A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ali Cohen

Torah Lecture

Parenting Series 13: Be Careful From Bad Parenting Advice

Lectured by Rabbi Ali Cohen

Published
February 9, 2025
Duration
9:09
Lecture code
p-13

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome back, everyone, to the Parenting Series with Rabbi Eli Cohen. I want to talk about a question that I just saw somewhere. I don't really need to get into the details of where or who, and I don't need to get involved with that. But I saw a question that was asked, and I did not like the answer. I didn't think it was fair to the readers to be misled on this concept. I feel like the real Torah, Hashkafah (worldview), needs to be said about this concept.

It was a very simple question. I mean, it turned into a monster. The question was very simple. Somebody has a large, frum (religious) family, and one of the children—a younger child, leaving out all the details—is basically wreaking havoc on the family. In a religious family, a child curses at everyone, throws things at everyone, defies the parents, and is just really a terror in the house. The other children behave well, I guess, for the most part. I'm just saying. I'm just saying what I heard, what I read.

And this person said, “What do we do?” Now, obviously, before I get started, I hope this is not too lengthy, but if you're dealing with something like that, I don't believe anyone should be sending it into a publication, to any magazine. I know the magazines are there. They do have panelists who are very reputable. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I'm aware of that. But sending something to a publication means some kind of response. Meaning, if you're sending a letter to one of those panelists individually, then you're looking for help. But if you're sending it to this magazine, which has people who know their stuff, and you're dealing with a kid throwing things around the house, smashing things, and cursing from home, I mean, you've got to get professional help. Hell, you've got to go straight—I don't know—talk to your Rav and talk to a professional and see what's happening. So that's not okay. That's an important piece of advice.

But the answer was just appalling. It was appalling. The answer was that—and I don't have it in front of me, and that doesn't really matter—the person answering the question said, “I'm 100% sure and guaranteed that it's the parents' fault, and that the parents are not treating this child correctly. And that's why all this is happening.” That was it.

So the advice was that the parents need to go to a parenting course, the child needs to go to therapy, and the parents need to have therapy as well. On top of the parents' therapy, the parents need, individually, to figure out—whichever one it is—who is the one suffering the trauma. They have to do trauma work. So, number one, there was a guarantee before anything was even, like, a discussion with the family. Number two, you just set up four separate therapy sessions. Therapy these days is $250 and up. You're looking at one, you're looking at four. Yeah, $200, do the math. You're about a grand per family session. Let's say they need to go for eight weeks. You're looking at $10,000 in two months. That's just for starters. I mean, yeah, I know we don't base anything on money. You have to do what you have to do for your family. But it's a lot of therapy. It's just a lot. I'm just putting that out there.

The next thing is the guarantee, which really irked me. But in any event, the way that I see it, again, people are entitled to their opinion. This person is a professional. They have their opinion. I deal with parenting and shalom bayit (peace in the home); that's what I do for a living. So this is the way I see it. I was trained by my great rabbi, Rabbi Shimon Gruen. And anybody who knows him knows what I'm going to say. If you knew him, you knew what the answer was before that. The burning question, the glaring question, is not on the parents. The question is: Why did they raise such beautiful children? Seven, eight children, and one they're struggling with. Why? Why is that happening?

So now, of course, like I said in the beginning, I would need to sit down and talk to them and see what's happening. And I'm sure I would meet the most ehrliche (upright) people I've ever met, who raised eight, nine, seven, eight wonderful children who never had such a thing. But that's a major kasha (question). It's a major kasha. And the kasha is on the child. What's wrong with this child is the kasha.

So there's an approach that I mention often, and I didn't get this on my own; it's Rabbi Gruen's approach: there's something called a sensitive child. And a sensitive child is very easy to detect. I really don't want to go into the whole sensitive-child concept. But I have classes on the sensitive child. He has multiple classes on the sensitive child. He has a book, Get Along with Everyone, about the sensitive child, and tons of articles. I have tons on it. I mean, if you want more, you can email me at alcohen at levtorah—A-L-C-O-H-E-N at levtorah, L-E-V-T-O-R-A-H dot org.

But we have to be very careful. We have to be very careful, because that's a balagan (mess). That whole thing of taking somebody's email without talking to them, without sitting down with them, and without putting these pieces together—that every child is good except for this one—and throwing them into four different therapy sessions is just not a great thing. It's dangerous. It's a dangerous thing.

I mention this in many of my classes. It's one of my own concepts: we've got to check your bases before you dig deep. You've got to check your bases before you dig deep. If anyone actually used to do this, I don't know if they do this anymore. I know they used to do this a long time ago. I used to do this maybe 25 years ago. Somebody goes to a psychiatrist for an evaluation, or it could be that there's specific ones that do it. They do a full-on physical. I know for sure there are certain doctors that still do it. I don't know if it used to be standard practice. They do a full-on physical. And that's brilliant.

That's the way that it should be. Someone comes in and says, “I don't feel good. I don't know why.” Get the blood work out there. Cover your bases before you say, “A trauma—that's the mother.” I mean, you're dabbling and messing around with Kibbud Av va'Em (honoring one's father and mother) before you got into the basics. What's going on with the kid? What's going on in school? What's going on in the house? What are the sleeping arrangements? I don't know. I don't know. What's with the siblings? How are they treating her? There are so many basic questions and so many bases that need to be covered before we trauma work it.

And this is really a rule for a lot of things. We've got to check our simple, simple things. I'm a schoolteacher. I'm a Rebbe (teacher/rabbi). And when someone's coming into class, every Rebbe knows this. Someone's coming in sleeping every day. Then you talk to the principal right away. Is he eating? Is he not eating? What's he doing at home? Is he having some cocoa before he comes in? The basics, the basics are covered before: “Oh, he's sleeping depressed.” It's got to stop. It's got to stop.

So let's just think about this. Be wise. Pray to Hashem. Hashem will guide you to the right thing. Bederech she'adam rotzeh leilech molichin oto (In the way a person wishes to go, they lead him).