A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H

Torah Lecture

Berachot 25; Daily Lesson From The Daf - proper attire for prayer

Lectured by Rabbi Yaacov Laredo

Published
January 30, 2020
Duration
7:37
Lecture code
RYL-DAF24

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Today, the Talmud continues with a Baraita (tannaitic teaching) that began on the last line of yesterday’s page. It explains a fundamental difference in the dress code for Keriat Shema (reciting the Shema), as opposed to praying the silent Amidah (silent prayer).

As a preface, it is important to know that whenever the Talmud says the word li-Tefillah, “for prayer,” that also includes all types of blessings, whether blessings for food or for studying Torah. When we speak here about reading Keriat Shema, we mean all types of prayer and blessing, with the exception of what the Talmud calls li-Tefillah, “for prayer.” That refers to the silent Amidah, the 19 Berachot (blessings) that we say for Shacharit, Mincha, and Arvit. It also includes Musaf, obviously.

So this is the difference: the Talmud is telling us that a person’s dress code obligations differ depending on whether they are doing Keriat Shema and the like, or praying the silent Amidah. For Keriat Shema, the Talmud says that all that is needed is a separation between one’s heart and one’s private parts. I’ll explain what that means practically. So what does that mean? The Talmud explains that for Keriat Shema and all types of prayers, the bare minimum a person has to have is something that is separating and covering their private part. For example, if a person would just be wearing underwear, and obviously a kippah (skullcap), we're not speaking about that now, but the bare minimum a person would need to wear to do Keriat Shema and any type of blessing, or learning Torah, would be just wearing underwear, trunks, shorts, literally, and a kippah. As opposed to prayer, where the Talmud says a person needs to cover their heart, our commentaries explain that a person needs to be fully dressed. What does fully dressed mean? Rashi explains that when it comes to the silent Amidah, there is a special law that a person has to be, as he says, standing and well-dressed as if standing in front of a king, with awe and respect. However, there is no such law when it comes to reciting Keriat Shema or any other type of prayer, for that matter.

The reason is that when we pray the silent Amidah, we are standing at attention and coming before God. As we know, we take three steps back and three steps forward. When we’re finished, we take three steps back. Since we are standing literally in front of God, we have to be dressed as if we are standing in front of God. All the more so, if you dress a certain way in front of a king or a very special person, we should stand in front of God that way as well.

The Rambam, as well as the Shulchan Aruch, in chapter 91, Halacha (Jewish law) 1, Siman Tzadi Aleph Seif Aleph (section 91, subsection 1), say that the proper and ideal way to pray the Amidah is to be fully dressed. However, if one has already prayed without being fully dressed, the prayer counted; or, if they don’t have a full set of clothes available, they are able to pray that way. The Mishnah Berurah, the Chafetz Chaim, in his commentary, the Biur Halacha on the Shulchan Aruch, explains that he disagrees with this leniency. He holds that if a person cannot dress properly for the prayer, they should not pray.

Furthermore, he disagrees on another aspect of this whole law, this whole concept. Even though the Talmud says that all you need is something to cover one’s private parts when doing Keriat Shema and all other types of prayers, as opposed to the silent Amidah, he says that is not ideal. That is only a non-ideal situation. Ideally, even for all types of prayers, including Keriat Shema and blessings and everything, one needs to be fully dressed and dressed properly.

Practically, what do we do? We understand that we have an obligation to be properly dressed, at least according to the letter of the law, for the silent Amidah. So what would be properly dressed? My Rebbe (teacher), Rabbi Yitzchak Berkowitz—may HaKadosh Baruch Hu bless him in his great endeavor of spreading Torah worldwide—is now the Rosh Yeshiva of Aish HaTorah worldwide. When I was learning in Kollel (Torah study program) with him, he explained this halacha as follows. He says that it depends on who you are and, more importantly, where you live, because different places have different standards for what is considered presentable.

For some people, depending on where they live, one would need to wear long pants, shoes and socks, and long sleeves, maybe even a jacket. That would be for a certain type of person living in a certain area. For others, wearing long pants but maybe a polo shirt is still considered presentable. For others, even a T-shirt, shorts, and sandals are considered presentable, and they are able to do the Amidah that way. It depends on where a person lives. The example he gave is someone living on a kibbutz (communal settlement). Yeah, wearing open-toed sandals, shorts, and a T-shirt is as fancy as they get. Even on Shabbat, some dress that way. For them, they would be allowed to do the Amidah that way.

For others, especially those of us who live here in South Florida, people are always showing up to very important meetings and events, maybe in a polo shirt, maybe in long sleeves, long pants, and proper shoes, but also in a short-sleeved T-shirt or a polo shirt. To them, that would be presentable and allowed for the silent Amidah. For others, being presentable might mean a long-sleeved shirt, perhaps a button-down shirt, perhaps even a jacket; for some who normally wear a hat when they pray, it might mean a hat. This is what it means to be presentable.

The same applies to women. There are gym clothes, clothes you’ll go out in, clothes you’ll be seen in public in, and clothes not... A woman should dress properly before prayer. But halacha lema'aseh, practical halacha is that for no reason should a person refrain from praying because they cannot be dressed properly, as the Shulchan Aruch says.

To wrap up, it’s important to remember that we need to dress properly and respectfully for this amazing and great opportunity to pray and speak to Hashem. We’re not dressing respectfully for Hashem; we’re dressing up respectfully for His honor, but it is to make our experience of speaking to Him more real and auspicious. When we imagine ourselves standing in front of Hashem and praying to Him in the Amidah, part of that experience, part of that connection to Him, is being dressed in a befitting, honorable, respectable way.