A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Marriage Series 18: I Don't Aprove Of My Spouses Friends

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
January 13, 2025
Duration
8:41
Lecture code
sb-18

First Distinguish Danger from Dislike

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says to pause and clarify what “a bad influence” means rather than dismissing a spouse’s friends without examining the concern.
  • A genuinely dangerous influence could involve drugs, alcohol, or going to places the couple considers unacceptable. The concern is different if the friends are influencing the spouse toward dangerous or unhealthy behavior.
  • If the situation is clearly dangerous—not merely dangerous in one spouse’s opinion—and unhealthy for the spouse, or for the other spouse or children, Rabbi Ali Cohen advises speaking to a rabbi right away. Consult the spouse’s rabbi or another competent rabbi, explain the situation, and ask how to proceed or whether the rabbi can speak with the spouse. The rabbi may help or guide the couple to a professional therapist.
  • If there is no danger, the concern may instead be personal dislike: for example, the friends’ language, lifestyle, lavishness, attitude, habits, clothing, hairstyle, or cars, or a perceived change in the spouse’s attitude. Rabbi Ali Cohen’s discussion focuses on this non-dangerous situation.

Respect a Spouse’s Individuality and Choices

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen stresses that a spouse should not tell the other how to live, operate, eat, sleep, dress, earn a living, whom to talk to, or whom to befriend.
  • A spouse’s choices remain their own, provided they are not directly harming the other through nasty or hurtful words or emotional and psychological attacks. A spouse’s friends and ordinary activities are not the other person’s to control.
  • Parents may tell children what they approve of while the children are growing up; that authority does not mean one spouse controls another.
  • Trying to dictate a spouse’s friendships can damage their individuality and autonomy, leaving them stifled or afraid and potentially creating a situation where they feel they need to lie. Rabbi Ali Cohen says he is not condoning or justifying lying, but describing what control can lead to. It can also create a rift in the relationship, even if the controlling spouse believes avoiding those friends will improve things.
  • Rabbi Ali Cohen shares a joke he heard from Rabbi Shimon Gruen: a newly married couple were told they would become “one.” When they later sought help with their problems, they said they were still unsure which one they were going to be. The point is that marriage does not require either person to merge into the other’s way of thinking or operating. Each remains an individual, and the couple works together as a unit while retaining their individuality.

How to Raise the Concern

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says a spouse has a right to express what is on their mind, but phrases such as “I don’t allow you” or “I don’t approve of your friends” are wrong and not how mature adults should speak to one another.
  • Instead, approach the spouse gently: explain that you want to discuss something on your mind, that you are concerned about the friends and about your spouse, and that it remains your spouse’s decision whether to continue the friendship.
  • Be specific about the concern. Saying only “I don’t like them” or “I get a bad feeling” leaves the spouse unable to understand or assess the concern. If the reason is unclear, take time to think it through and identify what, concretely, is troubling you.
  • Once you can name the concern, explain what the friends do and why you worry it might affect your spouse. Make clear that you are expressing concern, not issuing an order.
  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says this is the most—and the best—you can do. He notes that spouses generally want to make one another happy and may think seriously about a concern once they hear it. Controlling them instead can make them defensive: the issue becomes feeling stifled and being told what to do, rather than considering the concern or trying to make their spouse happy.

Prayer and Guidance

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen encourages praying to Hashem for clarity, guidance toward the right people, and help in opening up the situation; he says he has seen many miracles.