A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joseph Dana

Torah Lecture

Mishnah Temurah 2-2

Lectured by Rabbi Joseph Dana

Published
February 10, 2026
Duration
6:10
Lecture code
RJD-MTEMURAH-2-2

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Now we'll list other differences between communal and personal korbanot (offerings), specifically the korban chatat (sin-offering). The korban chatat is brought by a person to serve as a kapara, an atonement for certain aveirot (sins). If a person sanctified a certain animal as a korban chatat and then received atonement in another way, the first chatat cannot be offered as a korban, but has to be left to die. For example, let's say a person sanctified a korban chatat because he committed a certain aveirah (sin), and then, before he could bring it to the Beit HaMikdash, he lost that animal. The owner had to get a different animal in its place. Later on, he found the lost korban chatat, but he had already received the kapara he needed through the replacement korban. We say that the first animal cannot be offered on the Mizbeach (altar) and has to be left to die instead.

The Mishnah says, as we said, that the personal korban chatat, whose owner already received atonement through a different korban chatat, has to be left to die. The shel tzibbur einan metot (Communal sin-offerings do not die). But the korban chatat of the community, whose owners received atonement through a different korban chatat, is not left to die. Rather, we allow them to wander; we allow them to graze until they develop a blemish. At that point, they're allowed to be redeemed.

We're talking here about the korban chatat of a musaf offering of Rosh Chodesh, or of the holidays, which was lost and replaced, as we discussed before. When the one that was lost is later found, even though the community already received the kapara they needed, the korban chatat that they found is not left to die. Rather, we let it develop a blemish, and then we redeem it. We use the money from its redemption to buy different korbanot, olot (burnt offerings), to fill the Mizbeach on days when the Mizbeach is not really being used.

According to the Tanna Kamma (first tanna) here, this first chatat yachid (individual) that you allow to die when you have already received kapara is Halacha le-Moshe mi-Sinai, a law taught to Moshe Rabbeinu that was passed down throughout the generations. Rabbi Yehuda omer, yamutu (says: they shall die). Rabbi Yehuda says that a communal chatat also has to be left to die. In that same story, if there was a communal korban chatat that was supposed to be offered, it got lost, they brought a different korban instead, and then they found the first korban, according to Rabbi Yehuda, that one also has to be left to die. He disagrees with the Tanna Kamma, who said that you don't have to make it die; you can let it develop a blemish and redeem it. Rabbi Yehuda would also say this is Halacha le-Moshe mi-Sinai, a law that we learned from Sinai.

Rabbi Shimon is now going to bring support for the Tanna Kamma's view that a communal korban chatat is not left to die. We know that the law that a chatat has to be left to die is stated with regard to five different chataot, five different types of situations. Mah matzinu b'velad chatat (What do we find with the offspring of a sin-offering?). We know that one of the korbanot in that group that has to be left to die is the offspring of the chatat. If a female chatat became pregnant after it was holy and then gave birth, the offspring is considered to have the same holiness as its mother, but it can't be offered as a korban chatat because it wasn't sanctified to atone for the owner's sin. So we let it die.

The first one mentioned among those that have to be left to die was referring to the personal korban chatat, but not the communal chatat. The three cases that we mentioned aren't possible with a community korban. They're all talking about individual cases. So too, when it comes to the other two chataot that are left to die, one is the korban chatat whose year has passed. The sheep and goats used as korbanot for the chatat all have to be less than one year old. If an animal was designated as a korban chatat while it was less than one year old and the owner didn't offer it until it was past one year, it can't be offered anymore; it has to be left to die.

So what Rabbi Shimon is doing is extrapolating: of the five cases that we know have to be left to die, three are possible only with the korban yachid of an individual. Rabbi Shimon is saying, ah, so too with the other two korbanot of the chatat that are mentioned as being left to die. Even though these two could possibly be a korban of the tzibbur—the case where the owner already received a chatat, possibly a yachid's or the tzibbur's, or the korban chatat whose year is already over—since the other three are possible only with the yachid, Rabbi Shimon is saying that the law for these two was also stated only with regard to the personal chatat, and not to the chatat of the tzibbur.