The
Torah commands in Parashat Re’eh (Debarim 14:21), “Lo Tochelu Kol Nebela” –
that we may not eat a Nebela. The term
“Nebela” refers to the carcass of an animal, even of a kosher species, that
died in any way other than valid Shehita.
If the animal died on its own, was killed without slaughtering, or was
slaughtered in a manner that is not Halachically acceptable, then the carcass
is considered a Nebela and forbidden for consumption.
The
reason for this prohibition, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, is the same as the
reason for the Torah’s other dietary restrictions, namely, that the Torah
forbade foods which adversely affect a person’s mind and cloud his judgment.
After
prohibiting the consumption of a Nebela, the Torah adds that a Nebela may be
fed to a non-Jew. The Sages inferred
from this addition that this prohibition applies only to a Nebela which is
worthy of consumption. As the Torah
speaks of feeding a Nebela to a gentile, we may conclude that only a Nebela
which a gentile would want to eat is forbidden for a Jew. But if the meat had already spoiled, and has
a putrid taste, such that nobody would eat it, then it does not fall under the
prohibition of Nebela.
This
is the source of the well-known Halacha known as “Noten Ta’am Li’fgam,” which
establishes that a foul taste of forbidden food is not forbidden. As we know, if prohibited food was cooked in
a utensil, then the utensil has absorbed its taste, and it would thus be
forbidden to eat food that is cooked in the utensil subsequently, as this food
will have absorbed the taste of the forbidden food from the utensil. However, the Sages determined that once
twenty-four hours have passed since the food was absorbed into the utensil, the
taste becomes foul, and thus it is no longer forbidden.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch proceeds to explain how this principle applies to Hag’ala –
immersing a utensil in hot water in order to expunge the taste of forbidden
food, and thereby make the utensil permissible for use. At first glance, this immersion should be
ineffective, because the taste is released into the water and then immediately
back into the utensil. Often, the
quantity of water is not sixty times larger than the volume of the utensil such
that the forbidden taste can be nullified by the water. Seemingly, then, Hag’ala should not be
effective in making the utensil permissible, unless the amount of water is
sixty times larger than the amount of taste expunged into the water. However, if the immersion takes place at
least twenty-four hours after the utensil had absorbed the taste, then the
taste is foul, and thus loses its prohibited status. At that point, then, the immersion is
effective.
Relevant
to the topic of Hag’ala, the Poskim address the question of why we do not
recite a Misva before performing Hag’ala on a utensil that has become
forbidden. Seemingly, just as we recite
a Beracha when immersing utensils obtained from a gentile to make them
permissible for use (“Al Tebilat Keli/Kelim”), we should likewise recite a
Beracha when performing Hag’ala to expunge the forbidden taste from a utensil.
One
answer given is that Hag’ala is not a Misva, but rather the means of avoiding a
transgression. Hag’ala is performed so
that food cooked subsequently in the utensil would be permissible for
consumption; it is not performed in the fulfillment of an obligation. It is comparable in this respect to Nikur –
the removal of the Gid Ha’nasheh (sciatic nerve) and its surrounding area from
an animal – upon which no Beracha is recited.
Nikur is required not as a Halachic obligation, but rather to avoid
violating the prohibition against eating the Gid Ha’nasheh, and thus it does
not warrant a Beracha. By the same
token, some argue, no Beracha is recited over Hag’ala, a procedure done for the
purpose of avoiding the consumption of forbidden food.
Others
challenge this answer, drawing a distinction between Hag’ala and Nikur. Whereas the Torah never mentions Nikur, it
speaks clearly about the procedure of Hag’ala to purge utensils that had been
used with forbidden food (Bamidbar, chapter 31). Hence, as the Torah explicitly mentions
Hag’ala, we must find a different reason for why a Beracha is not recited over
Hag’ala. These Rabbis explain that a
Beracha isn’t recited because it is not necessary to purge the utensil of the
taste of forbidden food. One can use a
different utensil, or purchase a new utensil, rather than perform Hag’ala on
the pot that had been used with non-kosher food. Since Hag’ala is not necessary, it is not
considered significant enough to warrant a Beracha.
Others
question the first approach by noting the example of a Nidda, who recites a
Beracha over her immersion. In this
case, too, no Halachic obligation is being fulfilled, and the act is performed
only to avoid a violation (in this case, intimate relations with a Nidda). The answer given is that in the case of a
Nidda, the woman’s status is being transformed from forbidden to permissible;
the immersion has the effect of making her permissible. By contrast, when one performs Hag’ala,
nothing is being transformed. The
forbidden taste is being removed from the utensil so it will not affect the
food which will later be prepared in the utensil, but nothing is having its
status transformed from forbidden to permissible, as a Nidda’s status is
changed. (This is true also of Nikur,
which involves the removal of the forbidden part of the animal, and not its
transformation into permissible food.)
Therefore, a Nidda’s immersion warrants a Beracha, whereas Hag’ala does
not.
The
Nebela prohibition applies in all times and places, and is binding upon both
men and women. One who eats a Ke’zayit
of meat of a Nebela is liable to Malkut.