Another great benefit our sages tell us about guarding one’s eyes is this: any so-called pleasure a person would have gained or enjoyed from looking at something improper or engaging in something improper, if they overcome it, they will actually have that very same benefit and reward in a permitted way.
Listen to the following very, very famous story. The Talmud in Masechet Menachot (Tractate Menachot), page 44a, recounts it. I’m going to read along and translate. It’s a very, very interesting story, and it’s amazing that this could even happen to a Torah scholar back in the day, but the evil inclination is very strong. So listen to the story.
There’s a story about a certain individual. This guy was known to always fulfill the mitzvah (commandment) of wearing his tzitzit, his four-cornered fringe garment, at all times. He heard that there was a certain harlot in a very special city, somewhere out of town, whose fee for her services, unfortunately and God forbid, was a grand total of 400 gold coins. Very, very expensive. And as we’ll soon see, she was so famous and so sought after that you had to book and pay in advance to make an appointment. So she gave him 400 gold coins, and he sent her the 400 gold coins and set an appointment.
When the time came and he met her, she told him to enter, and he went in. She had arranged seven beds, all made up of linen. The Talmud explains that these beds were kind of like a seven-layer bunk bed, one on top of another, and they were made of gold and silver and were very, very prestigious. So, when he was getting undressed to unfortunately commit a sin with this harlot, his tzitzit, his fringes, whacked him in the eyes. He took this as a sign from God: “Hey, watch. Watch yourself. Don’t do this.” And Nishmat—he slipped away. He jumped off the seven-layered, seven-decker bunk bed and went to the floor. He sat on the floor, and she jumped after him and sat on the floor next to him. She told him, “Did you find anything imperfect about me, and that’s why you jumped off the bed?” Amar lah—he said, no. Rather, He says that I have a very special commandment. This commandment I have always upheld and fulfilled, and it’s called tzitzit. He explained to her about tzitzit: they are there to remind us not to look after our eyes or follow our eyes and do things that are improper. So he took the fact that the tzitzit whacked him in the eyes as a lesson that he should not commit this sin of immorality.
Amra lo—she answered him. She was fascinated. “Fine. I hear what you’re saying. I’ll let you go. But I’m not letting you go until you write for me: What’s your name? Which city are you from? What’s the name of your rabbi? And what school, university, or Torah study group are you part of, where you learn Torah?” So he wrote it all down and gave her the paper.
Now, what did she do? She was very curious about how someone could withstand her temptation and seduction. So she got up and distributed all of her wealth. She retired from being a harlot. This is what she did with all of her money. She was very wealthy. She was very wealthy. A third she gave as a gift to the king. A third she gave to poor people. And a third she kept for herself. Not included in all of her wealth, she kept something aside in that whole calculation. And that was—except for that seven-layered bunk bed and the linens that were on them. We’ll see why soon.
The story continues. The Talmud says she came to the study hall of Rabbi Chiya. Amra lo—she answered him. She was obviously not a Jewess, and she came to the rabbi and said, “I want you to tell me what I have to do to convert.” The first question the rabbi asked her was, Amar lah: “Did you cast your eye upon one of my students? And are you just trying to convert for marriage?” She pulled out the paper that the student had written for her, with his name, the place he was from, his rabbi’s name, and the school he was part of. Amar lei—he said, “Go and take your acquisition.” Meaning, the rabbi accepted her to convert and then allowed her to marry that very same student.
The Talmud finishes off: Those same beds and linens that she had prepared for him, she prepared and set up for him, and lived in a permitted fashion with that very same student. A very interesting piece of Talmud. Don’t draw any conclusions about the laws of conversion from this piece of Talmud. That’s not the point of this Talmud. This Talmud is speaking about the mitzvah of tzitzit and the mitzvah of withholding oneself from sin.
With our topic at hand, guarding one’s eyes, what we’re learning from here, as the Gaon miVilna, the Gra, Rabbi Eliyahu miVilna explains, is that anything a person who gives in to their lust and desire accomplishes after much effort for something evil or not permitted is also done and accomplished by, as he writes very, very strongly in Even Shleimah, the Temimei Derech—those who are innocent in a permitted way with not much effort at all. So the Gaon miVilna is explaining that a person who wants to sin and puts effort into going and sinning and doing things that are improper should perhaps rethink it, because someone who is innocent and righteous will also have their share of benefits, equal to those benefits, if not more—at least in this world, and of course, in the world to come, greater, greater benefits and enjoyment.
The Steipler also writes that a person who overcomes their temptations and certain tests for the sake of God in this world will see, Be'ezrat Hashem (with God’s help), as he says, longevity. But then he also writes that all of those great pleasures that a person withholds from themselves in this world, only for the sake of God, will also be returned to them—those very same pleasures in another way, in a permitted way. That means when a person withholds themselves from eating something that’s not kosher because of its taste, or because it is tasteless, or when they are tempted to do so, or when they go certain places to do something that would grant them great pleasure, but overcome it and don’t do it for the sake of God, those very similar pleasures will be given back and they will be rewarded in a permitted way.
And so too when it comes to guarding one’s eyes: a person who feels like, “Oh, sure, I’ll let my eyes roam all over the streets, all over the computer and the phone, and enjoy everything I can see.” That’s opposed to one who says, “No, I’m going to guard my eyes. I’m not going to enjoy things that are inappropriate, improper, prohibited according to the Torah and what Hashem wants from me,” and realizes that it’s not good for them. That very same person will have benefit and enjoyment from the same and even different venues in a permitted way, whether it be with one’s wife, whether it be any other type of enjoyment through one’s eyes, maybe seeing the nachat, the enjoyment and the success of their very own children. There are many more things, much greater things, that are more worthy and enjoyable to see than things that are inappropriate.