Welcome back, everyone, to the iTorah Marriage Series with Rabbi Ali Cohen. Call 917-837-0102 if you’d like to make a session or ask me a marriage-related question. Or email me: alcohen, A-L-C-O-H-E-N-A-L-E-V-T-O-R-A-H.org. I’ll be glad to help you, with Hashem’s help.
If you’ve been following me, you probably have an idea where I’m going to go with this question today. But questions that come up in real life, in real time, bring the message home much more clearly. Someone asked me recently—and many people ask this or mention it in conversation. I’m reading off of a question: “My spouse has friends who are a bad influence. How do I get them to stop?” Or people ask, “What do I do about the situation?”
Before I get into what to do, how to approach it, and what the correct outlook is, it’s important to analyze situations and not be haphazard about it, just saying, “Oh, I don’t like those friends. I don’t like them. They’re a bad influence.” First and foremost, think for a little bit, step back, and say, “Okay, I don’t like these friends. They’re a bad influence. What do you mean by a bad influence?”
Does “a bad influence” mean that they’re doing drugs and alcohol and going to places that are unacceptable for us to go to? Is that what you mean by a bad influence—that they’re influencing your husband or your wife to do bad things, like the things I just mentioned: drugs, alcohol, and other things? Or do you just not like them—the language they use, the lifestyle they live, a more lavish lifestyle, their attitude, their habits, or the way they dress? It’s important to understand and think about what you don’t like.
The question, and the entire conversation, is different if it’s something dangerous. This is really before we get started: if it’s dangerous, exactly like I mentioned, and something unhealthy for your spouse—and, of course, if it’s unhealthy for you and the kids—you need to speak to a rabbi right away. This is not something that anyone in a class can answer, or that you should go and read up about this and get some advice.
If your spouse is doing something clearly dangerous, and it’s clear to everyone that it’s dangerous—not only your opinion—then you need to speak to his or her rabbi, or to a rabbi who is competent, and say, “Hey, what do I do in this situation? My spouse is doing something dangerous. Could you speak to them? How should I proceed? What do I do?” The rabbi surely would be able to help you or guide you to a professional therapist or something like that. That’s just for starters.
Now, if you realize, no, they’re not doing something dangerous, and it falls under the other category—“I just don’t like them for whatever reasons”—why? And you consider a bad influence, it’s just not himself. She’s just not herself. You know, the change in attitude and things, the dress and the cars, like I mentioned—whatever it is, the hairstyle. It’s not dangerous. I don’t like it. That’s dangerous. That’s really the question I’m going to address today.
Step number one, or point number one, is that nobody should be telling their spouse how to live. This is very, very important. I want this message to get out there. Nobody should be telling their spouse how to operate, how to eat, how to sleep, how to dress, or who to hang out with. That’s part of who they are: their choice of friends.
Again, I’m being very clear about this. Of course, if it’s not dangerous, their choice of friends and whatever they like to do are their choices, so long as they’re not hurting you directly by saying nasty things or hurtful words to you—you know, emotional and psychological attacks, whatever that might be. I don’t want to go into that. But the way they operate, the way they make a living, and the people they talk to are not your department, or anyone’s department, to tell them, “Don’t do this.” That stopped at childhood. Once they got to a certain age, parents tell their children what they approve of and what they don’t. A spouse does not control them.
I mention this very often, but in this situation, I tell people: stop telling your spouse who to hang out with, who to hang around, who to talk to, and that you don’t allow them to do that. That’s extremely, extremely damaging to a person’s individuality and autonomy. It makes them stifled. It makes them either stifled and scared of you, because that’s not much of a relationship. It makes them scared of you. It could put them in a situation where they need to lie. I’m not condoning or justifying lying. I’m just saying what happens. And it makes a rift in the relationship, even though you feel like, “Once they stay away from those friends, we’ll be better off.”
That’s very, very important, and I have many classes on this at length. There’s a joke I heard from Rabbi Shimon Gruen, who talks about these topics at length. A couple got married, and they said, “You’re going to be one. That’s it. You’re both going to be one.” After a while, they were complaining that they were having trouble, so they talked it over with somebody. They were asked, “What’s your main issue?” They said, “We’re told we’re going to be one, and we’re still unsure which one we’re going to be.”
The joke is that you don’t just blend into the other person’s way of operating or way of thinking. No, you still stay an individual—you stay who you are. Now you’re coming together to work together, to operate as a unit, and to keep the individuality that you have while working together with someone else who has their own individuality. That is the way it should be.
Now, the question really was, “What should you do?” or “How do you proceed?” The only thing that I believe you can do in this situation—and not only can you do it, you have a right to do it—is mention what’s on your mind. Of course, anybody can mention what’s on their mind. Like I said, to say, “I don’t approve,” is wrong. To say, “I don’t allow you,” is wrong. To say, “I don’t approve of your friends”—that’s apparent. That’s just wrong. This is not how mature adults should talk to each other.
What you can do, and what actually works far more than telling someone what to do, is approach it gently. “I want to talk about something that’s on my mind. I’m concerned about these friends. I’m concerned about you. It’s your decision if you’d like to still be friends with them. I would never tell you what to do. I’m concerned about them.” And be specific. Being specific. Many times, we’re not specific. We’re very vague and ambiguous, and our spouse just says, “She doesn’t get it,” or, “He doesn’t get it,” because you’re not saying anything concrete.
“I just don’t like them.” “Well, what is it you don’t like?” “I don’t know.” “Okay, so if you don’t know, then how am I supposed to know and decide if I like these people or not?” “I get a bad feeling.” “Okay, so you have a bad feeling, so I have to stop talking to people because you have a bad feeling?” Be concrete, and think about it. You might not know yourself; you might just feel like they rub you the wrong way. Think about it. “Oh, okay. It’s X, Y, and Z.”
“Okay, I’m very concerned that they do these things, and I would be very concerned about you—that that might happen to you, or whatever the situation is. I don’t want that to rub off on you. I’m concerned. I’m just letting you know that I’m concerned.” That is the most you could do. Actually, it’s the best you can do.
Like I always mention, everyone’s spouse wants to make the other one happy. If they hear from you that something concerns you, they’ll think about it. They’ll actually think about it. People want to make their spouse happy. They don’t want to do things that concern them and make them unhappy. The other way, controlling people, makes them defensive, and emotions get involved. Now it’s not even a matter of making you happy or doing the right thing. It’s a matter of, “Don’t tell me what to do. I feel stifled.”
There’s a lot to talk about. Think about this. Like I said, you could email me. And, like I always say, you have to pray to Hashem. Hashem is the one who is going to give you clarity, guide you to the right people, and open up the situation in a way that I see all the time. So many miracles. Don’t forget to pray to Hashem. Be sure to have a wonderful relationship.