The
Torah commands in Parashat Mishpatim (Shemot 23:1), “Lo Tisa Shema Shav” – a
difficult verse which the Sages understood as a prohibition against placing
oneself in a position where he will hear false, misleading information. Specifically, the Torah here commands judges
not to hear one litigant’s arguments when the other litigant is not
present. The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains
that a litigant is more prone to speak untruthfully in the other party’s
absence, because people generally do not have the audacity to speak falsely
about somebody to his face. Therefore,
the Torah forbade judges from hearing a litigant’s arguments when the other
litigant is not present, because the litigant might lie and thereby mislead the
judges to accept his claims.
If
a judge agrees to hear a litigant’s claims in the other’s absence, in violation
of this command, the litigant is forbidden by force of this Biblical command
from presenting his claims until the other litigant arrives.
This
command also introduces the broader prohibition against involving ourselves in
any sort of falsehood. Additionally, the
Sages interpreted this verse as establishing the famous prohibition of Lashon
Ha’ra – speaking or accepting unflattering information about another person.
In
discussing this Misva, the Sefer Ha’hinuch elaborates upon the particular
importance of honesty in Torah life. He
says that dishonesty is “Nit’ab” – “abominable,” adding, “En Dabar Ma’us
Mimenu” – “There is nothing more repulsive than it.” If a person speaks untruthfully, the Sefer
Ha’hinuch writes, then “his home becomes filled with curse.” The Sefer Ha’hinuch explains that “Emet”
(truthfulness) is one of G-d’s qualities, and blessing is attained by those who
follow G-d’s example and live in accordance with His attributes, such as
compassion, kindness and honesty. We bring
upon ourselves G-d’s blessings by acting as He does. Conversely, if a person conducts himself in a
manner that is contrary to G-d’s attributes, he brings upon himself the
opposite of blessing, Heaven forbid.
Therefore, one who engages in falsehood brings, in the Sefer Ha’hinuch’s
words, “the opposite of blessing, the opposite of joy, the opposite of peace,
and the opposite of enjoyment.” And for
this reason, the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, the Torah commands several verses
later (23:7), “Mi’debar Sheker Tirhak” – that we must distance ourselves from
falsehood. Nowhere else does the Torah
command us to “keep a distance” from a specific kind of misconduct. This is said only about falsehood because of
its uniquely grotesque nature. Hence,
the Sefer Ha’hinuch writes, the Torah forbids judges from hearing a litigant’s
claims in the other’s absence, even though the litigant might actually be
speaking the truth, because of the risk that he will speak falsely. This is one example of the Torah’s insistence
on avoiding even the remote possibility of falsehood.
The
Sefer Ha’hinuch further notes that the Gemara repeatedly speaks in praise of
honest judges, and condemns dishonest judges, testifying to the critical
importance of integrity.
This
Misva applies at all times and in all places.
One who transgresses this prohibition is not liable to Malkut, because
this violation is committed verbally, without the performance of an action.
The
broader message of this Misva is that we must always speak honestly and as
accurately as possible. Sometimes people
impulsively state things which they do not actually know to be true. The value of “Emet” demands that we have the
humility to acknowledge what we do not know, and to ensure to speak the precise
truth at all times.