A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Marriage Series 21: The Number One Thing Plaguing Marriages

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
March 8, 2025
Duration
7:31
Lecture code
sb-21

Control as a Major Source of Marital Trouble

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen says control is a central problem in marriages that are falling apart or in a bad place. He has discussed it many times, but says people—including professionals and rabbis—often find his approach new, and he wants people to become familiar with the issue.
  • He sees control in 9 out of 10 calls he receives. It can mean telling a spouse what to do, what not to do, and when to do it.
  • Control can also be conveyed through attitude or implication—for example, remarks about a spouse going somewhere, eating a certain way, staying out late, or speaking to their mother. It can be manipulative, subconscious, and not necessarily intentional: if a remark deters someone from doing something or pressures them to behave against their wishes, Rabbi Cohen considers it a form of control.
  • Control can be overt or indirect, including the silent treatment, coldness, or refusing to communicate while saying, “You do your thing.” Rabbi Cohen calls the silent treatment “torture” and describes it as cruel and unusual punishment.
  • A client stopped using the silent treatment after Rabbi Cohen confronted him about it; the change, he says, drastically improved the marriage.

Two Adults and Their Individuality

  • Rabbi Cohen emphasizes that marriage involves two adults, and neither should dictate the other’s behavior when that behavior is normal.
  • He gives clothing as an example: spouses should not control what the other wears. He jokes about a clown hat or suit, saying that even then they would need to talk about how to address it. Controlling what a spouse wears or eats is wrong and unhealthy for the relationship.
  • A controlled spouse may feel compelled to work around the other person—wondering whether to lie or finding ways to wear, eat, or discuss what they want. Rabbi Cohen says this is not a good relationship dynamic.
  • Spouses should retain their individuality. Decisions that need to be made together—such as how to raise children, where to live, or where to go for Shabbat—should be discussed rather than dictated by one person.
  • He rejects unilateral claims of authority, such as a husband saying, “I’m the boss,” or someone invoking “Happy wife, happy life” to justify control.
  • As an example, he recounts a wife telling her husband that she was in charge of the house, including the children, and that he had no right to decide what happened there. She told him to ask his friends what was right. Rabbi Cohen calls this immature and childish.

Recognizing the Pattern and Seeking Help

  • The first step is recognizing whether control is happening in the marriage, whether one is doing it or experiencing it. If it is not happening, Rabbi Cohen says, one is fortunate.
  • If it is happening, a person can seek help to stop controlling their spouse or to address a spouse’s controlling behavior. Rabbi Cohen says help is available, including support for getting the behavior under control and working with a spouse; even a complicated spouse may be willing to work together if the person is willing to do so.
  • He warns that controlling people may hear a lesson about control selectively: someone who controls 80% of the marriage may point to the other 20% and claim to be controlled, using the message to try to dominate the entire relationship. Meanwhile, the spouse who has been allowing the control may interpret the lesson as a reason to give up even more.
  • If it is unclear whether one spouse, the other, or both are controlling, Rabbi Cohen strongly recommends speaking with a third party for an objective opinion, hearing the truth, and getting the marriage in order. He adds that a third party may tell a couple, “You sure have a wonderful relationship.”