A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Parenting Series 13: Be Careful From Bad Parenting Advice

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
February 9, 2025
Duration
9:09
Lecture code
p-13

The Family’s Question and the Advice They Received

  • Rabbi Ali Cohen describes a question about a large frum family whose younger child was causing serious disruption at home: cursing at family members, throwing things, defying the parents, and making the household feel chaotic, while the other children generally behaved well.
  • He says a situation involving a child throwing and smashing things should not be sent to a magazine for a response. A parent seeking help should speak with their Rav and a professional to understand what is happening.
  • He objected to the answer the family received: the respondent was “100% sure” that the parents were at fault and were not treating the child correctly.
  • The advice called for a parenting course, therapy for the child, and therapy for both parents; each parent was also told to identify who had experienced trauma and do trauma work.
  • Rabbi Cohen criticized the certainty of that conclusion before anyone had met with the family. He also noted the potential expense: therapy costing $250 and up, with the proposed separate sessions potentially adding up to about $1,000 per family session and roughly $10,000 over eight weeks. He acknowledged that money should not determine what a family needs to do, but said this was a substantial amount of therapy.

Rabbi Gruen’s Approach and the Sensitive Child

  • Rabbi Cohen says that his approach to parenting and shalom bayit (peace in the home) comes from his training with Rabbi Shimon Gruen.
  • Rather than immediately blaming the parents, he says the central question is why a family could raise seven or eight wonderful children and be struggling with one child. He would need to sit down with the family before reaching conclusions, and calls the child’s situation a major kasha (question).
  • He points to Rabbi Gruen’s concept of the “sensitive child,” which he says is easy to detect, though he does not elaborate on it in this lecture. He notes that Rabbi Gruen has classes, articles, and the book Get Along with Everyone on the subject.

Check the Basics Before Digging Deep

  • Rabbi Cohen warns against drawing conclusions from an email without speaking to the family and putting the relevant facts together. Prescribing four different therapy tracks on that basis, he says, is not a good approach and can be dangerous.
  • His principle is to “check your bases before you dig deep.” As an example, he describes psychiatric evaluations that include a thorough physical examination, which he considers a sensible way to investigate a complaint such as “I don’t feel good” before deciding on an explanation.
  • Before attributing a child’s behavior to trauma or blaming the mother, he says to ask basic questions: What is happening with the child? What is happening at school and at home? What are the sleeping arrangements? How are the siblings treating the child?
  • He cautions against getting into trauma work before checking these matters, particularly when doing so could affect Kibbud Av va'Em (honoring one's father and mother).
  • He applies the same principle to school: if a student falls asleep in class every day, a Rebbe (teacher/rabbi) should first check practical factors—such as whether the student is eating, what is happening at home, and whether the child has cocoa before school—rather than immediately concluding that the student is depressed.

Closing Guidance

  • Rabbi Cohen urges people to be wise and pray to Hashem for guidance.
  • He concludes with the principle, “Bederech she'adam rotzeh leilech molichin oto” (In the way a person wishes to go, they lead him).