A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H

Torah Lecture

Berachot 6; Daily Lesson From The Daf - Results vs Efforts

Lectured by Rabbi Yaacov Laredo

Published
January 10, 2020
Duration
6:03
Lecture code
RYL-DAF05

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

The Talmud today discusses how God is found in the synagogue when there are ten people. He is also found when there are three dayanim, rabbinic scholars, in the middle of their judgment. He is also found among two people learning Torah. Even if one person is learning Torah by themselves, God is found and right there.

The Talmud quotes a verse in Malachi, chapter 3, proving that God is found when two people are learning Torah. Then the Talmud analyzes the last two words of that verse. I’ll say it in Hebrew: ulechoshvei shemo (And those who think of God’s name). The Talmud wonders, “What does that mean?” The Talmud, in the name of Rav Ashi, explains something very, very beautiful, something very special, and something that our commentary, say, applies specifically to Jews.

A person who has in mind to do something good, but does not have the opportunity because it is against their will, still receives the merit as if they did it. The opposite is also true. If a person has the intention to do something wrong but is not able to do so, God does not count it as a dismerit, a sin, or a transgression for that individual.

Let me give you an example. A person has all the proper intentions: they set themselves up to wake up on time to go to the synagogue, or to prepare themselves to be on time for Shabbat. They have every intention of doing so, but something outside their control, something against their will, takes place. An ones (something against their will) occurs, and they are not able to make it on time or be there. But they had all the right intentions, so God still considers it as if it was done.

To the contrary, a person who intends to kill somebody, steal, or say something negative or nasty, but is unable to do so against their will, is not punished for doing that. This is something specific to Yehudim, to Jews. However, God’s level of mercy and compassion, and His being above the letter of the law, do not apply in the same way to Gentiles. A Gentile who intends to do something right, a proper deed, a good deed, but is not able to fulfill it does not get the merit for it. And if they intend to do something wrong but are unable to commit that crime, they are still punished for it in God’s books, in God’s eyes.

This concept really ties into something we learned yesterday on page 5b. The Talmud recounts an interesting story about Reb Eliezer, who got sick, and Rebbe Yochanan came to visit him. He saw that Reb Eliezer was lying down in a very dark room. In his great, I guess, wisdom and great levels of spirituality, he rolled up his sleeves and his arms, creating some type of light. His arms were so shiny that they brought light into the room, and he was able to see that Reb Eliezer was crying.

He asked Reb Eliezer, “Why are you crying?” He gave him two options. “If it’s because at this point you’re not able to learn Torah because you’re so sick and can’t even concentrate, it doesn’t matter. There’s a rule.” I’ll say the rule in Hebrew. The Talmud says it as follows: It doesn’t matter whether a person does a lot or a person does a little, as long as they direct their attention and concentration to God, to doing His will, to doing the right thing. That’s all that God cares about.

This is a very important lesson for ourselves and something we need to pass on to our children. As Jews, the way God judges us is not based on our deeds—or, better, it’s not based on our results. It’s based on our efforts. If we put in the genuine effort to do the right thing, God will reward us for it. If we don’t, that’s when He looks and says maybe now He has to intervene, maybe in a negative way.

In the world that we live in, all we care about is results. Grades. Did you make money? Did you get the job? Did you build it? Did you acquire it? That’s all we really care about in this world. However, that’s this world. In the world of truth, in God’s eyes, the way the spiritual world operates is very different. It’s not result-driven; it’s effort-driven.

Let’s remind ourselves that we just need to try our hardest, and Hashem will do the rest. We need to push ourselves and give our best effort, put our best foot forward, to do the right thing, and teach that to our children. How do we teach that to our children? Not just by preaching it, not just by saying, “All we care about is efforts.” No, it’s by really showing them that when they come home, maybe they did not do as well as you wanted them to, or they did not get exactly where you wanted them to get. As long as you look at them with a smile and genuinely say, “As long as you tried your hardest, your efforts count most,” that sends them a very strong message.

So let us remember that even though this is the very opposite of the way things are in the world we live in, we are not to be result-driven; rather, we are supposed to be effort-driven.