The Talmud today discusses one's proper conduct during the Amidah (silent prayer). It brings a Beraita (rabbinic teaching) that says a person who prays out loud, meaning they hear themselves when they pray, is an individual who has a small amount of faith, or their faith is imperfect. Next, the person who raises their voice loud when they pray is amongst the false prophets. They would be suspected to be a false prophet, as that's what false prophets would do. A person who burps or yawns is considered arrogant in the middle of the Amidah if you do that. A person who passes gas is a bad sign for them. And others, as the Beraita explains, say that it's a sign that the person is a disgusting person. And a person who spits in the middle of the Amidah is likened, to someone who spits in front of the king. These are all things which we would think are obvious to us, but I guess maybe the earlier ones less than the later ones. Scrolling down towards almost the end of today's page, the Talmud tells us, and it actually analyzes, this idea of praying out loud. Not raising one's voice, but just hearing oneself when they pray the Amidah. And there's a teaching brought in the name of Rav Huna that says, and explains this, this is only talking about if a person cannot concentrate when they pray completely silent. Meaning a person who's praying completely silent, not hearing anything they're saying, if they cannot concentrate and connect to the prayer, we're talking about the sound prayer, the Amidah, that's when they're allowed to raise their voice a little in order to concentrate. It's not for any other reason besides for the reason to concentrate. However, that's only talking about when a person is praying, if a person is praying alone, if a person is praying amongst others, they would not be allowed, as the Talmud says, to raise their voice loud enough that would disturb or distract anyone else. This vernacular of the Talmud actually reminds me of a very similar interpretation to an episode in our Torah. See, 4,400 years ago, God comes to Noah and instructs him to build an ark that will survive the upheaval of the Talmud. That will survive the upheaval of the Talmud. That will survive the upcoming worldwide flood. Now, fast forward 120 years. That's 120 years of building and preparing that Noah does for the flood. The Torah tells us, and I quote in Genesis chapter 7, verse 7, it says, And Noah and his sons, they all come together with Noah to the ark, because of the water or the rain of the flood. And the obvious question is, why are they going in because of the rain of the flood? Well, isn't the flood coming, obviously? Well, that's where the Midrash and Rashi quotes it. And I'll use the word because it's the same word that Talmud uses. Rashi says that Noah was also an individual who lacked in his faith. If we go back to our Talmud, the Talmud says, A person who hears themselves when they pray their Tefilat HaAmidah, is an individual who lacks in faith. So, are very similar in terminology. So, this reminds me of that episode that took place with Noah in our Torah. And Rashi was telling us that Noah did not feel the need to go into the ark. Until his ankles were already submerged in water. Meaning, Noah didn't really believe that God would actually, or could actually bring this worldwide flood. And it was the water of the flood that actually brought Noah to come to the ark. So, Noah's faith was, unfortunately, less than perfect. Today's Talmud is telling us something similar. That one who prays out loud, because they think that that's what will allow Hashem, or enable Hashem to hear them in a better way, is someone who lacks in faith. Now, practically, what is the Halacha (Jewish law)? How are we supposed to pray our Amidah, our silent Amidah? So, the Shulchan Aruch in chapter 101, Halacha 2, that's Siman Kuf Aleph, Seif Bet (chapter 101, Halacha 2), he holds that the silent prayer is supposed to be silent to all listeners, to everyone, except for the one praying. Meaning, the one praying himself or herself should articulate the words and very lightly be able to hear themself, but making sure that no one else, even if someone was standing right next to them, would not listen or not be able to hear, in order that we don't confuse them, make them have a lack of concentration. The Arizal clearly disagrees very strongly with this opinion of the Shulchan Aruch. And his ruling is that the Amidah is on such a level, such a high level, that one should only move their lips, but no sound at all should be made. Not even the own person that is praying should hear themself. So, practically, most Halacha opinions go with the first opinion, that of the Shulchan Aruch, that a person should hear themself and themself only, not loud enough to hear anyone else, during the silent Amidah. However, the Kabbalists, the Mekubalim (Kabbalists), go according to the Arizal, amongst them the Ben Ish Chai, and everyone should do according to their tradition. If a person normally doesn't go according to the Ben Ish Chai, or the Arizal, they should hear themself, like the Shulchan Aruch, and if they do normally, are normally Kabbalistically inclined, in those rulings, feel free to go according to the Arizal.
Torah Lecture
Berachot 24; Daily Lesson From The Daf - Hashem is always listening
Lectured by Rabbi Yaacov Laredo
- Lecture code
- RYL-DAF23
This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.
