A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Kelim 5-11

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
July 7, 2026
Duration
11:13
Lecture code
RJD-MKELIM-5-11

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We’ve been talking about ovens and a kirah (stove) made from earthenware. Now we’ll talk about ovens and kirot made from stone and metal. The Mishnah says, “An oven made from stone or metal is tahor (pure).” If it’s made of stone, it’s entirely tahor because stone does not have the ability to become tameh (ritually impure). If it’s a metal oven, it does not become tameh in the same way that an earthenware oven normally does. An earthenware oven becomes tameh if a source of tum’ah (ritual impurity) touches it or enters its airspace, but it does not become tameh from something that touches its outside. So how is that different from a kli matechet (metal utensil)? A metal utensil becomes tameh in the normal way a metal utensil becomes tameh, according to the rules that a metal oven becomes tameh when touched, even on the outside. Metal utensils become tameh, but they do not become tameh through the airspace the way an earthenware oven normally does. So there are different laws for metal. Even touching metal on the outside would make it tameh, but the airspace would not. There’s also a special law that an oven becomes tameh when it’s attached to the ground. That applies only to earthenware ovens, not to ones made of stone and metal. Stone ovens do not become tameh whatsoever, and metal ovens become tameh only when they are not attached to the ground. The law that a tameh oven becomes tahor only by being broken, as we’ve also been talking about, applies only to earthenware ovens. Metal ovens can become tahor by being dipped in a mikveh (ritual bath). When the Torah tells us about tameh ovens, it’s always talking about earthenware ovens. So what the Mishnah is coming to say is that stone and metal have a different law from the ovens the Torah is talking about. They become tameh only through the general laws of kelim (vessels). They don’t have the special stipulations of ovens, where they become exceptions to the rules. So stone ovens do not become tameh whatsoever. Metal ovens become tameh like a regular metal utensil.

Now we’ll talk about a case where even stone and metal ovens become tameh like a regular earthenware oven. These would be exceptions. Nikav, nifgam, nisdak: if a stone or metal oven has a hole in the wall, a piece has broken off the top, or there is a crack running down its whole length, and the owner makes a clay coating around it to seal the whole crack or damaged part, or adds clay to the top of the oven to fix the damaged top, the oven becomes tameh like an earthenware oven. The oven cannot function when it has a hole or a crack, and the clay on it gives it the ability to be used as an oven again. Therefore, the clay is the decider. Therefore, it now becomes like a clay oven. Once it’s heated to the required temperature, at that point it’s considered to be like an earthenware oven itself. Even if he doesn’t coat the entire metal or stone oven with clay, if the clay covers the cracks and makes it usable, it is considered so fundamental to the oven that it takes on the laws of an earthenware oven.

How big does the hole have to be to apply the din (law) we just mentioned? How much does the hole have to measure? How large does the hole in this type of metal or stone oven have to be for sealing it with clay to turn it into an earthenware utensil? We say it has to be large enough for the flame of the oven to escape through it. This type of hole has to be big enough for a lot of heat to escape. If the flame shoots through this hole, the oven loses so much heat that it can’t work whatsoever, and it’s not considered to be an oven. Sealing that type of hole with clay would bring back the use of the oven. Therefore, the clay makes it usable again, and we treat it like a regular earthenware oven.

We’ll learn that stone or metal kirot have the same law as ovens made from these materials. If a kirah has a hole and the hole is repaired with clay, then the stone or metal kirah is not treated like an earthenware kirah, as we just spoke about. Now we’ll talk about how large a hole this has to be in a kirah. Vechen ba-kirah, the same hole is true for a kirah. If a kirah has a hole large enough for a flame to escape through it, and then you seal up that hole with clay, the stone or metal kirah is now treated as an earthenware utensil as well.

Now we’ll talk about a metal or stone kirah, which follows the same laws we’ve been mentioning for a regular oven, with one exception, one difference. Kirah shel even veshel matechet tehorah. A kirah made of stone or metal is pure. A stone kirah cannot become tameh whatsoever. Stone utensils don’t become tameh. A metal kirah does not become tameh in the normal way a regular earthenware kirah would become tameh. But a metal kirah becomes tameh the way a regular metal utensil does. As we said earlier, a metal kirah becomes tameh, like a regular oven or regular metal utensils, by being touched by tum’ah, even on the outside, but it does not become tameh through something entering its airspace the way a kirah made of earthenware would.

If a hole develops, a piece breaks off, or the kirah becomes cracked, and the damage is on the bottom so that the kirah can’t rest on the ground normally, then if the owner made feet for it—little earthenware legs under the kirah to hold it up—the kirah is then tameh as an earthenware utensil. The kirah can’t be used if it isn’t supported by these feet. So the little feet made on the bottom are essential. They are fundamental and make the kirah usable. The entire kirah is now treated like an earthenware utensil.

The same dinim (laws). A kirah has to be in an upright position for the pots on top of it to sit and cook. If the bottom is broken or cracked, the whole kirah will be tilted, and nothing could rest on top. If a kirah doesn’t have a normal bottom, it won’t be able to cook anything. So what’s being made here—a little tripod on the bottom to hold it normally—eventually enables something to be put on top and cooked there.

This law applies only when the hole is on the bottom of the kirah. If the hole is on the side, repairing it with clay would not make it an earthenware utensil, a kirah used to cook pots placed on top of it. The kirah itself doesn’t have to be extremely hot for the cooking to get done. As long as the fire burns beneath the pot, it doesn’t matter if the sides are open; the pot will get hot. So a hole on the side that allows heat to escape wouldn’t be a me’akev. It wouldn’t be such a problem that, if we fixed it with clay, it would then be considered earthenware. We don’t have to say that.

Even if there’s a hole on the side, the pots on top will cook. But a tanur (oven), on the other hand, is used to bake bread. The bread is baked inside, on the walls of the tanur. To get this done, you have to have an oven that is very hot. A large hole would make that problematic; it would prevent the oven from getting hot. That’s why the clay becomes so fundamental. If you seal up the hole with clay, the oven can again be used for baking bread, and that’s why sealing up a tanur with clay would give it the din of a kli cheres, of an earthenware oven. But if you sealed up the kirah with clay, it wouldn’t really improve it that much, so we would not treat it that way. So here we’re specifying that this applies only if you fix the base when there was a crack on the bottom.

Now we’ll talk about an undamaged stone or metal kirah that was coated with clay. If he spread clay over a stone or metal kirah that was not damaged, whether he spread it on the inside or the outside, the kirah does not become tameh like an earthenware oven. The kirah here is made of stone, and therefore it’s entirely tahor. If it’s made of metal, it’s tameh according to the rules for metal utensils. The fact that he puts clay over it doesn’t really change much about the cooking normally done with a kirah. As we said, pots are put on top of it. The fire is underneath; the heat comes from the fire, not from the walls of the kirah. So the coating doesn’t really make a difference to the kirah.

In the previous case, where the kirah was damaged and clay was used to fix it, the clay does change the status of these ovens because it’s what made the kirah functional again by putting feet on the bottom of it. If you have a stone or metal kirah coated with clay, we treat it as an earthenware oven. We’re talking about an oven there because the bread is baked on the inside of the walls, and those walls have to be very hot. The clay coating increases it to a whole new level and allows it to bake. For this reason, we treat it like an earthenware oven.

So we have to be very specific about what we’re talking about. There’s a tanur, a kirah, and utensils, and for each one, because they function differently, the halacha (law) deviates in a small way. Rabbi Yehuda says that if the clay coating was put on the inside of the kirah, the kirah becomes tameh like an earthenware utensil. But if the clay coating was put on the outside of the kirah, the kirah is tahor from the possible tum’ah of earthenware utensils. According to Rabbi Yehuda, the clay on the inside is effective. The kirah then becomes like an earthenware kirah, and therefore becomes tameh according to those rules. But if the coating was on the outside of the kirah, the kirah is tahor from the tum’ah of kli cheres, and therefore it’s not considered to be like an earthenware utensil.