A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Torah Lecture

Halacha O”H 306 / Is It Permitted To Take One’s Temperature On Shabbat?

Lectured by Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Published
June 24, 2009
Duration
05:02
Lecture code
Y-H30

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Good morning, everybody. The question we're going to deal with this morning is: Is someone allowed to measure temperature on Shabbat? Is someone allowed to use a thermometer on Shabbat?

So here we go to the Shulchan Aruch in Siman Shin Vav, Seif Zayin, which writes that one is allowed to measure on Shabbat when the measurement has to do with a mitzvah (commandment). By contrast, one is not allowed to take a measurement that does not have to do with a mitzvah on Shabbat. One is not allowed to use a ruler to measure something or to weigh things on Shabbat. The reason is that it is considered Uvdin D'chol. It is considered weekday activity, and this weekday activity is asur (forbidden) on Shabbat.

But the Shulchan Aruch says there is an exception. If the purpose of the medida, of the measuring, is for a mitzvah, the Shulchan Aruch gives an example: If one wants to measure whether there is enough water in a mikveh (ritual bath) to be kosher (ritually fit), so one can dip and be able to do a mitzvah, then one would be allowed to measure on Shabbat.

As far as taking a person's temperature to determine whether he has a fever or how high the fever is, some Aharonim (later halachic authorities) say that it is also mutar (permitted). A person's health is also considered a mitzvah, and one should make sure he is not in sakana (danger). So that is also considered a mitzvah, and therefore one would be allowed to do it, the same way one can measure a mikveh.

Other Aharonim go even further and say that even if this would not be considered a mitzvah, it would still be considered in the Or be mutar. The reason they give is that the whole gezerah (decree), the whole isur (prohibition) of measuring on Shabbat, applies when a person performs an act of measuring, like using a ruler or weights. That's the measure of measuring on Shabbat. But here, when one takes the temperature, he is not measuring anything; he is not doing anything. All he does is place the thermometer next to the area where there is heat, and then there is a reaction from the thermometer. The mercury goes up or goes down, so he is not actually measuring anything himself. It is being measured on its own.

Therefore, some Aharonim say that here, even if we would not say it is a mitzvah, it would still be okay for that reason, because one is not actively measuring anything.

Others say even more than that. They say that even if this would be considered measuring, and even if this would not be considered a mitzvah, it would still be mutar on Shabbat. Why? They explain that the whole reason measuring things or weighing things is forbidden on Shabbat is that it is a weekday activity. A person who does that will get involved in his weekday activities, will do more weekday activities, start doing business on Shabbat, start weighing his things, and start doing more things. That's why a rabbi said he can't do it on Shabbat.

However, here, when a person is measuring the temperature of a sick person, that's not considered Uvdin D'chol. This is like the lashon (wording) the Shulchan Aruch uses. This is called Uvdin D'choli. This is considered activity for a sick person, which will not lead to anything. It will not lead a person to do business on weekdays. It's not considered Uvdin D'chol.

Therefore, one would be allowed to take the temperature of a person who has a fever on Shabbat. Of course, this applies only to thermometers that have mercury inside. They don't make mercury thermometers today, but there are other mercury-free liquids that work basically the same way. One would not be allowed to use a digital electronic type of thermometer. Of course, that would be considered forbidden on Shabbat.

So again, one is not allowed to measure things on Shabbat, but one would be allowed to go ahead and take the temperature as long as it isn't a digital electronic thermometer. Have a wonderful day.