says she should repeat and bring a dove as her olah. The chatat that she brought establishes what species she's going to bring, not the olah that she brought. The chatat was a dove, and therefore that's the primary establishment of what she has to bring for her obligation. So she has to bring another dove to count as the olah.

But what happens here? The same thing over here. If she brings a dove as her olah first, and then she brings the pigeon as her chatat, she has to bring a pigeon as an olah. Even though in this case the olah, which was a dove, was brought first, the chatat she brought afterward as a pigeon establishes that her obligation is going to be fulfilled only through a pigeon, because the chatat is what establishes the korban (offering). So she has to bring an olah from a pigeon in order to complete the obligation.

But Ben Azzai omer (says): holchin achar harishon. Ben Azzai says that it's not the chatat that establishes what species she's going to bring to fulfill her obligation. Rather, it's what's the first bird that she brought, even if it was an olah. So if she brought her chatat first from one species, the chatat establishes her obligation, and she has to bring an olah from that same species. But if she brought her olah first from one species, she then has to bring her chatat to match that species, even though she already brought a chatat from a different species. So that's how it works. If she brought the olah first from one species, she has to complete her obligation by bringing a chatat from that same species as the olah, even though she brought a separate chatat afterward. Here, it's the olah that came first. It's the first korban that's being offered that establishes her obligation.

A woman who was obligated to bring a pair of birds brought a bird as a chatat, and then she died before bringing the olah. Her inheritors could bring an olah for her because there's nothing wrong with someone else bringing a person's olah after that person has died. An olah is considered to be a gift to Hashem, and therefore someone could bring it on her behalf after she passes away. But if she brought only an olah and then died before bringing the chatat, her inheritors do not bring a chatat for her because you're not allowed to offer a chatat on behalf of somebody else after they have died. A chatat is an atonement. An atonement cannot be made after a person has passed away.