A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Torah Lecture

Halacha O"H 328 / Applying Ice To An Injury On Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi Meyer Yedid / Halacha

Published
June 15, 2009
Duration
03:15
Lecture code
Y-H25

Applying ice to a bump on Shabbat

  • Rabbi Meyer Yedid asks whether putting ice on a bump to prevent it from swelling is prohibited as refuah (healing) on Shabbat.
  • Shulchan Aruch permits putting kilorin (eye salve) on one’s eyes if it was mixed with water before Shabbat. Because it looks like washing, it is not mukcha milta (obvious matter) that the act is for refuah.
  • Applying ice to a bump, by contrast, clearly appears to be done for that purpose. Rabbi Meyer Yedid explains that the restriction on refuah applies to treatments that could be done with medicine. Since there is no medicine that can replace ice for this purpose, applying ice is mutar (permitted).

Crushing the ice

  • Shulchan Aruch says in Shin-Kaf (section 320) that one may not crush ice—meaning break it into small pieces—because of a concern about extracting liquid.
  • In Seif Yud (paragraph 10), Shulchan Aruch permits breaking ice in order to take water from underneath it. Rabbi Meyer Yedid explains that breaking ice is prohibited when the intention is to obtain the water, due to possible sechita (extracting liquid) or molid (making something new).
  • If the intention is simply to crush the ice, not to obtain water, it is mutar. Therefore, one may crush ice for this purpose and apply it to the bump, since this use is not refuah prohibited on Shabbat.